Scorecard · Independent comparison · November 18, 2026
Which proposal best fits your priorities?
Scenario 1 moves the fewest pupils between school areas. Scenario 2 gives Hardin Valley the most immediate relief. Scenario 3 keeps more elementary peers together into middle school and gives A.L. Lotts a path out of portables. The weights below let you decide how much each outcome matters.
Scores out of 100
The starting weights give 50 points to household moves, feeder continuity and portables, 15 to traffic and 35 to capacity and growth. These are suggested community priorities. KCS has issued no score or endorsement of this model.
What goes into each score?
Change any weight. The model divides each weight by the sum so the total available stays at 100 points. Each cell shows the input and the points it earns.
| Outcome | Weight | Scenario 1 | Scenario 2 | Scenario 3 |
|---|
What happens after opening?
By 2030, KCS projects 966 pupils at Hardin Valley in Scenario 1 and 905 in Scenario 2, both above its 80% planning level of 812 whole pupils. Scenario 3 keeps the Hardin Valley zone intact. KCS omitted its 2030 enrollment in that scenario. Scenario 1 reserves 90 places at the new school below 80%. Scenarios 2 and 3 exceed that benchmark there. District projections, slides 14, 19 and 25
Scenarios 2 and 3 leave room for 182 and 188 pupils respectively at Northshore below the 80% benchmark in 2030. Scenario 3 also leaves 64 at Lotts. None of the three draws new lines for Rocky Hill, Bearden or Sequoyah. If eastern need in 2030 equaled the four schools’ 2026 map labels totaling 288, the Scenario 3 model could accommodate 252 at Northshore and Lotts. Getting those places to the schools that need them would require at least 566 additional pupil reassignments across adjacent boundaries in that exercise. They could involve different children at each step. Corridor model and alternative assumptions
How the model awards points
- Moving pupils
- The three Farragut campuses count as one area. Moves between Farragut and other areas, and between Lotts and Northshore, count. Estimates use current enrollment and dwelling types. Actual enrolled children by address and grade would improve the comparison. Within-area campus changes still matter for classrooms and travel. Switch address-count definitions
- Continuity and portables
- The peer measure averages the share of elementary peers feeding the same middle school over 40,981 mapped addresses, using each actual campus. Today’s baseline is 75.8%. Portable points go to the proposal KCS says eliminates the need at Lotts. All three address Farragut Primary and Intermediate portables. Classroom counts and removal dates remain open. Explore feeders by school · KCS portable comparison
- Traffic
- For each group in a named subdivision, we compared its modeled parent-car route today and under each proposal. A location counts when a route passes within 75 metres of the Boyd Station railroad crossing or the Concord/Northshore roundabout. An address counts once if its trip adds either location and once if it avoids either. Changing from one to the other can count in both columns. The common sample covers 38,192 addresses, with equal weight for the two current Farragut grade bands. Added exposure is 0, 3,267 and 2,332 address-weighted routes. Avoided exposure is 0, 2,510 and 2,510. This is a two-location test of possible route changes. School-hour volumes, buses, queues, work zones and other bottlenecks require separate evidence. Traffic study area
- Hardin Valley and western capacity
- Immediate relief uses the estimated number of current Hardin Valley pupils whose elementary zone changes. The western reserve uses available 2030 places at the new campus up to 80%. Each earns a fraction of the largest positive value among the drafts. A school forecast above 80% earns zero reserve points. KCS forecast
- Eastern capacity
- Each usable place at Northshore earns 1/288 of the eastern weight, up to the full weight. The denominator uses current Blue Grass, Rocky Hill, Bearden and Sequoyah pressure as a test. A common eastern 2030 forecast is missing. Scenario 1’s -24 is conditional on the combined Scenario 1 and 2 areas having equal projected enrollment. KCS omitted the Northshore row for Scenario 1. Set the eastern weight to zero to drop this assumption. Credit covers potential receiving space. Actual relief needs another public boundary decision. Derivation and limitations
- Reading the totals
- For moves, continuity and route exposure, the best of these three values earns the full criterion weight, the least favorable earns zero, and intermediate values earn a proportional share. Lotts portable relief earns all or none. Scores compare the three drafts. A change in assumptions or in the set of options can change the ranking. Movement and Hardin Valley relief reflect opposite effects of some of the same reassignments.