[00:00:00] Q&A. So I will say this about Q&A. We've got two mics down here at the front. Please feel free to [00:00:08] come down if you have questions. Our goal for Q&A is to answer questions, provide clarity, [00:00:14] let you all know something that doesn't make sense, give us an opportunity to explain that. [00:00:20] If you get to a place of wanting to share feedback, we're happy to hear that, but we need [00:00:25] the feedback in the survey to be able to apply it. So please know that you might hear from me a [00:00:31] couple of times tonight, that sounds great, really appreciate your insight, please put it in the [00:00:37] survey. And I genuinely do mean please put it in the survey. So with that, we're going to go ahead [00:00:42] and get started. This is the popular mic, apparently. Good evening. I was also at Tuesday's [00:00:49] meeting, so I've seen this presentation, and I'm going to be honest, I don't like the presentations, [00:00:53] the scenarios, any more than I did. [00:00:55] Tuesday. When I asked questions on Tuesday and shared some of my concerns, I was given answers [00:01:01] that I don't think were truthful. I specifically asked what would happen to the schools in scenarios [00:01:05] two and three when North Shore, Farragut Intermediate, Farragut Primary, and Hardin Valley [00:01:11] and AL Lots, depending on the scenario, dropped below 800 in enrollment. I re-watched the videos [00:01:17] on YouTube. Thank you, Brian, for posting those, because I have yet to find them on Knox County's [00:01:25] website. I think you would want to get those up sooner, since you have five business days to decide [00:01:28] which proposal you're going to submit. And I think you would want the community to be able to see them [00:01:32] sooner than later. So I re-watched and I heard for a second time that my questions were not answered [00:01:38] and that the positions would not be affected, and that's not the case. Off the bat, having below 800 [00:01:45] kids would eliminate the need for one guidance counselor and one assistant principal at each of [00:01:49] those schools. And assuming that the new elementary school has two, that would still be eliminating [00:01:55] overall assistant principal positions and guidance counselor positions from this set of schools. [00:02:00] Not to mention when the student numbers drop based on zoning, that is going to reduce the [00:02:05] number of teachers, SPEDs, SPED TAs, TAs, and possible school nurses. And when deciding on [00:02:10] these numbers allocated at each school, it's based off of zoning and not the transfers, [00:02:15] and the transfer numbers will not be available until after the staffing window closes. [00:02:21] Also, has it been confirmed that the portables, [00:02:25] the free portables, are being removed from Farragut Intermediate and Farragut Primary school? [00:02:30] So the portables will be removed um I don't know if we have a timeline on that. [00:02:34] Okay, we don't have a timeline, but we can confirm that both Farragut Primary and Farragut [00:02:38] Intermediate, those portables will be removed. I can also say that in any transfer situation, [00:02:44] or any rezoning situation, we would hold on that staffing, that final staffing allocation, [00:02:50] until we have the transfer numbers in. [00:02:52] So staffing would follow. [00:02:55] the mapped and projected enrollment but also the locked-in transfers for students who take [00:03:00] advantage of that opportunity um the video should be up on the website and i am looking for my team [00:03:08] to confirm that i will have confirmation number mattress can it keep me warm when i'm cold [00:03:13] wait no i'm always hot sleep number does that oh that's not my question that does not sound [00:03:19] like a video um but if you will go to the rezoning at knoxschools.org on the website [00:03:24] and select farragut there are two options there you'll see powell at the bottom select farragut [00:03:29] you should see all of these resources as well as videos for this evening um i'm just gonna [00:03:35] keep talking through our music here uh can you remind me what your other question was [00:03:39] so the question was about the portables being removed if the portables are removed from farragut [00:03:43] primary and farragut intermediate school that actually brings their capacity down to 706 and [00:03:49] 558 students and not the 900 that you have in each of them in your scenario [00:03:54] up there so i will say that the 900 on the board is without portables so all of the scenarios [00:04:01] back in 2024 whenever these numbers were first presented i have a picture on my phone of the [00:04:08] totals with portables and without portables absolutely you are correct the reason it's 900 [00:04:13] now has been it reflects the transition to a k-5 school because the staffing ratios for k-2 [00:04:19] are different than the staffing ratios for three five so when we make each one of those buildings [00:04:24] k through five it changes the capacity um it changes the capacity by 250. [00:04:36] it does yes so three five um and that's actually how it happens so three five [00:04:42] is staffed um not quite as richly as k2 so k2 is staffed more richly [00:04:47] so when you mix the grade bands of those two schools the primary school is going to [00:04:54] actually make sure i'm getting this right lose capacity a little bit and the intermediate is [00:04:59] going to gain some capacity as a result sorry that's bad so the combined capacity back in [00:05:05] 2024 puts them both around 900 and you're telling me that now the capacity is increased to be 900 [00:05:12] without the portables but it's because of the new teacher student ratios the math isn't mapping [00:05:19] can i after this meeting can you and i huddle up and can i look at the picture on your phone and can [00:05:24] we right now because i think everybody would probably want to know the answer let's get on [00:05:28] video well i think it's important to this conversation because if these are the actual [00:05:39] numbers and you want to open all three farragut elementary schools below the 80 [00:05:45] threshold we currently have 2036 students enrolled between farragut primary and farragut intermediate [00:05:53] if you take 80 capacity of all three new schools you get two thousand one hundred [00:05:59] and thirty one and that would mean that there's 95 extra seats between all three farragut schools [00:06:05] until you're at that 80 capacity which you're saying for other schools is already too much and [00:06:10] you don't want to be there so farragut is crowded and busting at the seams before it even opens and [00:06:16] you're trying to pull people from other schools in when we're already full so i don't want to do math [00:06:26] um raw because you read off a lot of numbers um and i held on to maybe two of them and i [00:06:31] do not have my phone and i'm not going to trust myself to do this without a calculator what i [00:06:36] will say is that the numbers reflected on the poster here so i'm going to give you some some [00:06:41] context here and then we can compare it so what's here on the poster is the 900 capacity for each of [00:06:49] the two existing farragut schools very good primary very good intermediate that is reflective [00:06:54] of two things so it's reflective of the adjustment for k-5 at each of those sites so the change in [00:07:01] rapid change in grade bands that's a reflection there the other thing that has happened in the [00:07:07] last year and we did talk about this on monday i can't remember which um which meeting you said [00:07:11] you were at tuesday sorry tuesday um the first meetings so um the other thing that has happened [00:07:17] over the course of the last year is that we had a member of the facilities team go out to all 91 [00:07:22] campuses walk all 91 campuses make sure that we had accurate and updated maps of each of our school [00:07:30] footprints so [00:07:31] we have carried maps for years as a district but we also know that we've lived a lot of our [00:07:37] facilities for a very very long time we have walls that have been added we have walls that [00:07:42] have been removed we have instructional spaces that we are using in different ways because we [00:07:48] have programmatic needs in our facilities that maybe they were not at one point in time built [00:07:52] to accommodate and so over the course of this last year we not only walked the facilities [00:07:57] updated our campus maps but we are also applying what we're calling a [00:08:01] programmatic capacity formula that actually adjusts for the programmatic needs of the facility [00:08:07] so it is possible and that was a quick visual and i would very much like to talk to you afterwards [00:08:12] so we can compare numbers it's going to take me and a computer to actually kind of work [00:08:15] backward and try to make sure that you and i are talking from the same place but it is possible [00:08:20] that you are looking at numbers that were generated based on a building capacity model [00:08:25] we're talking about a programmatic capacity model and so the difference there would be what it takes [00:08:31] for students and so that's the difference in the formula that came out of last year compared to [00:08:37] ones that have been used in years past if i had to take a guess right now i would guess that that [00:08:42] discrepancy is a byproduct of that work being done i will also say that the 1400 that you see [00:08:49] for the new school that's programmatic capacity as well so we've got 900 900 1400 so once you [00:08:56] combine those across the board if we're looking at just the map of farragut alone and we're wanting [00:09:01] ourselves to that 80 threshold that would be the three numbers we'd want to add up that would be [00:09:07] the math then that we'd want to reduce down to that 80 threshold and you are right we want health and [00:09:12] wellness to be around that 80 threshold in a perfect world we'd be sitting at 80 across the [00:09:18] district so essentially that's what we're drawing these maps to try to configure right how close can [00:09:25] we get to 80 in all of our communities we're flagging um and you're exactly right in scenario [00:09:31] 81 that 83 coming over the 80 threshold we're not flagging that as a positive right we're flagging [00:09:39] that as a caution to say that's a conversation we need to have as well as a community that's something [00:09:44] we're holding on to and something that we're going to continue to be adjusting as we work toward that [00:09:49] final proposal made to the board so yes absolutely that's something that we are cognizant of and we're [00:09:55] still configuring okay so it sounds like a fancy way of saying that you've reconfigured things to [00:10:00] add more people to make your community more inclusive and that's something that we're [00:10:01] going to continue to do that I think is really important to reflect on and I think [00:10:04] we can talk later but 900 is still not an accurate reflection of how many students both [00:10:09] those schools can hold so if you were to take the numbers then the rest of this would be a moot point [00:10:21] so in my opinion there are far better options than any of them being presented [00:10:27] moving Hardin Valley down just to eventually move them back when a new school is built [00:10:31] because it's inevitable that a new school is going to be built those kids have been disrupted so many [00:10:36] times we've had friends come from hardin valley go back come back again and now we're going to do it [00:10:42] again hardin valley's growing there's no question about it the discussion needs to be how are you [00:10:47] going to build a new school for hardin valley rather than trying to bring them somewhere they [00:10:52] don't want to go just to bring them back here again it's just this constant shuffle and you [00:10:58] talk about the continuity of keeping kids in the same school k through five it's not keeping them [00:11:04] in the same schools by moving them back and forth uh with scenarios two and three sending the [00:11:09] overflow to north shore if needed but don't pull kids from an already established community and [00:11:14] place them into a school that will be over capacity in the next five years because those maximum [00:11:20] capacity numbers are wrong or instead of extending a generous transfer offer to north shore why not [00:11:26] reverse it and let people share it with their friends and family and that's what hardin valley [00:11:28] is going to do is transfer to the new elementary school if they want to come assuming that there's [00:11:32] still room after the new and actual capacity numbers for fps and fis are factored in um no offense [00:11:40] but these scenarios all seem to be very rushed and there were lots of things that weren't included [00:11:46] i don't believe that moving other schools was in the original plan until a few months ago [00:11:52] um considering that the infrastructure and busing concerns weren't taken into consideration before [00:11:57] producing the new elementary schools we're going to have to make sure that the new elementary schools [00:11:58] that we're going to be presenting these proposals it seems as though maybe none of them were ready to [00:12:01] be presented um back to my second question from the other night i feel like the conversion of both [00:12:08] fps and fis were not well planned out the toilet height was just the tip of the iceberg i actually [00:12:14] walked into school today and looked at the bathrooms and all of the sinks are very high [00:12:18] the soap is high the urinals are high um the cafeteria line is two-way where it should be [00:12:25] one way to be compliant with kindergartners so that needs to change so i think it's going to be [00:12:27] to change the stairs i'm actually not sure compliant for anybody because of the size of [00:12:32] the openings and the guard rails and i do also have pictures of all of those [00:12:37] i know that the bathrooms were renovated two and a half years ago with the goal of transitioning [00:12:41] to a k through five so i don't know why more thought wasn't put into what they were going [00:12:45] to look like for when kindergartners actually came both schools are also going to need different [00:12:51] furniture to accommodate new ages there will need to be new signage and new curriculum fps is [00:12:57] wondering how they're going to be supplemented for social studies and science when they've [00:13:01] never had those before and the list goes on is there an actual benefit to students in any of [00:13:07] these scenarios so a couple of things i would say what's exciting to us for the farragut community [00:13:14] will come to infrastructure um and i'm answering first um and that's why i'm going to take what [00:13:19] i feel like is exciting and then i may ask dr adams to come up and talk about the infrastructure [00:13:24] but in terms of what's exciting for the farragut community that conversation we had [00:13:28] three to five years ago about imagining what we want to be true right for farragut primary farragut [00:13:34] intermediate having that longer runway for students it's going to be an adjustment absolutely there [00:13:39] are curricular needs there are resource needs there's going to be that adjustment period of [00:13:44] figuring out what it means to do 3-5 in a former primary space you're going to have that same [00:13:48] adjustment in the intermediate space of figuring out what does it mean to do k2 right on the spot [00:13:53] is very different when you have difficult when you have kindergartners in the building trying to [00:13:58] figure it out in real time and that is why we have confidence in our principals they have known [00:14:03] this transition was coming so part of why we had that conversation in 2024 right was so that we [00:14:09] could start thinking at least about the programmatic needs of students what does it mean [00:14:14] to carry tested grades what does it mean to carry grades that we're building those foundational [00:14:18] skills in now we're going to have students in farragut not in one not in two but three schools [00:14:23] that have six years under the same roof with the same administrator with a team that knows [00:14:28] them with a team that knows their families that's a benefit to families and that is something we're [00:14:33] very very excited about so there are things to be excited about there are challenges for us to carry [00:14:38] but i also know that you all have worked with these school teams for years and you know how [00:14:42] talented they are so we know we're up to that challenge and we know they're going to do a lot [00:14:48] with those kids for that six years that they have them now and so to be able to mitigate that [00:14:52] learning loss that comes with grade band transitions that is something we're excited about [00:14:58] infrastructure is very well put i'm going to look to dr adams just to address a couple of those [00:15:03] because i know he's got a good answer to a couple and essentially we're looking at standardization [00:15:07] across the district thank you miss falkner so all of our schools are to a certain standard right [00:15:14] and they're too cold if you look at a lot of older schools you did have some toilets some sinks that [00:15:20] were smaller that's no longer the case right so when we build new elementary schools k through [00:15:25] five they all look the same they're all to standard [00:15:29] okay um it's not just about that though it's about the curriculum it's about the furniture [00:15:36] it's about resources being provided for them i have full confidence in them as well i work [00:15:41] very close with them i'm the pto president of fps and fis and so for years i've been [00:15:46] very involved in this process of what's coming and we had hoped we would receive more support [00:15:53] and resources from the county than what's been given so typically what we do when we [00:15:58] anytime we build a new school especially in this transition what we're doing we would look at this [00:16:04] three different schools right as they transition to transition to an elementary school we look at [00:16:09] the furnishings we look at signage we will address all of those concerns and those needs at the time [00:16:14] we have a year of actually planning for the new elementary school so that gives us a year to look [00:16:19] at all three different schools i do want to address your concerns as far as the capacity [00:16:23] is concerned if you think about a primary and an intermediate you're missing three grade levels [00:16:28] so think about five additional students for every classroom for every grade level that adds up [00:16:33] pretty quickly so i did want to come back and address that as well but wouldn't at the intermediate [00:16:38] school they have whenever they bring in lower grades they would have a lower student to teacher [00:16:45] ratio and at the primary school it would also be the same and so the primary would get lower [00:16:52] or sorry higher right yeah that is correct and our primary school currently is one of the largest schools we have [00:16:58] in the period as far as elementary the new school of course would be much larger so and i'll also [00:17:04] say just from a curriculum standpoint because that matters right our curriculum is going to [00:17:08] follow those students so schools are not saddled with the need to purchase that curriculum so that [00:17:14] is going to be a commitment from the district students will be resourced we will have the [00:17:18] curricular materials that they need for each and every grade level for each and every subject area [00:17:23] and i'm speaking from a i'm a former principal i'm middle and high but my brother he is the [00:17:28] the principal from very good middle school so he he educates me on the elementary so he's well [00:17:33] versed and so i do have a pretty good understanding of the programming for the elementary schools [00:17:37] um and i did have one more question but the long answers kind of throw me off um [00:17:46] i don't know but we'll just leave it at that um i would still love to see how you came up with [00:17:51] the numbers at some point that the maximum capacity magically grew over two years um [00:17:57] because definitely [00:17:58] after for sure anybody else who is interested in a huddle i just would like to have my computer [00:18:03] with me when we're talking thank you if i may speak at a turn real quick this might help clarify [00:18:08] do you have a definition of capacity we do so um i can actually we'll pull it up we will look at the [00:18:15] formula together yep so staffing um ratios are essentially the size of those classrooms that's [00:18:20] taken into account there are the number of classroom capable spaces in the building [00:18:26] classroom capable is important because we also [00:18:28] then remove some of our classroom capable spaces from the equation because we want to preserve [00:18:34] space for related arts instruction we also have a scale down modifier by grade band [00:18:39] so we're going to scale that down for our elementary school grade band so that we can still [00:18:43] just provide for some of those additional programmatic needs of students we know that [00:18:48] speech and language pathology for instance ell services different needs and accommodations take [00:18:53] space and so all of that is accounted for that is a very different formulaic model and i do think [00:18:58] this is a really good example of how we can look at some of these different things and then [00:19:01] we can start to think about what's going on here all right yes ma'am as a realtor with over a [00:19:06] decade of experience in noxville i believe we need to consider how housing affordability and [00:19:11] new construction will affect future school enrollment the recent median home sales price [00:19:16] in hardin valley 37932 zip codes is approximately 585 000 compared to 737 000 in the al zip code [00:19:25] that's over 150 000 difference this will attract families with elementary school age children into [00:19:28] Hardin Valley much more than it will pay a lot in the future. For example with [00:19:32] the current the current interest rates it's a difference of about a $3,000 [00:19:36] mortgage payment and a $4,000 mortgage payment. In my professional [00:19:40] opinion scenario one makes the most sense due to families with young [00:19:44] children seeking affordable housing. With a new subdivision plan in Hardin Valley [00:19:48] there are concerns that development could bring approximately 700 additional [00:19:52] children into the area. Has the district verified those projections and [00:19:57] accounted for that growth? Are we planning for what future students will [00:20:01] live where future students will live or simply moving students who are currently [00:20:05] established in their schools? As a single working mother I already struggled to [00:20:11] make school pickup on time. My son will be entering fourth grade and moving him [00:20:15] from ale lots would disrupt his education and create additional [00:20:19] transportation challenges. As a working mom I rely on my son's grandparents and [00:20:24] my 17 year old daughter to help with school pickup. [00:20:26] They could no longer take backroads to pick him up from school on time and would [00:20:31] be forced to get on the interstate. If scenario one addresses growth in Hardin [00:20:35] Valley without disrupting AL lots families why would scenario 3 be chosen? [00:20:40] I'd like to know what the district has accounted for all the group [00:20:43] subdivisions ongoing construction and projected student enrollment over the [00:20:47] next five to ten years when making this decision. [00:20:52] Let Mr. Dillingham talk about how oh and Abby has told us we have to move away from the mics creating feedback we apologize but Abby has told us we have to move away from the mics creating feedback we apologize. [00:20:56] so I'll let him talk about how those projections are generated but I also [00:21:01] want to say this the first time I'll get to use it this evening please also put [00:21:04] that in the survey so that's the type of feedback we're looking for in the survey [00:21:07] so thank you for that so I guess the short answer is yes we have a we work [00:21:14] closely with Knoxville Knox County Planning to get all permits that have [00:21:19] been pulled for new construction so they look at those then we they also pull [00:21:24] demographic data birth rates historical birth rates for areas broken down by zip [00:21:29] code but then we also Box County has divided into 1,200 individual study [00:21:33] areas so each one of those study areas is populated with attributes part of [00:21:38] them is the type of housing that are present there the student yield we have [00:21:41] seen over the last 20 years of types of housing they're modified by looking at [00:21:45] national and regional trends of student yields from those types of housing we [00:21:49] then use a I guess a well-regarded school enrollment [00:21:54] software called school site Pro that kind of pulls these things together [00:21:57] algorithmically it gives us an idea of like projecting for this study area what [00:22:02] do we think it's going to look like in the next few years we then stitch those [00:22:06] together into a school zone or in this case when we move lines around we're [00:22:11] moving study areas around to give us a projection is it perfect like it's not [00:22:15] it's not a an exact crystal ball this is what's going to happen next year the [00:22:19] year after the year after but what we try to do is try to get as much [00:22:23] information as we can trying to make informed decisions we're trying to make [00:22:27] data-centered decisions and so we're trying to pull in as many factors as we [00:22:31] can account for to try to fuel these discussions so that's the logistical [00:22:36] answer what it doesn't account for our parents picking up kids right and the [00:22:40] route that they take so please take the survey drop out and tell us what that's [00:22:43] going to feel like to you will accommodate as much as we can so thank [00:22:46] you for that good evening my name is Joey Ruffalo I am the elected alderman [00:22:54] Farragut in the North Florida [00:22:56] uh all the schools in Farragut are located in my district and many of the [00:23:00] concerns I've heard over the last couple of days I've heard before the last [00:23:04] couple of days and they're very valid one concern I have is has KCS done a [00:23:13] comprehensive Farragut or West Knox traffic study no so as I said the other [00:23:21] night we have not commissioned the traffic study to look at these things what we have done is you know I'm the [00:23:27] transportation guy like I work in the transportation office sure we have done [00:23:31] um we have looked at bus routes we have looked at how what kind of impact that [00:23:35] it would have on our bus routes how would we need to if this happens how [00:23:38] would we route this bus we have this number of students over here how are we [00:23:41] going to accommodate that we haven't started planning actual bus routes yet [00:23:44] because again we don't know which direction we're going to go but we also [00:23:48] don't want to start from scratch once the scenario is picked so like my [00:23:51] routing team has looked at those things and started sort of what if thing and [00:23:55] what would this look like and how would we do this [00:23:58] um you know a lot of these areas we're already providing buses so as I've said [00:24:03] the last couple of nights our usual process is we we start with a bus route [00:24:07] as it is see if that will still work and look at sending it just to a different [00:24:11] school when it gets to you know parents going to school those sorts of things [00:24:16] it's not that that it's not that that's not a real concern it absolutely is but [00:24:21] a parent deciding what they're going to do like when my wife takes my daughter [00:24:24] something somewhere that is an individual [00:24:25] individual [00:24:25] choice that she is making for our family it becomes more difficult for us [00:24:29] to forecast that across 500 a thousand fifteen hundred families so we we're [00:24:34] focusing on the the things that we can do the things that we know and try to [00:24:38] kind of lay it around for that so it looks like every scenario provides much [00:24:43] more traffic into Farragut you see the Farragut traffic as it is now when [00:24:48] you're deciding to do these routes are you going to seek how to Farragut [00:24:52] administration and staff input [00:24:54] for the bus routes for the traffic [00:24:57] Alzajar we've been there's not just Buston people driving their cars [00:25:02] absolutely yes I mean we've been in conversation with [00:25:06] the time period throughout this entire process so I mean they know I think we [00:25:11] have to do some of this is getting outside of my lane so that's why I'm [00:25:13] sure some of this might have happened before I took office it it did we worked [00:25:18] very collaboratively with the town of Farragut we did the actual traffic study [00:25:22] we took a lot of their input we made a lot of their [00:25:24] of adjustments to what knox county schools would own as far as the um the drive for the actual [00:25:31] school we discussed the queuing for buses the queuing for parent pickup so yes we work very [00:25:38] collaboratively collaboratively with them so there is a traffic study then there is a traffic study [00:25:42] for the town of farragut so guys mind sharing that with us you all have it we did it in collaboration [00:25:47] with the town of farragut so david smoke absolutely has that we sat in several meetings [00:25:52] uh with the traffic study so you all do have that information so so to your point and one of the [00:26:07] reasons we would not do a traffic study for this is because we haven't landed on anything right so [00:26:11] that's a bigger conversation once we land on whatever scenario we're moving with then we would [00:26:17] come we would either go with what we currently have planned for we would come back to the table [00:26:22] and have a conversation as well i can tell you that traffic study you're talking about is only [00:26:28] the new school because i have i was the ultimate for the last two years and now i'm the man [00:26:32] here um the uh traffic study we want to see i think what all the roof flow is talking about [00:26:40] is the fact that you want to bring people in from north shore into farragut you want to bring people [00:26:44] into chodo that traffic state has never been done by you mayor kane that is correct so let me look [00:26:53] i want to go back to so you all can understand this process right we've done this process now for [00:26:59] every new build that we have done when you [00:27:02] see these scenarios i want to be very clear we are not saying this is what we are doing right [00:27:07] we are getting your input and we are going to come back with a recommendation for the board [00:27:12] when i say that what we know for a fact is there is a new school we worked collectively [00:27:18] with the town of farragut to look at what does that look like look like in the town of farragut [00:27:23] right that is one of these scenarios okay if we go outside of that that's when we'll [00:27:28] have conversations on doing a traffic study because we haven't here in the town of farragut [00:27:32] to plan at that time, right? So we'll have those conversations if we go with another [00:27:36] scenario. So I want to be clear, we've not landed on anything. That's why it's so important [00:27:40] to get the input from the community. And I mean, and I'll actually piggyback on what [00:27:45] Dr. Adams here is saying. We have one thing we have to do this year. We've got to draw [00:27:51] lines within the town of Farragut, right? So we know we are doing that. Those lines [00:27:56] need to be drawn with the context of the broader community. So essentially that's why we're [00:28:00] having this conversation. The actual urgency behind secondary steps, tertiary steps, whatever [00:28:08] follows tertiary steps, the fourth phase, right? All of that actually can move at its [00:28:14] own pace and at the pace of these conversations, at the pace of community appetite. And so [00:28:18] when we say this is a conversation starter, it's a conversation starter for the broader [00:28:23] Knox County. It is an immediate conversation in the town of Farragut because of the new [00:28:29] school. And so that's where... [00:28:30] That's where that traffic study absolutely gives us some continuity to work with where [00:28:34] we're within the boundary lines of the town of Farragut. Beyond that, there are some additional [00:28:39] conversations that would need to be had, but we need to know from our community what those [00:28:44] conversations are even going to sound like. [00:28:46] Welcome back. I think we need a team of how many of us have done this for three nights. [00:28:55] Yes. Yeah. I like it. [00:28:56] Okay. So my first question is just a point of clarification. So the proposal for the [00:29:03] school will be publicly published on December 2nd with the board agenda. What is your internal [00:29:09] deadline for having that ready? [00:29:13] As soon as possible. And so I would say that we have internal deadlines to begin working [00:29:18] through, obviously feedback, what everybody sees on the surveys, right? Because everyone's [00:29:23] going to have a different reaction, right? We're all pulling through, we're identifying [00:29:27] what we see, what do we not see. I would say that that's a living, working document, if [00:29:31] I'm being perfectly honest with you. [00:29:32] Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. [00:29:33] Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. [00:29:34] We're going to keep working on that until we publish those. Right? [00:29:35] And so we're going to keep working on that until it feels right. And I will say this [00:29:44] just for anyone who's ever followed our board agenda items, there are a lot of contracts [00:29:48] on there. And so please do not lose faith. Scroll to the bottom, that is where you're [00:29:52] going to find this proposal. But those generally do publish fairly late in the day. And so [00:29:57] we know that December 2nd is our deadline. Will we be copy editing at that point, just [00:30:03] running final notes on those? No, we're going to keep working on that. We're going to keep [00:30:03] numbers on math yeah absolutely but we also may be making final adjustments as those projections [00:30:10] are coming in and we're finalizing it so I mean it's going to be a work in progress right up until [00:30:14] the time we press start yeah that makes sense so obviously you're and you mentioned that the [00:30:20] survey will stay open yeah I think you said last night that the last time you go last time you guys [00:30:24] will look at it will be December 1st so obviously you can't iterate on three scenarios up until the [00:30:32] end of the hour so what's your internal deadline for choosing a I know you are the final proposal [00:30:39] will be an iteration of one of these what is your internal deadline for for saying we're done [00:30:46] iterating on the other two now we're full force on this final scenario because really you only [00:30:53] need to do really really really good tweets to the one that you're paying I would say um actually we [00:30:58] can start with all three uh because it and I would say it's a difference in not what's [00:31:02] our scenario restarting from it's a difference in what's our point of origin so across each of [00:31:07] the three scenarios the point of origin that I would suggest is essentially the interior of [00:31:12] that triangle between the three new schools because we've got to work Farragut out so [00:31:17] essentially if we start within the town of Farragut right and we're looking there and [00:31:21] we radiate outward you're going to get to a point across all three scenarios where the lines probably [00:31:26] start to look very very similar and so because that's our urgency that we're starting from [00:31:32] those maps they always just kind of you know squishing together you'll have obvious outliers [00:31:37] that as you're permutating you can just go ahead and say you know what it's obviously not that one [00:31:41] we can take that one off the table so essentially you just got to run through the permutations until [00:31:46] you start locking in on something that feels consistently iteratively right so your process [00:31:51] is that you iterate until a scenario no longer makes logical sense got it we're essentially [00:31:57] eliminating what we can as much as we can because exercises like this it's [00:32:02] not everybody buying for one thing they really want right it's everybody saying I don't want [00:32:07] that um and so it's us essentially trying to eliminate bad options until we lock in on something [00:32:13] that feels right yeah okay um okay my next question and at some point I'll sit down and [00:32:19] come back my next question is I want to circle back to the question I had last night about [00:32:25] budgetary implications where you essentially said that because we're talking about the same number [00:32:32] of staff from a budgetary perspective it's basically a wash thesis yeah and this is not [00:32:39] a cost saving that was kind of the heart of the conversation we're not pursuing these scenarios [00:32:43] as a cost savings measure if anything it's a cost of frame measure um in the form of can we land on [00:32:48] a plan that prevents the need for new capital construction to the extent possible can I jump in [00:32:57] only in that case [00:33:02] um help me understand that when Dr Roswick you say your job is to make the right financial decision [00:33:09] if like why is that hold on all right you got that she's got it this is basically our marriage [00:33:16] how many years I'm circling back to that is because your response that this kind of doesn't [00:33:26] have anything to do with the budget sits in stark contrast to an email that I got yesterday from one [00:33:31] of our board members [00:33:32] that essentially said it's all about the dollars which is it so let me contextualize the difference [00:33:39] in dollars right now in future dollars right so one of these and future dollars when I say to frame [00:33:45] the need for capital that's what I need right so anytime we make a capital investment we are going [00:33:51] to have to pay on that investment for years essentially it's a mortgage right and so when [00:33:58] we talk about needing to look at how to alleviate potential [00:34:02] overcrowding and future overcrowding that defrays the need for capital so these three scenarios it's [00:34:10] not an immediate cost savings measure in that one of these costs less than the other it is that any [00:34:15] amount of reduction we can do for overcrowding and maximization of the use of the spaces we have [00:34:21] that's another mortgage payment we may not have to carry so when we say it's about the budget it's a [00:34:27] future budget and that's the consideration there does that make sense do you want if you want to [00:34:32] follow because I yield so given that we haven't seen dollars we know that in the short term it's [00:34:45] a watch we know that in the long term there are greater implications I still just can't help but [00:34:51] think that there are factors that we haven't seen in this presentation but we have been told that [00:34:57] like this is the decision it is about enrollment it is about growth it is about [00:35:02] what makes sense for feeder patterns all of that can we have a commitment from you guys that when [00:35:08] we look at your proposal to the board there will be no additional factors that add color and context [00:35:16] to your proposal I mean that from a budgetary standpoint I mean that from a faculty and staff [00:35:22] standpoint I just want to be clear that everything that is going into your decision has been [00:35:29] communicated to us my gut answer is yes [00:35:34] but I've heard this question enough times I'm starting to question myself now so what is the [00:35:39] suspicion of what's remaining right well here's when I when I get an email from a board member [00:35:46] where I say I say look at this dominant effect this is this is a long-term decision and it [00:35:53] requires long-term planning not three weeks notice the response is no school pass sale lots will be [00:35:59] impacted by this upcoming vote recommendation you are correct though that the other communities will [00:36:04] pass during a later date our budget is becoming tighter and tighter each year and enrollment has [00:36:09] shifted quite a bit goes on to say all of the schools in District 4 have portables not true [00:36:14] nor short of fun and the county will likely not fund additions to schools unless we show that we [00:36:19] are being good stewards and doing everything possible to balance school I don't like this [00:36:22] at all but the county commission has reduced our budget in some way each year for the last five [00:36:26] years as well as the state's new funding I'm working on plans to bring in December something [00:36:31] for the board to discuss regarding budget [00:36:34] this is a budget conversation and it's insulting to our intelligence to pretend that it's not and [00:36:43] so that's that's what I want to know wait what is going on behind all these numbers because I [00:36:50] think most rational and logical people in this room look at scenario three and two to some [00:36:57] extent that none of us actually think that two is a real scenario look at scenario three and think [00:37:04] it's garbage unless there's politics at play or unless there are assumptions at play that are [00:37:09] there are two things that are true for us right now and those two things are that every single [00:37:26] conversation we're having as a district right now is about our budget the other thing that is true [00:37:32] is that every single conversation that we're [00:37:34] having right now every single conversation I can say that we've had this administration for the [00:37:38] last five years has also been about our kids and so when we're having conversations every single [00:37:43] one and this is one of the biggest ones that we are having right now as a district is about our [00:37:49] kids and about the budget so I will own that absolutely there is a budgetary factor here it [00:37:57] is not that scenario one versus scenario two versus scenario three no one of those is more or less [00:38:04] offensive than the other every single one creates an opportunity that will have a later on down the [00:38:11] line budgetary impact right so we go with uh say scenario one right or some version of it what that [00:38:18] essentially means for us as a district from a budgetary standpoint is that a capital solution [00:38:23] in the Hardin Valley area is probably not as immediate right we are able to buy ourselves [00:38:30] some time with the relief that we can take advantage of there [00:38:34] that's a budgetary implication for scenario one you get a slightly lesser factor of that in [00:38:39] scenario two but you also are going to pick up a version of scenario three so I'm going to skip to [00:38:43] scenario three for just a minute because scenario two is essentially the combo of the two right so [00:38:48] it's a little bit of both so if you then skip to scenario three the budgetary implication there is [00:38:55] that domino effect and the uh budgetary when I say there's a budgetary implication I mean that if we [00:39:01] can alleviate congestion [00:39:04] Easton Pike or North Shore Drive we would not be anticipating a need for a capital solution at those [00:39:12] schools that are experiencing congestion so one is going to buy us some time to defray what is probably [00:39:18] a very very large capital expense another would also potentially just eliminate the need for a [00:39:26] more moderate capital expense somewhere so those are the possibilities and honestly right now when [00:39:32] we say possibilities we mean possibilities because [00:39:34] we go back to that original map that we were looking at that was again that 80 threshold right [00:39:39] those are not schools that right now across the board are overcrowded we have to start this [00:39:46] this conversation somewhere so we're starting it now because we have an opportunity it would [00:39:51] be remiss of us not to label for the entire community that we have an opportunity what [00:39:57] we're saying is that we don't have to use it right now but we do need to talk about it when it exists [00:40:03] so this is the first time [00:40:04] we've been able to put real numbers on that opportunity so we're labeling that now so we [00:40:10] can figure out as a district as a community how we want to use if we want to use that space right now [00:40:17] or in future years so that's when we say there's budgetary implications that's essentially what that [00:40:22] looks like I have one other question about the budget and the question about our board and then [00:40:31] um have you done an analysis to understand which of these [00:40:36] populations might be using vouchers at a different rates and what your attrition [00:40:42] might look like because of vouchers as a result of this reason so I thought I had an answer right [00:40:51] up until the end can you say that one more time have you played out in each of these three scenarios [00:40:57] essentially how many students you expect to leave a public school system in favor of a voucher solution [00:41:06] that something we are aware of is the fact that we are accounting for kids our projections right [00:41:13] are accounting for the presence of school-aged children that are not arriving in our buildings [00:41:18] so we are aware of that um we have suspicions uh potentially as to you know what's happening [00:41:24] in that general um space but in terms of actually predicting which parents are going to choose and [00:41:31] or receive a buy lottery opportunity no i would say that the amount of money time and effort that [00:41:37] would go into an analysis that would really be chasing a lot of highly variable human factors [00:41:42] probably also would not be a good use of our dollars just it it does seem relevant given [00:41:47] the it is definitely relevant mapping a theme to something that is that new that's the trouble that [00:41:52] we're kind of up against right now sure um and then regarding our board uh can we expect that [00:41:59] all of you will be casting a vote on december [00:42:01] now just to confirm on the record so no no board members are recusing themselves in any way from [00:42:15] that vote just just to be on the record and to be clear so for those who don't know me i'm lauren [00:42:29] morgan i'm uh the district five representative which is uh probably a lot of you at the [00:42:37] farragut schools west valley's my other school and then uh kat and i share a lot of constituents [00:42:43] kind of along those lines between the board [00:42:45] of board and five um we are set to vote on december 10th as for casting a vote so i will [00:42:54] tell you this i have never once recused myself from a vote i am not going to say i never will [00:42:59] in my life but this is my district i've attended all three meetings because it affects every single [00:43:05] resident in my district so this is of top importance to me the board deals with rezoning [00:43:13] that's a board responsibility there are a lot of things that are going on in the district that are [00:43:15] happening in our district lately that don't fall under board purview this does so casting a vote [00:43:23] on this is incredibly important in my opinion the work we do the district does and brings to us [00:43:30] between now and december 10th is incredibly important and while this [00:43:36] is absolutely fast and shocking and sudden for many of you um and i certainly do not love the [00:43:45] fact that um everyone is together and it makes me so sad that we are at the end of our own time [00:43:50] in our own time um i just want to take a minute to present you with an etude that was really [00:43:52] important to me and i will share with you today the one that came out during q a on monday that [00:43:56] sequoia and other hills uh west hills and other schools were mentioned that was astonishing to me [00:44:00] the heat on owning that I asked the district what have we looked at when [00:44:07] they first brought the maps I have been asking them since last year I've been [00:44:11] asking them I mean really since I got on the board but we started talking early [00:44:15] in the winter when are we doing the rezoning when are we talking about it [00:44:21] let's do it sooner rather than later because my Farragut residents have known [00:44:27] for all these years they will go to different schools they will be split up [00:44:31] from how it has always been done it's a huge deal we have never done this before [00:44:36] Knox County wide where we've essentially opened three new schools in our [00:44:40] community because we have never split Farragut into zoning for elementary [00:44:45] school big deal Cory and I have had endless conversations I don't even think [00:44:51] I would need more than two hands to count how many conversations we have had [00:44:54] to make sure that we all understand that we are not the only ones that are going to [00:44:57] be doing this and I understand it's a big deal we're not just opening one new [00:45:02] school this is not the same as when Mill Creek was open it is very different [00:45:06] we're opening three new elementary schools and we need to be prepared for [00:45:10] that now when we started talking about maps and I know I believe I don't want [00:45:16] to speak for them I believe what I have been told is that back in the summer [00:45:20] they really started working hard on these maps they've known it was coming [00:45:24] but back in the summer they started honing in on it is what I've been told [00:45:27] They've been honing in on the map. [00:45:28] But when I saw them for the first time at the end of September I was stunned because I had also been told that it was only going to affect Farragut and the maps were beyond Farragut and then I started asking other [00:45:40] questions if we're bringing in these outside groups why are we not looking at [00:45:47] all of these different communities like people will come and ask questions as [00:45:51] you all have and I'm thrilled that you have because it impacts every single one [00:45:54] of you and this is our responsibility to do so. [00:45:57] as a district and as a board is to involve the community so I I opened up [00:46:05] the can of worms I'll take ownership on that to say let's look at all of this [00:46:11] because we know what we're looking at and we know that there's a lot going on [00:46:16] however I also very clearly have said to the leadership team if we open that can [00:46:23] of worms we better come with a plan and I think you guys have done a really good [00:46:28] job of pointing out that as my Farragut PTO president said earlier on where she's [00:46:34] sitting the math isn't mathing why would you make Farragut overcrowded from the [00:46:39] beginning and then put North Shore at 60% capacity that's crazy that's the [00:46:45] whole reason we started building a new school it makes no sense unless you have a bigger plan and if you have a [00:46:52] bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan and if you have a [00:46:53] bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan than everyone deserves to know about [00:46:55] bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan than everyone deserves to know about [00:46:55] bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan and if you have a bigger plan than everyone deserves to know about that so and I have had [00:47:01] that so and I have had [00:47:01] that so and I have had conversations all week they have all been [00:47:04] conversations all week they have all been [00:47:04] conversations all week they have all been so available to me because this is [00:47:08] so available to me because this is [00:47:08] so available to me because this is obviously a big deal and we've had lots [00:47:11] obviously a big deal and we've had lots [00:47:11] obviously a big deal and we've had lots of conversations because you guys are [00:47:15] of conversations because you guys are [00:47:15] of conversations because you guys are intelligent engaged educated informed [00:47:19] intelligent engaged educated informed [00:47:19] parents and even if you weren't it should be a transparent process and we as a school district [00:47:27] should be held accountable for how we're making these huge decisions that impact so many children's [00:47:32] lives and families lives and every point that you have said has been valid i was not doing this so [00:47:38] sorry that's my soapbox here um to answer your question i mean yes i will be voting how i will [00:47:47] be voting i have no idea because i don't know what's going to be presented i could have short [00:47:53] answer said they'll bring us a recommendation and i know that they will work very closely with us i [00:48:01] know they'll work closely with me because they have for the two almost two and a half years i've [00:48:06] been in the seat i know now that basically all of west knoxville has gotten brought into this [00:48:13] they'll work closely with kat as well um and anyone else who would impact [00:48:17] and who's here in heartland valley and we're gonna figure out a good path forward i know [00:48:23] that's why dr reiswick is here tonight because we're committed to doing the good work and i [00:48:30] think it's really important that we are all here and making sure that happens so yes i will vote [00:48:36] i have no idea how i will vote i honestly don't like any of the options but i appreciate all the [00:48:43] work i do also want to say that i know that over well i have the mic let me just keep [00:48:47] knowing um over the last few nights i do want you all to know that their hearts are for kids they [00:48:57] really are and okay so i will say and i'll push listen i'm on your side but i'm going to push back [00:49:03] on that because i know it's hard and it's hard to see at the district level but i know there are [00:49:09] hearts for kids and there's a lot of big things happening county-wide i think that a whole bigger [00:49:17] brought if this can of worms was going to be opened. And I appreciate you guys pointing out [00:49:22] the things that don't add up. So anyway, I've said enough. Wait, Lauren, I do have one thing that doesn't [00:49:27] add up. You and I spoke on October 21st, and I asked you, as a North Shore dad, can you explain [00:49:34] to me what the maps are? I'm hearing North Shore's impacted, which is ridiculous because these were [00:49:39] supposed to be Farragut primary and Farragut intermediate. And you told me, I have not seen [00:49:45] any maps. I think I would know because if they were impacting the students in my district. [00:49:50] Yeah. And you just said that you saw those maps in September and you were aghast. And you don't [00:49:55] think that this dad right here, who was in the dark, would it also be aghast with you and want [00:50:01] to know? Did you think it was appropriate to wait another three weeks and not be honest about that? [00:50:06] Well, mister, let's talk. We have had a great conversation. We talked, I believe, for 30 minutes [00:50:12] on the phone. And we got off the phone, and my fifth grader, [00:50:15] said, I think I should be going to North Shore. That sounds like a really good school because she [00:50:20] heard all of the amazing things about North Shore that all of you North Shore parents have been [00:50:24] talking to have advocated for. She loves her school and Farragut's great. Don't get that wrong, but [00:50:30] she's pro-North Shore right now. So, yes, I said that to you because here's why. I saw the first [00:50:36] round of maps on September 21st, and I didn't like them. And I was very honest with our team here who [00:50:44] was in that meeting. And I said, I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't [00:50:45] understand. And I said, this is not what I expected because it went outside of Farragut. And no one. [00:50:51] Like, I was, like I said, stunned by that. I didn't know that was going to happen. So, um, I saw them [00:51:00] then. And we went through a working process of do we go forward with this or? But they took my [00:51:08] feedback, and they listened to my question. They listened to the list I gave them of here's what my [00:51:14] constituents are going to ask. [00:51:15] they went back to the drawing board scratched it and started over so i was honest when i told you [00:51:21] i had not seen maps because any of the maps that are here tonight i had not seen that that is a [00:51:27] ridiculous that is ridiculous to hide behind that and i will i'll get like that you had seen maps [00:51:34] and the correct answer would have been i have seen maps i'm disappointed in the number of schools [00:51:39] that they stretch to and that they're affecting and i've asked them to go back to the drawing [00:51:43] board and come up with a better solution which frankly as one of your constituents i would have [00:51:48] said thank you i really appreciate you advocating for the interest of this community instead what [00:51:53] you said was you hid behind a political half truth of i have seen no maps i think i would know about [00:51:58] something that affects the students in my district that is extraordinarily disingenuous i hope the [00:52:03] people here share that opinion very very frustrating to hear the person that we put on [00:52:08] the board to advocate for our interests not be willing to communicate transparently back to us [00:52:19] i'm so sorry wait wait wait i'm i'm gonna answer that [00:52:25] oh right yes but i'm i'm a board member and i'm gonna answer the will i vote [00:52:31] because i was also asked that um i represent district four which i'm not sure if i have [00:52:36] constituents in here but honestly i take i appreciate you um i i feel like my vote is for [00:52:44] the entire county and north shore is one of my schools so i care very deeply about everyone [00:52:49] in this room and um i've always cast a vote on zoning um and i've sometimes been the [00:52:56] the deciding vote and that's not very fun um it's not very fun at all but i do [00:53:01] my due diligence to make sure that i'm talking to people let me just say y'all are really good [00:53:05] at emailing and i'm not keeping up right now but i will get back to you and um i read all [00:53:11] of the emails i'm taking it very seriously and i was very excited that i didn't get to see these maps [00:53:19] until like I had no idea this was going on and that my schools were going to be touched [00:53:23] until a couple weeks ago and so that was not very exciting but the moment that I found out [00:53:28] that this was going to happen I reached out to my principals I let them know and I said [00:53:33] what do you think what's going on tell me about the roads because I'm going to be honest I live [00:53:38] in Sequoia hills and I don't come far west that often except you sometimes have a really good [00:53:43] trip um and so I want I'm excited for the feedback from everyone because and I I don't [00:53:52] drive these roads every day so last night after the meeting I sat with ALI's principal and we [00:53:58] talked about the roads we talked about what people drive what what makes sense and looks like oh [00:54:03] there's train tracks and all this stuff so I guarantee you that we are doing the work to look [00:54:08] at all of this stuff and also when they bring us maps and they present it to us you still have an [00:54:13] opportunity to come to our board meeting and talk things I have never seen a zoning vote and [00:54:19] this is my fifth year that hasn't changed all up until the day we are voting so there is always an [00:54:25] opportunity for things to change I promise you and I will be casting a vote today on something [00:54:31] thank you that was not my actual original question I was clarifying all of Liz's questions so I'd like [00:54:36] to ask my actual questions now um and that was really long answers for just could have been yes [00:54:41] or no um the last [00:54:43] I've been to two meetings this is my second one my husband came to the last and I also watched it [00:54:47] today I do have a crowd participation question if you don't mind raising your hand if you are from [00:54:51] Hardin Valley tonight will you raise your hand just so we know like a percentage I find that [00:54:55] incredibly interesting that we are at Hardin Valley and there are three few hands when they [00:55:00] are largely effective and that's a side note um this has been referred to as a conversation [00:55:05] multiple times so much so that we were counting and we lost track just for tonight alone um I'm [00:55:10] not a teacher but I do have a degree in English a degree in English and a degree in English and I'm [00:55:13] in journalism and a 25 plus year career in communications um this isn't a conversation [00:55:19] because conversations take time for people to be present which clearly Hardin Valley has two or [00:55:24] three so I'm guessing they maybe couldn't make it tonight um time to establish a trust or at a [00:55:30] minimum a common respect and common ground time to hear both sides out and time to reflect and put [00:55:35] into responses time to allow for both parties to offer suggested compromises time to provide [00:55:43] questions um this feels incredibly rushed of a conversation because we were notified on North [00:55:51] Shore PTO we were notified on November 5th that this meeting would even these meetings would even [00:55:56] happen we were not given proposal information to a few ahead of time so as of Tuesday night was the [00:56:02] first time we had seen any of this to begin this conversation um what's interesting about that is [00:56:07] you both mentioned everyone else has mentioned you all have had plenty of time to discuss this [00:56:12] in your conversations ahead of time so I'm going to give you a little bit of time to talk about this [00:56:13] um what's interesting about this is that you have had so much time to discuss this in your conversations [00:56:15] ahead of time so much so that you broke ground on this school on May 25th of 2025 so you've had one [00:56:22] year that you knew that school where you broke ground was going to have to be filled and how you [00:56:26] would fill it before that Farragut to my knowledge I'm not a very good parent but I have friends who [00:56:31] are they've known about this as you just said earlier for years so that conversation has been [00:56:36] going on what's confusing I think to everybody at least to me is that we have rushed this process to [00:56:43] happen now in five years and that's not fair to me this is something that I think we've talked about [00:56:43] so far this is something that I think we've talked about and I think we've talked about and I think we've talked about this [00:56:43] business days and you've already said so i have a couple of yes and no questions that i would love [00:56:48] that were just yes or no confirmations you are not going to you don't have to and you are not [00:56:53] going to complete a bus transportation or traffic analysis before december 2nd yes or no correct [00:57:01] okay in addition to the one that has been in for the town period okay you're not gonna you're not [00:57:05] gonna evaluate that's a question it's a different question this is the ones that i have questions [00:57:11] i had to multiple pages um verifying and finalizing any kind of educational staff and [00:57:18] resource impact will you have to provide that information before december 2nd can you clarify [00:57:25] that yes how teachers will be affected what teachers would be affected you're gonna at some [00:57:29] time between now and five days you're going to come up with this final picture that you're going [00:57:33] to propose behind that are you going to provide any kind of documentation about what teachers [00:57:38] and staff and resources would be affected yes okay are you saying [00:57:44] sure you're saying will we know i'm basically asking what you guys are going to have to [00:57:49] accomplish in the next five days aside from reasons thousands of responses in five business [00:57:56] days you're going to read all of those responses you're going to finally you're going to evaluate [00:58:03] those based on a plan one of these three things and possibly come up with a new scenario that fits [00:58:09] everything better or responds to it seems like a lot of work in five days and the reason it seems [00:58:14] like a lot of work for five days is as it was mentioned earlier videos of the previous night's [00:58:19] recordings were not posted the next day i go to a church that can do that within the next 12 hours [00:58:24] um you also not i'm clarifying if i'm wrong earlier dr rex said that he's not you did not [00:58:31] submit a memo for the december 2nd or yesterday's deadline for the december 2nd agenda is that [00:58:38] correct correct was that a hard deadline or they don't mind if you're late or how does that work the [00:58:44] deadline for the memo is december 2nd okay what was yesterday's deadline because that was brought [00:58:50] up in the meeting last night that you were supposed to submit something yesterday [00:58:57] the agendas that had to be set yesterday no somebody made that up yesterday okay [00:59:01] that's is that on the website okay okay there was a deadline yesterday guys i don't know what it was [00:59:07] but you don't either and i guess that's okay um it's just going back to that feeling of trust [00:59:14] if your own board members had an idea and fair get out of the way [00:59:16] large had an idea that this was a farragut solution one what changed it seems like you [00:59:23] could just solve a farragut problem with a farragut school and call it a farragut solution [00:59:27] and maybe that doesn't look i don't know sexy for the next 10 years of numbers but it solves [00:59:32] the problem you have right now of farragut being overcrowded and maybe you open that school at 50 [00:59:37] 60 why is that so scary you're fully willing to cut north shore down to 40 or 50 percent [00:59:44] and that's fine they'll fill up from somewhere [00:59:46] but god forbid we open this new glossy 44 million dollar mistake it seems like [00:59:51] and not have it open at absolutely 80 which is already the maximum that seems like there's some [00:59:57] trust issues and i think it's been illustrated tonight with everybody that spoke before me [01:00:02] we don't trust you guys because there hasn't been a lot of clarity and this feels incredibly rushed [01:00:07] and my second question is why not punt this to the december or the january and i understand [01:00:12] from last night and the night before that that has to be with transfers but i would [01:00:16] rather you guys do your due diligence and answer all the questions we have before you make some [01:00:21] sort of proposal that will affect my child's life very fair so i will say two quick things um so [01:00:27] going back to the staffing implications what will be published in the memo that is published on [01:00:32] december 2nd will be the projected enrollment for any of the impacted schools that projected [01:00:38] enrollment will be the starting point for staffing so when you ask do we know essentially what the [01:00:43] staffing implications are we will have a starting point for staffing so when you ask do we know [01:00:46] essentially what the staffing implications are we will have a starting point for that [01:00:48] what gets layered on at that point would be the family choice piece [01:00:53] in terms of who chooses to take advantage of whatever transfer option is awarded [01:00:57] so when i say yes we will have an idea of what the staffing implications are because [01:01:03] we will have the lion's share of enrollment already mapped out in the memo and we do [01:01:07] formulaically assign staff so there's some awareness but yes absolutely there's some [01:01:11] additional math that would need to be done as families have access to a transfer opportunity [01:01:16] um so even an in-house team member in the middle of your family is able to take advantage of a [01:01:18] transfer opportunity i also want to say that again the thing we have to determine in december [01:01:23] is a fair-gate decision when how is this not a farragut decision this is it is a fair palestine [01:01:29] so we're contextualizing potential zoning lines for the town of farragut for three schools any [01:01:35] broader impact beyond that is what we're pulse checking so when we say there's not urgency right [01:01:42] now and we're starting a conversation early we're starting a panel of x 105 and [01:01:46] conversation so that we can determine is there isn't there interest in any number of the scenarios [01:01:53] or situations or variables we're talking about something that was positioned to us that we are [01:01:58] pursuing right and you all actually have answered this largely for us over the course of the past [01:02:03] three days is whether or not there would be an appetite for families who are currently zoned for [01:02:09] North Shore Elementary School who are destined for Farragut Middle School destined for Farragut [01:02:13] High School something we've heard for a while is that there's an appetite for potential continuity [01:02:19] for those students to begin their educational career with the peers that they will graduate [01:02:23] from high school with that is something we can be aware of but something we can't necessarily [01:02:28] lock in on unless we have pulse checked right this is part of that pulse check and we have to ask [01:02:34] that question to determine whether or not that's something that actually would be appetizing to act [01:02:39] on so I know I've beaten this dead horse of a conversation [01:02:43] doesn't feel like that right now because we're in the midst of the exchange right so where that [01:02:48] exchange either earns or loses trust honestly and i know we're kind of in that lost trust space [01:02:53] right now it'll be in december so we're doing this so that we can garner your feedback so that [01:02:59] we can test those hypotheses i said yesterday and i can't remember if that was the meeting you said [01:03:04] you were at or not um the prior one i said yesterday you know if we had this conversation [01:03:09] about we've got some available resources that honestly settled for us as the community settled [01:03:16] so yes we know the school is coming for a long long time but we are talking about an area of [01:03:21] the county that is rapidly changing right every subsequent month is a little bit different than [01:03:26] the last one so we still we know we are at a decision point we want to wait and see what is [01:03:32] the shape of this community what is the face of this community what do these numbers actually [01:03:36] look like before we make a long-term decision for [01:03:39] the school [01:03:39] these kids because it is going to impact them in a very very real way so now that we're at that [01:03:44] point we're testing whether or not there is something that we could potentially do with some [01:03:50] available space that is a win across the board and if that's not the case that's what we're here [01:03:56] trying to figure out but it would be wrong of us would be poor stewards of that resource not to ask [01:04:02] the question there is a perception that we're going to force an opinion right force a decision [01:04:08] on families [01:04:09] that right now doesn't have to be forced we do have to ask the question and that's important i would [01:04:16] hope that you would hold us accountable in out years for not asking the question i would hope [01:04:21] you equally hold us accountable for not listening to the answer so i think that's what we're going to [01:04:26] start touching with the five days is that's an incredibly small window for you guys to evaluate [01:04:30] all of our answers and all of our feedback and as you guys are not elected officials you're appointed [01:04:36] correct so there's a little bit of a different weight than what we were talking about earlier [01:04:40] just it's the appreciation of we are all here on our time away from our families and there's [01:04:45] a very short window for you guys to make what seems like some really big decisions regardless [01:04:50] of the conversations before and i would just hope that you guys would appreciate that the [01:04:53] tiniest side note just because you brought it up earlier with this moving around um i drive [01:04:59] more short all the time from october from august until now i have not been in an accident backup [01:05:05] either i would say i can't think of one from i would you drop off every morning and pick up [01:05:10] every afternoon in my commute here from north shore to hardin valley we were in two traffic [01:05:15] backups just on a regular old thursday night so thank you guys for your time for sitting in the [01:05:21] traffic to get to us i would also like to say this we have had almost non-stop conversations [01:05:29] since tuesday so wednesday morning we were huddled up we were on the phone [01:05:34] on the drive [01:05:35] in talking about what we heard tuesday night yesterday morning began the same way this [01:05:41] morning began the same way and so we are asking for this feedback so that we can be processing [01:05:47] like it is fast and i do want to respect and honor the fact that it is fast it's fast for [01:05:52] us as well but so that we can make the right decision for our schools to start settling [01:05:57] those staffing formulas hi um my name is kim parks i live in the town of harrogate [01:06:06] so transparency builds trust and the fact that this presentation or any of these [01:06:13] numbers weren't presented before tuesday night is a big problem especially if you want [01:06:19] participation from the community um we only have what three a handful of harden family parents here [01:06:27] and two of these options impact them [01:06:30] who do we ask for [01:06:31] like how in the world can you feel the need to show your support to someone who hurts so badly [01:06:33] how in the world can you feel good about them not being here i i i don't need to answer yet [01:06:41] because there's another factor that you guys are talking about doing after the fact that's [01:06:47] putting the cart before the horse with this traffic idea listen fair gets a different [01:06:51] anomaly when it comes to buses all right parents do not really from kindergarten to fifth grade [01:06:59] put their kids on the bus because guess how long it takes them to get home from school [01:07:04] if even if you live right behind the school it takes hours which is [01:07:10] unsat for a kindergartner to sit there for hours on the bus that's how kids get in trouble so [01:07:18] the fact that you guys aren't even thinking about that like fairgate is an anomaly when [01:07:23] it comes to that trust me i i've lived it i've sat in car lines upon car lines upon car lines [01:07:30] all because my kids would get home at 6 p.m if not when they got out of school at 3 30. so [01:07:38] really you guys should have been thinking about like for thinking that that's the reason why [01:07:42] farragut when you guys came to us i was at those meetings [01:07:47] we really emphasized making sure we could stack the cars in the lines [01:07:52] so it would bleed out onto kingston pipe because that's a big problem area in our town [01:07:59] so [01:08:00] mr bus guy i don't know i don't i don't remember your name um [01:08:08] how are you going to help the situation by not understanding the whole anomaly with farragut [01:08:16] and the bus issues and uh because you can't put a number on it it's not a statistic that [01:08:23] you can put in place because parents are just not going to let their kid be on the bus they'll say [01:08:29] yeah this is my school here i'm out of town i'm out of town i'm out of home i'm all right [01:08:31] i don't care where i am i can't go home now because i'm gonna be out of here by 6 p.m [01:08:33] so um so a couple of things i mean um we have there are a lot of families and fair that are [01:08:38] you're exactly right to take their students we have thousands or hundreds of families high [01:08:41] hundreds of families that do entrust their students with us um every single day one of [01:08:47] the things that we have accounted for is whatever whatever ends up happening whichever scenario [01:08:54] whatever proposal comes forward one thing that is undeniably true is there will be fewer students at [01:08:59] primary school and ferried intermediate school than there are currently. So there's reduced trips [01:09:03] to each one of those. The other thing that the shift from a primary and intermediate to K-5s [01:09:08] will do specifically for our buses is right now every single bus route goes to both schools. [01:09:14] So we have half of our buses that start at the primary school go to the intermediate school, [01:09:18] half of our buses that start at the intermediate school go to the primary school. So there is a [01:09:21] built-in 10 to 15 minute buffer of lost time for the beginning of each one of those routes each [01:09:27] afternoon. Now we're going to be able to start each one of those routes at 245 at this missile [01:09:32] and start delivering students home. So from a routing perspective, one of the things we are [01:09:36] taking into account is yes, there's going to be a lot of traffic. There will continue to be a lot [01:09:41] of traffic, I guess I should say. But we're going to be picking up some efficiency just because of [01:09:46] redesigning how we do elementary school. Unfortunately, I don't think you're taking [01:09:51] into account that there are only three ways from Hardin Valley to get to Farragut. Our roads are [01:09:56] already failing. [01:09:57] The current population. Okay. And there's no I know traffic will work itself out. But there's no [01:10:03] working it out in Farragut right now. Our roads are at capacity. And I know this because I work [01:10:10] closely at the town. So the numbers that you guys got, those are old. Those are old numbers. They [01:10:20] have not been updated. And so the fact that you guys are using that data right now is is [01:10:27] kind of moot because the roads have changed since then. Like 2020 data is not going to work for 2026 or [01:10:34] 2027. For that fact, given that there's like five new apartment complexes surrounding Farragut that [01:10:40] are going in. So um, you guys really need and there's only one way for buses from Choteau into [01:10:50] Farragut. So I really that needed to happen before this. [01:10:57] Um, because once you guys have the school there, and you guys have the zoning done, guess what, [01:11:03] there's no changing it. So you guys really should figure out a new process. That's the end of my [01:11:12] comment. Thank you have been here before. Good to see you. So my name is Chris D'Angelo. I have [01:11:25] four children. Two of them are at North Shore and they love it there. I've got two little ones below [01:11:32] them who are really excited about. [01:11:34] The idea of going to North Shore because of the passion and the love that their older siblings have [01:11:39] for it. I did want I do want levels that I think that you all have a really hard job. I have no [01:11:46] doubt that your hearts are for our kids. And I appreciate that you wake up every day thinking [01:11:54] about how our kids need to get a world class education. The reality is the choices that you [01:12:01] made have enabled a staff and North Shore who gives them [01:12:04] a world class education. And I think the thing that's disheartening is that part isn't coming [01:12:11] through in your process. Your process feels very opaque. It feels very cold. And it feels very [01:12:19] calculated. I you all mentioned your your kids. And I think as you're talking about your kids, [01:12:29] you're lighting up and then as you're talking about our kids, it's lines, bus routes, [01:12:34] numbers, and it doesn't really feel great to be on that. I also think when you are talking about [01:12:41] language like we need to imagine what's possible or look at the opportunity that we have. We don't [01:12:47] want our kids to be your opportunity. The opportunity that the opportunity that our kids are [01:12:55] is for you to give them a world class education. They are not an opportunity for you to figure out [01:13:01] how to move the pieces on a chessboard so that the numbers seem to look right XYZ. [01:13:06] I understand that that's a responsibility that you have. But as long as your hand is not being [01:13:10] forced, which it's not with these plans, and you've admitted that as such by saying that [01:13:14] you're not in a crisis mode. We do not want again, I'm a North Shore parent. I don't want North Shore [01:13:20] to be a halfway house for kids that you're rolling west when it's most convenient to do so. I don't [01:13:27] think you do either. But that's that's what that is what we're here. And I think it feels like [01:13:32] that's not really coming through to you all in a compelling way. And so I just I do want to make [01:13:37] that clear. So when I look at your process, I want you to see what we see here in the field. [01:13:43] You talked about starting key decisions in January 2022. We haven't heard from you about these plans [01:13:51] since November of 2024. So for nearly two years, you've been absolutely silent, while you have [01:13:57] been contemplating different machinations for where these lines need to be. Albeit because you [01:14:02] think it's the right thing to do from a stewardship perspective, but it seems to have never entered [01:14:07] what the community response might be. Typically, in a process like this, when you say things like [01:14:13] we need to test assumptions, we need to have a conversation, we need to gather community input, [01:14:18] that should be happening far upstream from developing possible scenarios that you would [01:14:24] then tweak and come to the board. And that is a huge disconnect that we all have. And now what [01:14:29] we're hearing is we're hearing other language that you all are using of over on a really tight [01:14:34] timeline, we've got a short runway, we're going to open up a survey, [01:14:37] we're going to... And what we're sitting here and thinking is, and Catherine elucidated this, [01:14:42] you're going to have a five-day survey where you're going to get hundreds of unstructured [01:14:46] feedback that you are going to have to synthesize to make determinations of what to do. [01:14:52] Nobody put you in this situation except for yourselves. You could have been gathering this... [01:14:57] You could have been gathering this feedback for months up to this point. [01:15:03] There are not a million different scenarios that can really exist. [01:15:07] The set of choices is fairly clear if you all have grander ideas in terms of rolling kids West, [01:15:13] which I don't think is particularly wise given even if the development patterns have slowed, [01:15:18] the development is still largely happening to the West. When we think about these other schools [01:15:25] that will be impacted to the East, they're in largely, I'll call them sealed environments. [01:15:30] There's not that much opportunity to develop. So this kind of 80% danger zone is a bit of a farce, [01:15:37] when we know there just can't be hundreds of kids that suddenly move into some of these schools. [01:15:42] There's just not a place to build a house or an apartment complex. [01:15:46] Where there is that type of capacity is in the Farragut area, which is why making this a Farragut [01:15:52] centric decision is what would be wiseness. Keeping kids as far East as they can be right [01:15:57] now is likely the better outcome to protect what's happening in the longer term. [01:16:02] So again, I just think from the process standpoint, I think you need to understand [01:16:05] where we're at. [01:16:07] And I think you also need to be honest with yourselves that it's simply not feasible for [01:16:12] you to give the feedback that you're going to receive, the credit and the due diligence that [01:16:17] it deserves before submitting a plan to the board. And if you think that you can, I would really ask [01:16:23] you to look at yourselves in the mirror and say, is that an honest interpretation of what I'm about [01:16:27] to do? I have a day job and then on top of that, I'm going to do all of this. When I could have [01:16:32] done this a year ago, at least months ago, I guess several weeks ago, [01:16:37] it would have been better. And so I, I would be very curious to understand why did you wait so [01:16:43] long and what were you all doing up until now? So I will say in full transparency, our district [01:16:50] team has by design gotten smaller and smaller every single year, right? And that's it. We're [01:16:56] talking about budgetary choices. It's a conscientious choice we've made to be able to [01:16:59] preserve as many of our dollars as close to our kids as possible with a lean team coming out of [01:17:05] a year that we just had, right? [01:17:07] Um, this honestly is a conversation that was on the till on in the hopper for this summer. And I [01:17:14] don't know how many of you joined us in the news this summer. Um, but it was a very different summer [01:17:19] for us, uh, than the one we intended, right? So we had some very big things, very unexpected things [01:17:24] going on in June. We had some very big things, very unexpected things going on in July. I also [01:17:29] want to label that's not an excuse, right? That is our reality. But I hear you when you say I wanted [01:17:35] this to have started sooner. [01:17:36] Yeah. [01:17:37] Yeah. [01:17:37] Yeah. [01:17:37] Yeah. [01:17:37] I do respect that. Our commitment right now is to say that this is the timeline that we are on, [01:17:43] and we are going to spend as much time as it takes beyond our contract hours, [01:17:49] because I will say this on behalf of all of our teachers, someone who worked in a school for a [01:17:53] long, long time, I believe deeply in the district office, having seen the time our teachers put in, [01:17:58] right outside of contract time that we owe it to spend that amount of time and more on decisions [01:18:04] that are this important. Should we be doing that? No, we shouldn't. [01:18:07] Is that where we want to be? No. Is that the type of commitment it's going to take to make sure that [01:18:13] we are processing everything that you all are sharing? Yeah. And it's worth it. So every single [01:18:18] time we've walked out of a community meeting, this is number three. And I want to say you're [01:18:23] not hearing the change that we're all talking about, because we made a commitment to ourselves [01:18:29] at the beginning of this process that every single presentation is going to be the same, [01:18:32] right? We know that not every family who's represented here today, [01:18:36] Right. [01:18:37] had the same opportunity to be there yesterday, to be there two days ago. So we committed to the [01:18:42] same presentation. We committed to the same amount of information sharing. Has our thinking evolved [01:18:47] in the last three days? Yes. We intended for it to evolve over the last three days. Will it continue [01:18:53] to evolve tomorrow? Yes. We have already blocked off the entire afternoon tomorrow. We are going [01:18:59] to be sitting in a room digging through everything that you all have contributed vocally and [01:19:05] everything that you all are contributing. [01:19:06] Digitally, because that is the commitment. We are going to be carrying that into next week with us. [01:19:13] We will be carrying it into the subsequent week. And I know that it doesn't seem like that feedback [01:19:19] is going to be reflected in our final proposal. And I can't make it seem that way right now, [01:19:25] but I really deeply encourage you all to join us at least in watching on December 10th, [01:19:31] to open up the proposal on December 2nd, because so many of what. [01:19:36] So many of the factors you all have already elevated have been heard and are already being [01:19:43] applied in a way that I genuinely think will feel reflective of what you're sharing right now. [01:19:49] Respectfully, then I, I feel a little bit to use a school analogy. You all are the student [01:19:56] that for sure have been studying for the test for weeks, forgot or two years before. And now [01:20:01] you're saying I'm going to use every hour that I have to study for that test, because that's what [01:20:06] deserves and I'm going to give it my all. There is simply not enough time between now and when you [01:20:13] must make decisions for you to actually spend what this requires. That's the problem. It is not [01:20:19] heartening to me to hear that you are setting aside a single afternoon to process the deluge [01:20:24] of comments that you're writing. That is insufficient. That is not being supportive of our kids in our [01:20:29] community. That is a rushed response to a process that has been botched. I, again, I do not doubt [01:20:36] that this is in the right place. I do not doubt that you want to do the right thing. But what I'm [01:20:40] saying is you need to look at how you can, how you can get yourself out of the situation of making [01:20:45] false dichotomies and preserving a decision set that actually makes sense for the set of [01:20:50] constraints that we have. And that set of constraints is we don't have enough data, [01:20:54] we don't have enough time, and we don't have enough understanding right now to make a decision [01:21:00] that affects three, four, five schools so that we can preserve something in the future that we're [01:21:05] fundamentally uncertain about. [01:21:06] That would be an honest reading of the facts that you have. [01:21:09] I don't want to discount that. I only want to say, just on behalf of the decision-making, [01:21:18] it will not be done tomorrow. And so, yes, I want to honor everything that you just said. I'm not [01:21:22] going to discount it. But I do want to say, just for clarity's sake, that we are not sitting down [01:21:27] in a room together and going through all the survey responses. All the survey responses won't [01:21:31] even be in tomorrow. And I, and I know that that is also insufficient. I just wanted to clarify. [01:21:35] Understood. And I appreciate that. But candidly, if you woke up [01:21:39] today and worked from 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. from now until the day that this is quote-unquote due [01:21:45] through Thanksgiving and all the rest, it still would be insufficient to me because it is simply [01:21:49] too large of a decision to cram into the time that you have allotted for it right now. And that is [01:21:55] the, that is the point that I want to drive home. I did, I did have some specific questions about the [01:22:00] data as well. I believe you mentioned using School Site Pro. Can you just expand on what is the [01:22:08] underlying data set that you're working on right now? Can you just expand on what is the underlying data set that you're working on right now? [01:22:09] Can you just expand on what is the underlying data set that you're working on right now? Can you just expand on what is the underlying data set that you're drawing upon to actually make [01:22:11] these decisions? Because they seem to have led you astray given that you need to open up a world of [01:22:17] opportunity that you weren't considering before. So what are the data sets that you're looking at? [01:22:20] Sure. I spoke earlier about the, sort of, the inputs into that. So a lot of it is every single year we [01:22:28] pull, we geocode every single one of our students. And so we pull that, we send it to planning, they [01:22:35] pull in the things that I mentioned with the study areas, the attributes of the different study areas, [01:22:39] on and so forth did you i want to know where it's coming from so i want to be i don't want [01:22:43] who you got the data from i want the underlying source that's feeding so we do code our students [01:22:49] so we know the source okay what about for population patterns so we pull it um actually [01:22:54] planning pulls it from the health department what is the health department using they well so the [01:22:59] health department tracks birth rate data and births live births in the knox county okay but [01:23:03] what about influx outflux so you're using county business patterns what are you getting so planning [01:23:08] pulls in all of the a lot of that is pulled from the construction permits that are pulled [01:23:13] that people you know subdivisions that are planned apartment buildings that are planned [01:23:17] uh use some review that kind of certainly helpful proxy but there's also you have inflow and outflow [01:23:23] structures that already exist where you have older families turning over for newer families so [01:23:28] what are you using to understand that type of demographic shift so that demographic shift on [01:23:33] often shows up in our enrollment so like you know a new family moves in they enroll [01:23:38] north shore so they weren't there on tuesday but they are there on wednesday that's obviously [01:23:41] something we track we also get the data from planning about you know new people coming in [01:23:46] new develops that are happening on a monthly basis in addition to our kind of once a year [01:23:50] big projection center okay understood so then what went wrong in terms of predicting a spike [01:23:56] that didn't occur so what i want to dig into is where in the data that you're pulling missed it [01:24:02] so um so it's a statistical model right so it's accurate at the population level less so at an [01:24:09] individual level so what we saw is a continued pattern over the last three years of growth [01:24:15] in ferry um dr reiser alluded to it earlier there we've also seen unevenness in our enrollment we've [01:24:22] you know there are 3 500 fewer kids that enrolled in knox county schools than there were three years [01:24:26] ago so you know i can't get into the why or what that looks like um because again it's an [01:24:31] individual family [01:24:32] that's making decisions what we can talk about are the macro effects and so part of what happened [01:24:37] is we saw a continued pattern of projected um or projected increased growth in this area uh and [01:24:45] then when we got to the newest projection set in 2024 that pattern was shifted okay so okay [01:24:53] i just want to play this back so you're you're seeing a macro pattern projection [01:24:58] did you overlay your enrollment data on top of that to understand if the macro projection was [01:25:02] telling you [01:25:02] an accurate story yes so those two things were buried together and they were telling you yes [01:25:08] we're going to continue to see things grow is that accurate yes so 2024 has been different [01:25:12] that's accurate yes so you're using a single data point to now question your entire forecasting [01:25:16] strategy not our entire forecasting strategy but it is we had a pattern showing one thing [01:25:21] and now we have something else showing something a different thing and in our like each one of our [01:25:27] projection sets contains multiple years we typically go five years so we were seeing repeated [01:25:32] year patterns of growth now we see one that is not showing that that led us to this larger [01:25:37] conversation of are we like maybe we don't need as many seats as we thought we were going to in [01:25:42] farragut should we explore other things but you understand what i'm saying you're seeing [01:25:46] an existing pattern you're seeing one data element that is now telling you that pattern [01:25:50] may or may not persist and and that really seems to be the driver that's led you to say [01:25:55] perhaps our entire strategy for this zoning needs to be rethought this one one data point relative to [01:26:02] your historical trend it is um so i i guess the short answer is yes the more nuanced answer or at [01:26:10] least for me and maybe only for me is that like it is it is one data point but it is lots of small [01:26:16] data points that come into one it's aggregated as one thing but it is not just one thing i understand [01:26:21] but that aggregation pattern was true for a long period of time and now what i'm saying is that [01:26:26] aggregate think of them as aggregated columns those columns were telling you the same story [01:26:31] over and over and over again [01:26:32] and now you're getting one column that's not and you all have now brought three scenarios none of [01:26:38] which are true to the original plan you're not i don't know if you even that has resonated as [01:26:43] ironic but the original plan isn't even on one of those posters and so you're letting that one data [01:26:48] point redirect your entire approach you don't think that that is a little bit of an odd choice [01:26:55] i advise i used to advise clients on this type of data analysis all the time i would have never [01:26:59] told my client hey we're seeing one data point let's fundamentally change [01:27:02] our business strategy i would say we might want to pull up and see if this is a truer pattern and [01:27:06] truer story but i certainly wouldn't have done a hard pivot over it so why are we here [01:27:15] as we've said earlier when we saw the anomaly we took it as an opportunity to have a larger [01:27:20] conversation obviously you don't think that was a good idea you had a lot you had a larger internal [01:27:24] conversation not once did you take that conversation out to the community until this [01:27:28] moment yeah i guess what i'm trying to say is like it started as a fair and only solution which is [01:27:33] because of it and again you disagree with that the conclusion you disagree with that's totally [01:27:39] fair but like that is being trying to try to be honest with you no i appreciate that like that [01:27:44] that was where we were coming i just wanted to run you around the thought process i i i [01:27:49] fundamentally disagree with it and i think you're making a massive mistake and i i want to make sure [01:27:53] that we continue to expose what led us to this point the other yes true so if you solve the data [01:28:07] why don't you break around to 25 why don't we say hold on we're about to make a 44 million dollar [01:28:12] capital decision let's wait a minute here yeah so i'll say a couple of things real quick just to [01:28:16] kind of bring us back around one thing that i can just say is true in general right securing that [01:28:22] capital securing that land securing that opportunity to build that is a multi-year process [01:28:27] by itself right so one thing that we know no matter what is that we will need seats in west knoxville [01:28:35] so exactly what the distribution [01:28:37] of that need is you know that's going to fluctuate over time that's part and parcel [01:28:41] of the conversation that we're having but when we have land we've got capital we've [01:28:45] got a construction group we are going to use that right now do we have to [01:28:50] make use of the classrooms themselves immediately not necessarily that's the conversation we're [01:28:56] having today right that's what we're trying to pulse check so i want to go back to the scenario [01:29:00] three right that's that rough point to say that hey we are recognizing as a district that the [01:29:06] projections [01:29:07] are going to potentially invite us to start around or above the 80 threshold for these schools [01:29:14] the byproduct of that would be providing that continuity of experience for our families [01:29:20] who are currently at north shore going to uh farragut middle farragut high that was that [01:29:26] suspicion that we were pulsing right so what we wanted to recognize on scenario three [01:29:31] is that from a planning standpoint that 80 threshold taking it to the 81 83 that is something [01:29:37] that we're labeling as giving us heartburn right with or without the statistical you know anomaly [01:29:43] in the model that is just something that we're labeling we don't feel great about that but if [01:29:48] what we're hearing in the community that there is a desire for this continuity of a feeder pattern [01:29:53] is so great that farragut feels like we can swallow that starting point that's a conversation [01:30:00] that we're having right we're learning two things here not just tonight previous night night before [01:30:07] one is that absolutely not right we want our room to grow we're hearing that we're labeling that [01:30:12] it's a theme we're talking about the other thing that we're hearing is hey that suspicion that [01:30:17] you're pulsing that we want that continuity in that theater pattern that is not actually true [01:30:22] for me and my family i had a phenomenal conversation with a group uh in the parking lot [01:30:26] of the church on tuesday and they were talking about just the diversity of experience that they [01:30:31] felt like they received by starting in north shore elementary school right so that's the type of you [01:30:37] that's very much worth clapping for it's a phenomenal school community that's been [01:30:40] cultivated there so that's what we're collecting right we're recognizing that there's a push and [01:30:45] a pull in every single one of these equations now you said something i do definitely want to [01:30:51] go back to right that we're we diverged from the original plan so i do want to be really [01:30:56] clear that at no point had we drawn zoning lines for the new school and the two schools [01:31:03] i think what you meant and i want to clarify is that we've diverged and that we're not just talking [01:31:07] yes so what i wanted to say is that again what we're pulsing is do we want to talk more broadly [01:31:13] than farragut and we are definitely drawing zoning lines for farragut in december we want to know [01:31:21] from the town of farragut so for our folks who will be zoned for one of those three schools [01:31:25] because you live in the town of farragut one thing i am desperately asking that everybody do in every [01:31:30] single meeting is make sure you give us your street specific feedback because again the only [01:31:37] thing we want to do right now is that we will absolutely be making a proposal for zoning lines [01:31:41] for the town of farragut we have to do that to be able to open the new school [01:31:45] everything beyond that is a community conversation about what do we want to do now [01:31:50] what might we want to do in the future and it is going to color our thinking for years to come [01:31:55] so that is really what we're doing here today do you hear can i get two more minutes [01:32:03] appreciate that you're checking with the lines [01:32:07] that's kind of you to say um i just want to stick on the thread of the data for just a minute [01:32:13] so again i want you i want you to hear the way that we hear and feel how this process is going [01:32:18] so you are going to make a recommendation to the board and you're fully admitting that you [01:32:24] have not done an adequate traffic study you have not i appreciate the precision precision with [01:32:31] which you're using the rules however what i would well i would counter a few things i would not have [01:32:37] i would have done every day of the week and i would have averaged it i would have also done it [01:32:41] in the afternoon to understand if the two front patterns are different uh i beyond that i would [01:32:46] have looked at oh yeah anyway we'll leave it at that so i appreciate the attempt what i don't [01:32:52] understand is how you can think that that type of analysis is sufficient knowing that you're [01:32:57] fundamentally changing the load on the roads and the way that those cars are going to move [01:33:02] you guys are the ones who are you're you're the market mover okay you're introducing a school [01:33:06] that's going to [01:33:08] fundamentally reevaluate how all these things can operate but it feels like that self-awareness [01:33:14] isn't being reflected in the analysis that's being done to help families get comfortable [01:33:18] with the commute time that their children are going to have and and that kind of troubles me [01:33:23] that that hasn't even seemed to enter the psyche that that would be a critical component of how [01:33:27] we're going to design these maps for for our children the other aspect is the the voucher [01:33:33] piece i don't want to be naive that we're talking about one of the wealthiest parts of our school [01:33:37] and what you're doing now is potentially angering a lot of people and risking a significant amount [01:33:43] of attrition that you otherwise wouldn't have i i get that that that data can't be fully known [01:33:49] but there are very effective ways to get at a proxy number for what you think that attrition [01:33:54] would look like it's simple it's fast it doesn't take nearly two years to do and it could have been [01:34:00] done to again make sure that we're looking at numbers that are giving us the best picture [01:34:04] possible so i guess what i'm saying is do you all feel that you're not doing the right thing or i'm [01:34:05] using this information to get rid of the truce or to make that change i'm not going to give you the [01:34:06] answer to that information because i know that the process for that is a lot of work and the way that we work with our [01:34:07] that you have the relevant information that you can actually make a good [01:34:11] recommendation to the board, recognizing that you don't really have accurate [01:34:14] traffic data to be reflected, you don't really know what tuition looks like, we [01:34:19] can't really trust the underlying data for these population trends, and you're [01:34:24] getting feedback, qualitative feedback, that you're planning to analyze in [01:34:28] around five days. Do you actually feel like you have what you would need to do [01:34:32] your job to make a solid recommendation to the board? I feel like we are actively [01:34:37] collecting that, and I would also say when you see the proposal on December [01:34:41] 2nd, if you do not feel that it is accurately reflecting what you are [01:34:47] currently hearing, because you've been to these meetings, and also what you are [01:34:50] sharing with us, share that with us. Do you feel like you have all of the [01:34:56] information that you need to make the right recommendation? Not having read all [01:35:01] of the survey responses, I don't think I would be able to make a solid recommendation to the board. [01:35:02] Do you feel like you have all of the information that you need to make the right recommendation? Not having read all of the survey responses, I [01:35:02] would say I have enough right now to feel like with the addition of those [01:35:09] survey responses, because I do not want to discount what's coming, right? That's [01:35:13] why I'm kind of hedging my words, right? I still want to be able to apply what [01:35:17] we're going to find from families to the extent possible for the next, you know, [01:35:22] five or six days, right? With that added on, as we're continuing to permutate, yes, I [01:35:28] do believe we can make a good recommendation for this year. I think we [01:35:32] are learning a lot. I think we are learning a lot. I think we are learning [01:35:32] a lot to be able to continue contextualizing out your planning. So I'll [01:35:38] take away some of the conditionals for you. Let's assume, which I don't believe [01:35:41] you have enough time to look at the qualitative data, but let's assume that [01:35:44] you do, and let's assume that you're at a point that you've analyzed it, synthesized [01:35:47] it, and now incorporated it into your recommendation, which again, Herculean [01:35:51] task on its face, I simply don't believe that you do, but I'll concede that perhaps you do. So [01:35:57] you've got the qualitative piece, but you, you do have, you're telling us that without [01:36:02] accurate traffic data, without understanding attrition, and without being able to have [01:36:08] true confidence in the population figures that you're looking at, you feel like you [01:36:13] have the sufficient quantitative analysis that can lead you to make the right decision [01:36:17] for this community. I think it will lead us to make a decision that we feel is informed [01:36:23] based on what you all have told us, based on the data that we have at our disposal, [01:36:27] and based on our commitment to being able to open a facility that will serve [01:36:32] the student population now, and continue to serve the student population that we foresee in the [01:36:37] future. And so that is what we are working toward. We would not be having this conversation. We would [01:36:43] not put ourselves on this timeline if we did not believe that we could bring a meaningful proposal [01:36:48] to the board on December 2nd. I think the proof point, I'm hearing your disbelief, right? And so [01:36:53] at this point, this is an exercise in don't believe, all believe, and then we'll see how [01:36:59] that comes together on December 2nd. Okay, well, [01:37:02] you've been generous with your time. You all have been generous and patient with me. Thank you for the responses. [01:37:07] Appreciate the questions. Hi there. First of all, I want to say I'm impressed with how prepared [01:37:17] everyone has been here tonight. Questions? I don't have a pad full of questions I want to ask you. [01:37:22] I'm just a dad who found out this morning that my daughter who goes to AL a lot could get swept up [01:37:29] in all this. Our neighborhood is inside the new lines. Her friend who lives literally across the [01:37:35] street from us is not, and I don't want to see that happen. And so the first question I wanted [01:37:40] to ask is a really simple one and Chad GPT couldn't answer it for me, so I thought I'd ask you. The [01:37:45] students who go to North Shore Elementary, what middle school do they go to? West Valley. Well, [01:37:50] currently North Shore, currently, I'm sorry, currently North Shore has half, currently North [01:37:57] Shore has half of their kids that go to Farragut, but for your family, the areas that you're talking [01:38:03] about, those students go to West Valley. [01:38:05] Okay, you know, so one thing that concerns me, you know, you talked about trying to maintain the feeder system continuity, trying to maintain [01:38:14] national, natural barriers. You know, where my neighborhood is located, which is West Arden, [01:38:20] you're going to be sending us across 140. We'll have to get on the interstate now to get to school. [01:38:24] I saw the numbers you compiled for traffic. You used Tanberra as an example. You had the commute [01:38:30] going from seven minutes to nine minutes. That is simply not reality in the world we live in. I have [01:38:35] to say, both of those commutes at school time in the morning and it's going to go from more like seven minutes to about 15 minutes, which is not true, you know, doubling your traffic time. But you know, I imagine now my daughter, if we get caught up in this, will be making friends at North Shore, who will then be going to Farragut when she's going to West Valley. Whereas if she stays in the AL lot school system, we don't have to worry about that. [01:38:59] Well, if any of these were adopted and, like, let's say that in both scenarios in which, or actually, you're only, you said you're an AL Lots parent, correct? [01:39:09] So in that scenario, the Choteau Peninsula would go to the Farragut schools. [01:39:13] So the Choteau Peninsula is the students that are zoned to Farragut Middle School. [01:39:17] So in that scenario, the students that remain at North Shore Elementary School, including the students that would be zoned out of AL Lots into North Shore, would also be going to West Valley. [01:39:26] So all of North Shore would go to West Valley? [01:39:28] In that scenario, correct. [01:39:30] Okay. [01:39:31] And then the one other question I had, and I'll get out of the way so other people can talk. [01:39:34] Is it possible for you to pull up slide six? [01:39:37] Yeah, absolutely. [01:39:38] You'll have to stop me on whatever you intend. [01:39:40] Yes, just in slide two, whoever said it. [01:39:42] You've been with us long enough to get the reference. [01:39:46] Well, stop me when you think I've reached slide six. [01:39:50] I think I'm going in the wrong direction, actually. [01:39:51] Actually, if you go forward from here, we should be good in just a second. [01:39:55] Maybe three slides. [01:39:57] I have a bit of a... [01:39:58] I have a flag. [01:40:01] That one. [01:40:01] Okay. [01:40:02] It might move and then I'll bring it back. [01:40:03] No? [01:40:04] Again, just sort of hitting on the idea of natural barriers and major road barriers. [01:40:09] I guess the question in my head is how did AL Lots get caught up in all this? [01:40:13] They're not all that overcrowded. [01:40:15] Thank you. [01:40:16] Let's hear it. [01:40:17] We're not all that overcrowded. [01:40:19] We're a small community. [01:40:21] The PTO has meetings in the clubhouse of the neighborhood I live in, which you're talking about rezoning right now. [01:40:28] And there are neighborhoods, you know, there are people who are currently zoned for Rocky Hill, which is much more overcrowded. [01:40:34] If you need to shift students west, there are some down there in the southern area below 140. [01:40:40] You could easily shift over to North Shore. [01:40:42] And I know that's going to anger people, too. [01:40:44] But what's AL Lots doing in this? [01:40:46] I guess that's my question. [01:40:47] No, I mean, I really appreciate the question. [01:40:49] Absolutely. [01:40:50] So essentially, when you're looking at a map this large, right, you have to have some sort of factors, right, that you're going to apply to at least pursue. [01:40:57] And so the factors that we were pursuing and looking at, you know, what could we potentially present to the community as possible accomplishments, right? [01:41:05] One was possible feeder pattern parity. [01:41:07] We've talked about that. [01:41:08] The other was could we potentially draw any lines to eliminate at any school in this immediately surrounding area the need for portables? [01:41:18] And that's really how lots, you know, came into the conversation. [01:41:21] So conversation we had yesterday with the lots community. [01:41:25] I see them raising their hand. [01:41:26] Yes. [01:41:27] They're here again. [01:41:28] Is that, you know what, we're making great use of our portables. [01:41:30] Our kiddos like our portables. [01:41:32] There's a little bit of fresh air that we're getting between, you know, this door and that door. [01:41:35] And so, again, that's the context that we are soaking up. [01:41:38] I said just a moment ago there were some suspicions that we were testing where feeder pattern parity was concerned. [01:41:44] We were also testing, you know, we've heard about portables for years, right, how much we need our portables, you know, and we would love to be in a brick and mortar facility. [01:41:53] And so we're testing that right now. [01:41:55] And if that is not desirable. [01:41:56] That is, again, information that we're soaking up. [01:41:57] And when you ask, you know, how did we come into the conversation? [01:41:58] It was because, essentially, we were able to draw a line that would eliminate that need [01:41:59] if that was about to take the community. [01:42:00] Okay. [01:42:01] Well, thank you for taking my question. [01:42:02] Appreciate it. [01:42:03] Thank you, everyone else, for your questions. [01:42:04] I'm going to go talk to my daughters. [01:42:05] Hi. [01:42:06] I have several questions, and I will do my best to be as brief as possible. [01:42:07] My first one is very simple. [01:42:08] When will the survey close? [01:42:09] So we actually, I got this question yesterday. [01:42:10] And I'm going to go talk to my daughters. [01:42:11] And I'm going to go talk to my daughters. [01:42:12] And I'm going to go talk to my daughters. [01:42:13] And I'm going to go talk to my daughters. [01:42:14] We're not closing it at any given point in time. [01:42:32] Our final look, before we generate any of the finishing touches on the memo, is going [01:42:37] to be December 1st. [01:42:39] I honestly will continue to check it after that just to make sure, you know, there's [01:42:44] no glaring aha that appears. [01:42:45] And if it does, absolutely. [01:42:46] Thank you. [01:42:47] might wind up being a conversation that we have so we don't want to close it prematurely but i [01:42:51] would highly recommend everyone get in their feedback before december 1st okay so our pto [01:42:56] comms person is here let's put november 30th on that post okay i really like the real-time [01:43:01] planning yeah yes let's do that okay um i want to address a couple of things that we've talked [01:43:06] about one is continuity of peers so i have a third grader and i have a sixth grader my sixth grader [01:43:11] goes to west valley i'm a north shore parent um and my sixth grader last year felt that every [01:43:16] single one of his friends was best friends was going to go to fairbairn he was heartbroken by it [01:43:20] that child is thriving at west valley middle school he is with a new set of peers including [01:43:26] abby's son who he adores that is not an issue that is not an issue hard stop um the other thing i [01:43:33] want to address specifically is you talked a lot about teacher formulas when we counted at the [01:43:38] beginning of this meeting there were 46 people in this room 15 of those are staff and teachers [01:43:43] at north shore elementary school and they are not a form [01:43:46] i will say this uh it will always come across a little bit sterile from our purpose we have to [01:43:58] have an answer for you all and that is how we make those allocations but absolutely you are completely [01:44:03] right um our teachers have the reason you all are so passionate about the schools you are passionate [01:44:08] about and that is not lost on us that's right um i do have a specific question from a staff member [01:44:13] with the mission of curriculum the [01:44:16] current print department cannot provide reading curriculum which is the benchmark foundational [01:44:20] literacy to the existing schools how can it also provide for this additional 1400 seats [01:44:26] the print department literally asked for prayers for their copy machine [01:44:31] i appreciate everyone who offered the prayers um so let me get with our academics division one [01:44:35] thing i will say is that we have a runway at least to plan for the new school some of those [01:44:41] may be consumables and so in terms of the new just curricula that will be [01:44:46] resourced at the school there's a degree of planning um i can guarantee has already been [01:44:50] done for that facility and also for our converted uh schools in farragut as well as far as the [01:44:57] consumables go that is a conversation i know our academics division has been navigating um and it [01:45:02] essentially is are we going to outsource we're going to purchase a new printer we will have a [01:45:07] solution uh coming up quickly so thank you good excellent okay my next question is assuming the [01:45:12] motivation behind these scenarios is to truly address overcrowd [01:45:16] how does it make sense to remove roughly half of the student body from the school with the [01:45:21] lowest percentage of capacity what is your true motivation on scenario two and scenario three [01:45:31] so i'll give them a moment and uh here's what i will say true motivation is to if this is [01:45:37] something that we believe we could palette right so true motivation number one is just determining [01:45:41] what is the community sense right into is as to whether or not this is something that we in some [01:45:46] community is something we might be interested in long term right that's motivation number one [01:45:50] motivation number two would be if that is possible to then start having a similar community further [01:45:56] up that corridor to determine how much we might be able to alleviate long term to eliminate or [01:46:04] mitigate the need for capital solutions in other spaces does that make sense [01:46:11] okay um another thing i'll i have two more and then i promise i'll sit down um earlier tonight [01:46:16] said that when you worked with the powell community that your solution there was quote staked and [01:46:21] grounded in feedback from the powell community i would like to share a quote that was shared with [01:46:25] me from a member of the powell community as i shared about these meetings good luck [01:46:31] they aren't afraid to gut a community we in powell tried to fight for a new powell elementary school [01:46:37] or a decent remodel and instead of fixing anything they are yanking kids out to distribute [01:46:42] that to redistribute them to other communities even though they have a lot of money to spend on it [01:46:46] they have lived in powell from elementary school up it's really sad maybe you guys will have better [01:46:51] luck what do you have to say that that sort of specific feedback from a powell family one i hate [01:46:57] um that that is the perception and two that when i say we're starting this conversation right now [01:47:02] about the potential needs further down kingston pike down um north shore driver even in the hard [01:47:09] and valley area it is to avoid putting ourselves in a position similar to powell if we can start [01:47:15] earlier we can start earlier we can start earlier we can start earlier we can start earlier we can [01:47:15] have those conversations to potentially eliminate the need to have the conversation that we had [01:47:23] in powell elementary school because it wasn't as a north shore parent that is how we feel [01:47:28] that is how we feel about north shore the the scenarios that move the peninsula out of north [01:47:33] shore will gut our community hard stop it will get up and i will say that part of again why [01:47:40] we're having the conversation today is to determine that because we're not in the same [01:47:45] position today that we were in powell that is the difference okay my last question is based on the [01:47:52] community feedback that you have received over the course of these three meetings including tonight [01:47:57] notwithstanding the line that is still behind me um which scenario has the strongest community [01:48:03] support that's a great question actually right now and i'm going to do not hold me here because [01:48:08] it's going to change by the minute right but just final look at the survey so i'll answer in two [01:48:15] at the surveys there is some interest in a version of scenario one that we're seeing in the survey so [01:48:21] we actually have heard from some of our hardened valley families uh i think they're a little [01:48:25] intrigued right um and so we've seen that coming across in the surveys i would say actually across [01:48:31] uh all three community meetings um the resounding answer is let's just you know maybe him in our [01:48:38] focus uh across the three scenarios and focus a little bit more closely on farragut i think that's [01:48:42] completely all right so then my follow-up question is how are you to how are you prepared [01:48:49] to defend a final proposal that does not align with what you just said should the final proposal [01:48:56] not align with what you just said how will you defend that to the thousand hundreds i'll say [01:49:00] hundreds hundreds of people that have shown up this week and that have responded to the [01:49:04] messages great question so i would say we're going to have to have some really good survey [01:49:08] data right to back that up to say that it somehow outweighed what i just shared [01:49:12] but our commitment is to continue to process along the way and i think the lion's share of [01:49:18] the feedback we anticipated has been heard over the last three days so i'm not anticipating a lot [01:49:23] of shift at this point unless the survey responses really just surprise us right thank you thank you [01:49:31] you've lost your sling yeah congratulations thank you [01:49:38] my disguise didn't work i don't really have a whole lot to say after mr green jacket talked [01:49:44] over there like god that guy is so smart anyways i do think it's ironic though the traffic question [01:49:50] i think is a good one because if i was a private citizen and i was going to build a 40 to 50 million [01:49:56] project and it was going to affect hundreds of vehicles and thousands of human beings moving [01:50:02] around the city i don't think i would get approval for that without the traffic study [01:50:06] so i do think that's that's very interesting that you guys can kind of do that but anyways i digress [01:50:14] at the north shore and that's that's my interest you see my sweatshirt um and and i think it's [01:50:20] very disingenuous and i think it's very important right now that everybody understands that [01:50:23] the north shore rezoning is a vote to rezone that whole red district i know they're like it's just a [01:50:30] conversation we want to have long conversations about it we don't want to we're not necessarily [01:50:35] going to do that we just want to have conversations and this opens up the door to have conversation [01:50:38] you know what's a fact nothing is stopping you from having all the long droned out conversations [01:50:48] you want to have without rezoning a school in north shore that does not have to be rezoned [01:50:55] right now in fact in fact the the importance of rezoning it will go down next year because [01:51:03] a lots the attendance is going to go down along with other schools in that red district i know [01:51:08] mr ryan there said it's cyclical every school district is cyclical and you can't account for [01:51:13] that but yeah it is cyclical but as of right now your words not mine we are not in a crisis mode [01:51:20] next year based on what i've heard from principals from this meeting we are not going to be in a [01:51:25] crisis mode and my if i'm guessing it's going to be less of a crisis mode next year which leads me [01:51:31] to believe you're not suddenly going to jump into a crisis mode in three years so you have at least [01:51:36] three years in my small peanut-sized room [01:51:38] frame to deal with conversations that you can have all day long i would love to sit at starbucks [01:51:45] and just hear you talk corey i think those conversations are right there for you to have [01:51:51] you don't have to rezone not to mention you haven't given any salient arguments to actually [01:51:56] rezone north shore and and let me expand on that and this leads to my question of how you can [01:52:00] justify the rezoning proposals for north shore i've all i've heard from you in the last two days [01:52:08] or maybe or there's a chance we could or maybe the numbers will change we won't have to do it so [01:52:15] it is baffling to me beyond words that you could actually propose or heaven forbid [01:52:21] rezone north shore based on ifs and buts and maybes and coulda possibly ifs when you have [01:52:28] at least three years to have all the conversations you want to have furthermore i think you know the [01:52:32] one the one argument that you you like to do is you like to add up all the numbers in that red [01:52:38] it's four twenty right it's it's 420. right that's impressive i actually wrote it down [01:52:45] i was afraid i wouldn't remember it and that number is my friend in the green jacket [01:52:50] smart guy over there um acknowledge that it's based on that hard 80 percent occupancy rate [01:52:56] and and that that number just kind of bothers me ryan said eight percent is an industry best [01:53:02] practice right he said that yesterday he said it's a marker sign and you said it's something [01:53:08] going in that [01:53:08] it's something it indicates that something is going on there that bears a [01:53:12] closer look it's really hard for me to believe that because it really seems [01:53:19] like a number that is just convenient to manipulate based on what proposal you [01:53:24] are trying to put forth let me expand because Ryan you did a very good job in [01:53:29] all three presentations of making an argument that Cory's numbers are [01:53:34] actually wrong and I thank you for that because in your proposal in 2030 you [01:53:40] said the Farragut schools would be at an occupancy of eighty four point seven [01:53:44] eighty seven point eight and eighty eight point three occupancy that bears a [01:53:51] closer look apparently to the industry standards now the ironic part is if you [01:53:55] look at Farragut Hardin Valley it's been accepted fact that those are the two [01:54:00] communities that are going to grow the most Hardin Valley the most Farragut the [01:54:03] second most [01:54:04] and if you look back at what you guys did to prepare to build that school that [01:54:08] that that study you did that justifies a forty four million dollar investment [01:54:13] into a school that's going to hold 1,400 people you forecast a certain student [01:54:17] population just within Farragut to fill those schools I don't think anybody's [01:54:22] giving you forty four million dollars if that's not compelling right and so now [01:54:27] the argument gentlemen mr. Dr. Adams said the first night that the growth [01:54:34] wasn't as much as we expected you said that yesterday the growth wasn't as fast [01:54:38] as we expected nowhere in any of these three conversations did they say that [01:54:43] the growth wouldn't come they only said that the growth wasn't as fast as we [01:54:50] expected which leads me to believe that there [01:54:53] still is growth coming that that original proposal unless that proposal [01:54:57] was wrong or unless that proposal was fraudulent whatever it is if that was right it's saying [01:55:04] growth is going to come and if i'm just using the very simple low-hanging fruit of someone again not [01:55:10] high intelligence all you got to do is look around this city and go there is not a square foot of [01:55:15] dirt that will not hold a housing unit in 10 25 10 20 years from now it's you can bet your life [01:55:24] on it right so let's just so we know that farragut is is one of the fastest not the second fastest [01:55:30] growing community that we that we're talking about that being said it seems like you've made [01:55:34] a very very good argument that we should use those same percentages to evaluate the red district [01:55:42] seems like in fact if you switch those numbers you could make a much more compelling argument [01:55:48] to use those 85 87 88 to evaluate the crowding in those red districts if you do that which i [01:55:56] thank you for making the argument for me if you do that [01:55:59] the percent that number that 40 420 which is the only thing the only compelling argument you have [01:56:07] to rezoning north shore that number goes down to less than half that's if you lose the use [01:56:12] the lowest percentage that that mr ryan has proposed in fair in schools that's the lowest [01:56:18] if you use the highest which again it's hard to argue with the logic that he has made that you [01:56:23] could use that percentage and cut and paste it in those red zones which the guy in the green jacket [01:56:29] dare anybody to disagree with him also said those are very mature communities that are not in any [01:56:36] way shape or form going to grow as fast as farragut if you apply the highest percentage [01:56:41] it goes down to almost non-existent and this is at a time that north shore [01:56:46] their their attendance their capacity is going to go down a lots is going to go down you are [01:56:52] doing this on ifs and buts and dreams and maybes you can have all the conversations you want without [01:56:59] rezoning a school that does not need to be rezoned you can have all the conversations so that turns [01:57:06] blue and again back to mr green jacket that leads me to the fact that how how this how this isn't [01:57:13] just about the original plan farragut only or maybe a version of of proposal one is beyond me [01:57:22] because if this ends up being a rezoning of north shore i'll tell you what there's going to have to [01:57:28] be a lot of people that answer a lot of questions i'm not going to be able to answer a lot of questions [01:57:29] that no facts support literally no facts that you can use using your own words your own numbers your [01:57:37] own statistics that you presented over three days support rezoning north shore so i hope um i guess [01:57:43] my question would be how can you but i don't really have a question i guess you can just [01:57:47] let it go but um yeah i think that's all i got thank you so my takeaway is nobody's [01:57:58] arguing with mr green jacket [01:58:04] like mr green jacket i want to quickly preface my question by sharing that my husband and i are [01:58:10] both special educators so my question is centered around supports for the students that we have [01:58:15] dedicated our careers to when evaluating scenarios two and three is knox county considering the [01:58:22] impact on existing school programming not just building capacity and enrollment specifically [01:58:28] how will the district ensure north shore does not lose special education resources staffing [01:58:33] as well as encore opportunities as a result of rezoning if our population drops to below 60 [01:58:40] i want to make sure that we're considering the impact on the students who remain at north shore [01:58:44] not just the students who are being moved will special education staffing allocations be [01:58:50] determined by overall enrollment or by individual student needs and iep requirements if our [01:58:56] enrollment decreases under scenarios two and three could that result in reduced staffing even if the [01:59:03] students remaining at north shore stay the same because a school can have fewer students without [01:59:09] having fewer students who require those more intensive supports absolutely so i can say this [01:59:15] in two ways um so for our just general education teachers right that is a formula and i know um [01:59:22] that the the service that our teachers provide well exceeds that formula right and so that's [01:59:27] not a perception of the service that's being provided but that is a formula that is applied [01:59:33] as far as the service needs of students with ieps goes we are also looking at that caseload we are [01:59:39] making sure that schools are resourced according to their caseload needs so that's not the same as [01:59:44] an enrollment rate to your point um i may have an enrollment that is reflected that is dropping [01:59:49] i may have service needs that are increasing right um and so those are two different factors that [01:59:53] are evaluated separately and honored separately are those formulas or ratio or are specific [01:59:59] student hours being looked at [02:00:02] so for just [02:00:03] general education and for classroom teachers that's going to be a ratio for our service [02:00:07] hour computation and i will say dr brown is not with us tonight um so he's over our student [02:00:13] services division but we're looking at service hours for caseload thank you thank you and [02:00:23] honestly i'd like to thank you so much for all the time you're putting into this i know for [02:00:27] everyone else it seems very short-sighted but i've been involved in this since like [02:00:31] 2018 when i became an introduction to farragut graduate and became really well versed in [02:00:37] municipalities and how farragut functions that means you're still excited about that i didn't [02:00:41] really appreciate that you screwed up that first school build and you know we won't even talk about [02:00:46] that but that's why we're just now getting to a new school in farragut but i'm also part of pto [02:00:52] in the fis and fp um fps and so i'm also a business owner beard graduate that also crossed [02:01:01] the enemy lines into farragut so i get it people i get it better than most 1999 i've been here ever [02:01:07] that being said i'm not a numbers person however i'm a business person and i'm a mom who cares [02:01:13] so i think where you have lost a lot of trust is when you see the cte closing at the announcement [02:01:19] yesterday of the school and things like that when you all like vote in for your own raises but then [02:01:24] we're cutting four million dollar budgets and all of that stuff has lost a lot of trust with you all [02:01:29] but that being said i'm not a person that brings problems without solutions also i have really big [02:01:37] respect for the teachers who have been teaching third fourth and fifth grade who haven't really [02:01:41] had a lot of experience in the past 20 years with the little kids and that's for sure concern for [02:01:48] them so i guess my first question is what's the problem with just leaving the primary the primary [02:01:54] and the intermediate i know you guys have data that says it's better but we also have some of [02:01:59] the best test scores and have proven our track record that we rock when it comes to education [02:02:04] and north shore you can keep your north shore we don't really want you [02:02:07] but we'll take it because we love you and we're not that hard to deal with however what is the [02:02:13] problem with keeping it like that and then figuring out the fair get rezoning lines and [02:02:18] by the way traffic studies you want to talk about kingston pike that's a highway which means you got [02:02:22] to go to nashville for those traffic studies when are you doing that where is that communication and [02:02:28] when are you actually expecting those traffic studies to be pushed through from the nashville [02:02:32] perspective because you can't do anything here like locally at the knoxville school of law and [02:02:37] county level and also as someone who has worked with the pto on the grounds it is infuriating to [02:02:44] deal with kcs school system being a farragut resident because we have our hands tied farragut [02:02:51] cannot pour money into their own schools because we're technically knox county so how do you guys [02:02:57] propose to fix all those problems but i want to know can we go on record as far as putting on [02:03:05] maximum cap times for bus [02:03:07] is because that's a big issue do you plan on doing that you mean maximum time for students to be on [02:03:13] buses absolutely we already have one okay and what is it 90 minutes so an hour and a half you're [02:03:19] welcome that was an important question you all have missed so there is a uh so that's state law [02:03:24] yeah state law is 90 minutes that is not our practice what's the average our practice are [02:03:28] the average for elementary middle or high school elementary so elementary is about 27 minutes [02:03:35] middle school is about 32 high school [02:03:37] is about 35. our our practice is like when my guys are routing we're looking at an hour max [02:03:44] okay so why can't we just keep it fis and mps so uh that really would go back to one it would take [02:03:52] a board vote um because the board has already voted to make that conversion and at the end of [02:03:57] the day when we're talking about three new facilities in the community or one new facility [02:04:02] and potentially two existing facilities we had that opportunity just to determine could we do it [02:04:07] anything that we believe would be better for kids and that conversation with the community at that [02:04:11] time aligned with best practice research to say that yes there was agreement in the community [02:04:16] to um agree essentially with the research that we had shared to make that conversion and so now [02:04:22] that that decision is already made at this point walking that back to go against best practice [02:04:27] really just isn't an avenue that we're pursuing what i will say though is that the point you [02:04:31] raised regarding you know what about my third fourth and fifth grade teachers teaching k2 you [02:04:37] have some folks who have experience teaching k2 right who are excited to go back i would say most [02:04:41] third fourth and fifth grade teachers um will probably prefer to say third fourth and fifth [02:04:45] grade teachers right they're very different kiddos and so that's that next step conversation uh oh [02:04:50] yeah it's a different world um and i would say that our kids are two friends probably feel the [02:04:54] same about three times right so in terms of recognizing the talents that each of our teachers [02:04:59] bring into the four right that's going to be the conversation that we're having with farragut [02:05:03] primary with farragut intermediate because we have the talent pool we [02:05:07] have the passion pool now it's a matter of just matching those to our student population so is [02:05:12] there potentially going to be some moving yeah there's potentially going to be some moving [02:05:16] that's a lot of conversation with our principals over those two schools it's a lot of conversation [02:05:20] with our teachers to determine you know what do they want to do um and we're going to be sorting [02:05:25] all that out over the course of the next semester so as we think about planning ahead uh part of why [02:05:31] we are pushing so hard for a december vote on this is so that we can begin that process because we [02:05:37] don't want to begin that process and it is going to take a semester to be able to say in good faith [02:05:42] we are prepared we want to do that starting in january okay and as a developer i understand how [02:05:48] the line has to keep moving i mean progress has changed and no one likes it but we have to deal [02:05:53] with it so that being said when i did my own analytical data thank you jim and i i gave all [02:06:00] the mls i did all the research that i know and it said number two is the best scenario for the [02:06:07] for the social economic for all of the rest of the things that we are equaling into this and i'm [02:06:14] sorry that you know people are going to be mad but at the end of the day the school is going to open [02:06:18] regardless of whether or not we all agree or not so i wonder how long will it take before we go [02:06:25] back and rezone because obviously you're going to build another school we're going to have to [02:06:31] if we keep growing at this rate when would that timeline be 2030 i don't think that we would have [02:06:37] for the farragut area 2030 deep west valley you know so for hardin valley it would really depend [02:06:43] i mean you saw the map right actually it might still be able to shoot the map um and so essentially [02:06:47] that is an area that we are keeping a pulse on right the reason that they are part of this [02:06:50] conversation that's bringing 57 000 constituents to kingston pike in deep west ferry they are [02:06:58] moving people from that that's how the church works i've been in communication with them that [02:07:02] means you're going to be bombarded in that area sooner have you taken that statistic [02:07:07] into consideration when you've been dealing with these models because i didn't i appreciate that [02:07:12] question i'm going to assume that that's part of the planning conversations that mr dillingham has [02:07:15] been having with knoxville knox county planning what i would say is that as of right now our [02:07:20] capital plan is a plan for five years at this point in time on that capital improvement plan [02:07:26] we do not have another new construction in this area on the capital improvement plan so we can [02:07:32] really only sustain probably one major solution at a time and right now even [02:07:37] is very very tight and we have a very large county so our next scheduled look at the county from a [02:07:44] capital solution standpoint right now is slated for south knoxville beyond that that's a continued [02:07:49] conversation with our board just to continue to look at those areas of need part of why we want [02:07:54] to maximize every resource that we have at our disposal is that this is a major investment in [02:07:59] west knoxville right and we just had a major investment in west knoxville in the form of [02:08:03] mill creek so at the end of the day when we think about the math and our opportunity to potentially [02:08:09] alleviate overcrowding we are probably not coming back to west knoxville for the foreseeable future [02:08:14] gotcha yep thank you so much with this and i really do appreciate it i would probably leave [02:08:19] north shore alone because they got plenty of money to sue you and do all the things and they [02:08:23] really don't like change but hardin valley loves new schools and so they're not even here because [02:08:28] they're like it really we win anyways so just take that into your [02:08:33] brain and algorithm realize that guy's going to be up here another half an hour if he doesn't get [02:08:38] his way thanks appreciate it thank you you've been so patient welcome to the front of the line [02:08:45] why have you involved al lights in this with only 41 students over in a declining population since [02:08:53] 2022 as opposed to say a rocky hill that has a multitude higher amount of overage [02:09:04] i'll go back to what i told the gentleman over here so at the end of the day it really just was [02:09:09] a look at what we could accomplish with the space we had available and so with the factors that we [02:09:13] were looking at eliminating the need for portables that's the only school based on this permutation [02:09:21] that we could have eliminated the need for portals in and i know that maybe that is not [02:09:25] a compelling argument that is just the reason it made it onto the presentation that's the reason [02:09:30] we're having a conversation okay let's think about this [02:09:34] you have 41 student overage i believe there are two classes that are in the portables currently [02:09:41] why could those not be used for art or music and all your students are in the building without [02:09:46] moving a person and let me tell you i know from experience having a mom that did this kind of stuff [02:09:54] if you take portables and they're just storage and sitting there y'all will not invest the money to [02:10:00] keep them up when you need them so it's better for them to stay in use than to be relegated to storage [02:10:06] and then that's the kind of feedback we are looking for in the survey so that's what we're [02:10:10] looking at please fill that out oh don't worry i will appreciate it dead with a lot it's having [02:10:18] a declining population can i get you to commit that you will not touch a school like lots in [02:10:27] your proposal yes or no that you will not affect them this time around in december i'm not asking a [02:10:38] for next year or the year after in december will you right here right now say they are not going [02:10:43] to be affected in december does it seem like that is the direction the trend is kind of leading us [02:10:50] yes will i make a commitment around a decision in this meeting i won't because i've begun every [02:10:56] single meeting saying by design decisions won't be made in these meetings so we want to honor the [02:11:01] feedback that we are receiving does it seem like the feedback that we are receiving will lead us [02:11:06] away from that right now it does [02:11:08] okay then uh our board members that are here will you promise not to vote for that yes or no [02:11:18] ah i see um with ao lots having a declining population or any other school that has a [02:11:24] declining population that might be affected in any scenario put forward officially [02:11:29] will you say that you will not vote for a proposal that has a school with a declining population [02:11:35] that the problem will fix itself yes or no it is a yes or no question [02:12:09] for you it's not say yes or no but i mean without looking at all of the information [02:12:17] a whole picture of everything and i don't want to say something here and then do something different [02:12:24] for it but your point is well received and i do agree with you that it does not make sense [02:12:30] for a declining population that having a declining population that isn't just one year it's a trend [02:12:40] since 2022. then our enrollment trends have grown you know um you want to go see increase our enrollment [02:12:43] has been falling. We have a happy stable community. I understand the idea of you using roads and [02:12:49] all other geography reasons, but keep in mind the most important thing about residing is [02:12:55] community. Yes. And we don't want to move. By a show of hands, does anybody here want [02:13:01] to move? Okay. You want to be popular? You want to recover some credibility? There's [02:13:09] your answer. I appreciate it. You basically, you just kind of started to summarize how [02:13:33] your thinking is evolving. I want to make sure I'm capturing this correctly. You are [02:13:38] hearing that there's actually some excitement in Park Valley to get moved. And what was [02:13:45] the other reason? The other big thing is honestly the takeaway from the meetings. Or I would [02:13:50] actually say the big takeaway for me from the meetings is the concentrated focus in [02:13:53] the Farragut area. And that's not surprising. [02:13:55] This is the conversation we knew was coming. Which gets us to scenario one or potentially [02:14:06] a .... When we've done this in the past. [02:14:10] Yes. Fourth scenario is probably the direction we were always headed. [02:14:13] So my first question is what would happen... You said, I'm not anticipating a lot of shift [02:14:21] away from those two things, which... Yes, you said I'm not anticipating a shift between [02:14:23] those two things. Exactly. [02:14:24] Which... Sorry. [02:14:25] not anticipating a lot of shift away from those two findings which those two findings do keep [02:14:31] north shore lots and i know you guys want to pretend it's not this but bluegrass rocky hill [02:14:35] west hills beard and sequoia out of the conversation right now what would have to change [02:14:42] over the next week for us to be back in the picture great question um i will say that if [02:14:51] uh the population we thought existed that has not seemed to emerge comes out and says absolutely we [02:14:57] want to go to farragut right in volumes right um that could alter our thinking that is one thing [02:15:03] that could potentially come across that would be worth us leaning into if i believed that existed [02:15:09] um i imagine they would already have arrived uh so i mean it's possible that does not feel likely to [02:15:17] me and you all know your neighbors better than i do is what i would say so it feels to you like [02:15:23] scenario two and scenario three are not going to [02:15:27] be central to your proposal on december 2nd i love west knoxville [02:15:35] i would say that that feels reflective of the comment i gave a moment ago [02:15:47] so we okay um okay i want to explore questions that i don't see here and i'm hoping that you [02:16:00] can take a walk with me through a piece of data because i like to crunch numbers too [02:16:05] okay so we one of the things that makes you nervous about scenario three [02:16:12] is opening two of the farragut schools at 81 and 83 capacity one of the things that is [02:16:21] one of the major drawbacks of scenario one the hearted valley plan is that you guys like to get [02:16:27] reports and actually i would say uh that is true but i would say the major drawback [02:16:35] to scenario one is that it is insufficient to the need that we are projecting there [02:16:40] okay so it essentially it buys us time we do not look at that as a wholesale solution to the [02:16:48] problem we have identified in that area right but a capital solution is probably far off definitely [02:16:56] not in the next five years last night you said definitely not you said probably in the next 20 [02:17:01] years this is going to happen in park valley i would say definitely not in the next five years [02:17:05] i mean honestly just our current relationship with the budget in general um makes me believe [02:17:10] it is as far off as possible now at the end of the day when students arrive we have to serve them and [02:17:15] so some of that is contingent on just what happens from a development standpoint yep okay so i want [02:17:21] to talk a little bit about scenario one and i for any hard development i am not saying that this [02:17:28] is what should happen i am just i want [02:17:31] i want i want to understand your thinking here so scenario one has the new school opening at 66 [02:17:39] capacity and it has hardened valley opening at 85 or not opening it has hard valley next year at 85 [02:17:49] harden valley's capacity without portables is 1016 kids and next year in scenario one you would have [02:18:01] 60 kids at hardened valley someone asked about this the first night they said [02:18:06] i don't get it hardened valley is under its capacity with for without portables but you're [02:18:12] saying we can't get rid of portables and you essentially said they're going to grow rapidly [02:18:16] enough that the portables are going to have to come back we would not be removing those portals [02:18:22] so what is the number that hardened valley elementary school has to get down to in order for [02:18:31] portables to actually go away honestly until there's less land to develop in hardened valley [02:18:38] even if we programmatically can move students out of portables and that's the decision the [02:18:42] principals are making all the time right um so we have that ebb and flow you get to a point at [02:18:47] which i may no longer need my portables for instructional space maybe i converted into a plc [02:18:52] room right we're going to try because whoever spoke and said you know when you convert it to [02:18:57] storage space right it does kind of fall into disrepair not untrue right so there are purposes [02:19:01] that could be used or portables could be leveraged for different purposes beyond just instructional [02:19:06] usage right so until we are pretty darn certain that we do not need those the cost of demolishing [02:19:13] or moving them really is not prudent for us and so i would say from a hardened valley standpoint [02:19:20] sorry i have a little bit of rework but that's distracting um so from a hardened valley standpoint [02:19:25] given the sheer amount of developable land that they have i cannot imagine a foreseeable future [02:19:33] at least in the like runway ahead of us that we remove those portables unless you feel otherwise [02:19:38] they're probably there for the long haul how they're used as a programmatic decision on the [02:19:42] principal's part they're cottages yeah they're cottages learning cottages yes so if so here's [02:19:51] what i can't figure out to be comfortable enough [02:19:59] with the 81 and 83 i know you said you're not comfortable with it but you're comfortable enough [02:20:04] you were comfortable enough to ask if you all were comfortable does that make sense [02:20:08] because again that was that was the question of that entire scenario was built on do you want that [02:20:14] continuity for those elementary school middle school high school students enough that that [02:20:20] threshold is worth it right that was the question we're asking so here's what i can figure out [02:20:27] you you're moving [02:20:29] 150 something hardened valley kids down to farragut and in the in the chodo scenario [02:20:36] you're saying okay we'll we'll do 83 and 81 it's fine it's not great but it's fine [02:20:42] it's good enough whatever there's a solution where you could move up to 200 [02:20:49] additional hardened valley kids into the new school and still only hit 80 percent [02:20:57] why [02:20:59] aren't you comfortable with proposing that why are we so uncomfortable or why are we so comfortable [02:21:04] with moving your short kids to get here get past that 80 but we're not going to move [02:21:11] actually that's what makes sense to give an opportunity it gives even more runway [02:21:19] for hard and valley especially if you don't intend to demolish the portables in which [02:21:24] case your capacity at hard valley is actually much higher than 10 15. [02:21:29] but why did we see such a conservative movement of kids [02:21:35] from Hardin Valley to Farragut [02:21:38] when you were okay moving three to 400 North Shore kids [02:21:43] and 200 Locks kids? [02:21:45] And so for Proctor. [02:21:46] Yeah, so the quick answer goes back to [02:21:49] when I said these were not proposals, that mattered, right? [02:21:52] So to assess, we're essentially trying to pull scopes [02:21:55] through on that. [02:22:00] As I'm tabbing through, [02:22:01] because it's gonna take me a minute. [02:22:02] If you recall, when we looked at scenarios one [02:22:05] and scenario two, we were talking about different sets [02:22:09] of or different portions of the Hardin Valley population. [02:22:13] This is just not, but I'll use my hands right now. [02:22:26] So if you think about it, [02:22:27] the two scenarios that touch Hardin Valley. [02:22:28] In scenario one, we were talking about [02:22:30] kind of the Southwestern line of Hardin Valley, right? [02:22:34] So essentially what we wanted was a scenario [02:22:37] that would allow us to pulse check the community to say, [02:22:40] hey, how do you think [02:22:41] how do you in this affected area feel about this movement? [02:22:45] The other scenario that affects Hardin Valley [02:22:49] takes the Southeastern side. [02:22:51] So essentially we have separated those two areas [02:22:54] just to pulse check whether or not there's a difference [02:22:57] in that appetite, right? [02:22:58] In a perfect world, we could have done the exact same thing [02:23:00] in scenario three, where we're talking about [02:23:02] kind of the Choteau Peninsula moving in. [02:23:05] The reason, honestly, we could not do that [02:23:08] is because of the Concord Round Valley. [02:23:11] So in a perfect world, we would have loved [02:23:13] to divide up that area to find out, you know, [02:23:16] hey, drive times or just appetite in general, [02:23:19] do they differentiate on this side versus this side, right? [02:23:23] And at the end of the day, we couldn't [02:23:25] because there's that one entry exit point. [02:23:28] So we really could only talk about the Choteau Peninsula [02:23:31] as the Choteau Peninsula. [02:23:33] At the end of the day, that was also the complicating factor [02:23:36] in taking us to that 80% threshold. [02:23:38] So essentially that was our communication to say, look, [02:23:41] if this is appealing to you all, [02:23:44] the only way to do this is to take you up to, [02:23:48] if not beyond, that 80% threshold. [02:23:52] But you don't want the 80% threshold. [02:23:54] You actually would like to be in a perfect world. [02:23:58] If we were to feel comfortable as a district, [02:24:00] just ideally, everyone would sit right around 80%, right? [02:24:05] Okay. [02:24:06] I mean, that'd be a perfect world. [02:24:07] Okay. [02:24:08] Okay. [02:24:09] I just, I want to do a looming. [02:24:11] I wanted to illuminate the fact that if you're saying [02:24:18] we can't get rid of portables, [02:24:20] perhaps you can at least temporarily. [02:24:21] I know you wouldn't destroy them, but yes. [02:24:24] And moving more Hardin Valley kids into the new school, [02:24:28] if you want so badly for the new school to have more kids, [02:24:32] that actually gives a lot of relief to Hardin Valley. [02:24:35] And there's a lot of runway between 66% and 80% [02:24:40] for you to move more of those kids. [02:24:41] Now, I do think you have a little bit of a tricky situation [02:24:44] because as far as I know, and you're sure, [02:24:46] the only people who were actually notified of these meetings [02:24:49] were the people who were affected on your minutes. [02:24:51] And that's you for Hardin Valley too. [02:24:52] You've heard that too. [02:24:53] Right. [02:24:54] We were only exclusively talking essentially [02:24:56] about that southern line anyway. [02:24:58] It doesn't really make sense to exceed [02:25:00] any of that southern line. [02:25:02] The reason the scenarios were drawn in such a way [02:25:05] that we've got one happens in Area 1, [02:25:07] one happens in Area 2, again, was to give us a way, [02:25:10] in the survey to pulse [02:25:12] check whether or not there were differences of opinion [02:25:14] so that's not to say [02:25:16] and again I have yet [02:25:18] to see us ever [02:25:19] take a survey [02:25:21] sorry it's 9 o'clock [02:25:23] take a scenario and just deliver [02:25:26] one of these scenarios to the board [02:25:27] I also want to [02:25:32] highlight I think Amanda made the point earlier [02:25:34] that if you [02:25:36] do decide to really hone in [02:25:37] which I hope you do [02:25:39] it's what was told to the community [02:25:41] and it really is what makes the most sense [02:25:44] I forgot about the temple but oh my gosh [02:25:46] we should be thinking about that [02:25:48] you have talked [02:25:52] a lot the last two nights about a generous transfer [02:25:54] solution there can be [02:25:56] a generous transfer solution [02:25:57] to the new school I have to imagine [02:26:00] that there are some families in the Choteau [02:26:02] area who would take it and there are probably [02:26:04] some families in Hardin Valley who would take it [02:26:06] and it gives you actually [02:26:07] all of the flexibility [02:26:09] for the future that you actually want [02:26:11] I am and I'm also gonna express [02:26:16] some personal frustration [02:26:18] and so we're going to fix this [02:26:20] but essentially one of our [02:26:23] one of the reasons we pursued [02:26:25] the project that we did last year [02:26:27] to overhaul our [02:26:29] programmatic capacity for [02:26:30] a really yes you began as a full circle moment [02:26:33] right so the precipitating factor [02:26:37] to that project really was um the fact that we have yet to be able to like well as last year [02:26:46] we had yet to be able to land on a capacity formula that we felt was real enough to allow us [02:26:53] to more openly um allow to oh i'm going to start that entire sentence over sorry nine o'clock talk [02:27:01] to you guys a lot in the last three days essentially our prior capacity formula really [02:27:05] did not feel resilient enough to the reality of our schools to allow us to open more voluntary [02:27:10] transfers in so there's a little bit of a chicken egg situation when you're talking [02:27:16] not about resenting transfers so grandfather transfers are shockingly easier right because [02:27:21] you're already working with established zones we know exactly which because you're talking about a [02:27:25] very um captured kind of sheltered group of kids right when you just have that general transfer in [02:27:31] the problem we're up against is we want to give families an opportunity to actually [02:27:35] want [02:27:35] to transfer right and very few families are thinking about wanting to transfer [02:27:39] in the fall families start thinking about wanting to transfer in the spring we have to start [02:27:44] staffing schools in february so there's a little bit of this chicken egg problem which is that we [02:27:49] can't accidentally over enroll through transfers our schools that have physical capacity but don't [02:27:57] have the staffed capacity to accommodate that so what this is a very long answer and i apologize [02:28:05] but [02:28:05] we went through that programmatic capacity work last year to essentially identify down to the seat [02:28:11] level and that's why prior to this year you've never really heard us talk about seats because [02:28:14] we never felt like we could be confident enough in our capacity to get it to the seat level we [02:28:20] now feel like we're confident enough in our capacity to get it to the seat level [02:28:24] that now will allow for us to start kind of building in this opportunity [02:28:29] to provide for an early cushion from that priority transfer window [02:28:34] into our school. [02:28:36] so we are headed in that direction i think i would be lying to say that we feel confident [02:28:41] enough that that will go into effect starting next year but any school with capacity right [02:28:48] and that's what we're identifying and so in any of these scenarios probably the likely one that [02:28:52] we're talking about um making it to the board there's probably going to be quite a bit of [02:28:56] capacity right um to play with in the farragut area so what we would then be able to do and [02:29:02] part of the reason that eighty percent threshold is kind of magical to us right. [02:29:05] Right is that that would be our cutoff [02:29:07] point right to tell ourselves that for voluntary transfers in we're not going to take a [02:29:13] community over that threshold that would be unfair to that community so essentially [02:29:18] yes we're headed in that direction but we need to live with our map for just a little bit [02:29:22] longer before we really feel good about starting to stack it up with staffing allocations. [02:29:26] Yeah one thing I want to just tack on just about parent i'm not... [02:29:30] currently obviously, [02:29:31] But, okay! [02:29:34] Okay, correct me if i'm wrong. [02:29:35] wrong. Yes, Liz. After class assignments were already sent out this year at the intermediate [02:29:44] school, a handful of students had to be emailed by the school to say, we have an unprecedented [02:29:53] surge in enrollment of third graders, and we have to add an entirely new third grade class. [02:29:59] Yes. So I think that's just like an anecdote that I want you to hold on to. Like, [02:30:05] Farragut is being surprised even a week before school starts by surges in enrollment, [02:30:12] and we can't ignore that in these scenarios. Okay, I, well, you know what, I'm going to wait. [02:30:28] If you're not going to do two or three, I'm going to wait. [02:30:32] So, I'm losing steam. I had some teachers help me with the numbers, [02:30:43] and they still aren't mapping, so I would be very curious to know what happened between [02:30:47] 2024 and 2026 to allow another combined 500 capacity between both of the schools, so I [02:30:56] still think something's off. But I'm too tired to finish talking about it tonight. [02:31:02] But I would encourage you guys to please look at that before you continue trying to bring [02:31:07] more people into the Farragut schools, because this new building was supposed to be a solution [02:31:11] to Farragut overcrowding. [02:31:13] and I would hate for all of our schools to be opening at over 80% capacity and [02:31:19] uprooting other people from there where they want to be. That's all. Even if you [02:31:24] don't hang out with me with my laptop after I promise I will be open and we [02:31:28] will be figuring out. I can't play North Shore but I'll be ready to go. So this is the first meeting I've been able to make it to just [02:31:37] congratulations Kendall. So and a lot of what I was going to ask and talk about maybe doesn't necessarily warrant as much time. I do want to say that the feel of the [02:31:54] presentation was that all of this is urgent. It all has to be decided by [02:31:59] December. [02:32:00] We're talking like all of the schools that are involved. But now in the Q&A [02:32:04] you've said multiple times we have time. This isn't critical aside from the three [02:32:10] Farragut schools. Yes that's critical. It's going to open when they need and know who's going where. But the rest of the schools, Hardin Valley, North Shore, AOLOTS, the other West Knoxville schools, it's not urgent. And so I think it's kind of created this like false urgency that has gotten you a lot of community response. [02:32:29] So I think it's kind of created this like false urgency that has gotten you a lot of community response. [02:32:29] So there's that. [02:32:32] One of the reasons that the presentation and delivery over the last three days really has been that direct right is that we've had different people in the room every single time. [02:32:46] And so what we were waiting to hear is do we think we're going to do any number of these things right and so if we really did begin to experience you know a desire in this direction. [02:32:59] I want that to feel urgent to families because it very well make it onto a proposal in December. [02:33:06] Right. So that's what we've been pulse checking what feels different tonight right is the fact that this is the last of the three. [02:33:12] And I do feel like I can be a little bit more honest in my thinking with you all because it has evolved over time. [02:33:19] But we wanted to have that commitment that every conversation was as consistent as possible. [02:33:24] And until we really had a good gut check. And again, we're still collecting surveys. [02:33:28] My worst case scenario would be that we undersold this to you all right because I would hate for you to participate in this conversation and think, oh, oh, it's fine. [02:33:39] Like they're talking about 10 years from now and five or six people participate in the survey that nobody else participates in and says, absolutely. [02:33:45] I want to go. And then you are mesmerized in December. Right. [02:33:49] That we are making a proposal that affects you and your family today. Right. [02:33:53] I would always prefer for it to feel urgent. [02:33:57] Because I do want to collect feedback that is based on what if this was real. Right. [02:34:02] And so I appreciate it. And I hate that we created anxiety. [02:34:06] But at the end of the day, I also want to know what that anxiety feels like, because that's what we need to be reacting to. [02:34:12] So and I and I appreciate that. And I apologize for for what it did. [02:34:16] Essentially, in terms of scenarios, two and three, which may be. [02:34:22] But they both involve many more schools that have been made aware of the process. [02:34:26] You know, the Farragut schools have known for multiple years that this this is that's the point of this. [02:34:33] North Shore has known for less than three months. [02:34:37] I don't know what a lot's found out about the same time. [02:34:40] All of the federal schools. Yes. Yeah. [02:34:43] Bluegrass, Rocky Hill, Bearden Elementary, Sequoia and West Hills, to my knowledge, don't know anything about it other than maybe they scrolled through Facebook and saw where they're North Shore. [02:34:55] Lots Hardin Valley and Farragut friends. [02:34:58] Yeah. Yeah. [02:35:00] So, like, but it's been on the PTOs and the individuals to share that. [02:35:05] And going to the transparency that just something for you all to take away, take home is that if the ultimate plan could impact in the next two or three years. [02:35:16] Hey, we're going to trickle all these east west Knoxville things, you know, farther west. [02:35:22] They need to know. Because people buy houses based on that. [02:35:24] People buy houses based on what school zone they're in. [02:35:31] Okay. And just one more push for North Shore. [02:35:35] North Shore, as I'm sure you've seen over the three nights, I know you've seen tonight, has built a culture of family. [02:35:41] I mean, you can see it on my shirt. Six houses, one family. [02:35:45] And so the reason we've shown up so much is because two of these proposals are scenarios. [02:35:53] They take away 40% of our family. [02:35:56] And personally, I wouldn't be affected because my house isn't in one of those spots. [02:36:04] But both of my kids, while at North Shore, have had best friends who are in the Choteau Peninsula. [02:36:11] And that has enriched their lives. [02:36:14] And for us to hear that there's a possibility that 40% of our family is going to get ripped away. [02:36:21] It hurts. [02:36:22] It's unconscionable. [02:36:23] It's just, you know, it's had us all torn up. [02:36:27] Yeah, that's pretty much it. [02:36:31] Thank you for sharing. [02:36:35] This is my second night in a high school auditorium. [02:36:41] Based on the fact that it's 9 o'clock at night, I know everyone would like to not spend any more time in this high school auditorium. [02:36:47] I'm going to do my best to keep my questions super concise. [02:36:49] If you can give me super short answers that you feel like are sufficient, I would love nothing more. [02:36:54] So, I just want to say thank you. [02:36:55] So, I know that it feels like the vibe is leaning away from Plan 3. [02:37:00] But unfortunately, I feel a deep distrust in this entire process. [02:37:03] So, I'm going to ask all my questions as if that's not the case. [02:37:05] Because I do not feel like that's 100% guaranteed to us. [02:37:11] Distrust isn't the intent, but the sense of this could be is. [02:37:14] So, yes, please lean into that. [02:37:16] Yes, so I'm a kindergarten teacher at Analogues. [02:37:18] We are currently at our lowest enrollment since the day the building opened over 30 years ago. [02:37:23] So, the fact that we are being considered for rezoning and being named as overcapacity for us is astounding. [02:37:29] I mean, I have the lowest number of children in my class I've had in 13 years of teaching. [02:37:33] So, we're super... [02:37:35] Yeah, so, yeah, that's exactly what I wanted to do. [02:37:38] So, we're super confused why we've even been included in this conversation. [02:37:42] And it feels to us that the answer is because there is a longer term plan to roll other schools down that corridor into our school. [02:37:51] The plan is, in the meantime, you're going to take staff and families out of our school. [02:37:55] And I'll just speak from the staff perspective. [02:37:57] If this plan, as it stands, would happen to us, we would lose a third of our staff. [02:38:03] That is not something that you can recover from quickly. [02:38:07] And then, what, a year, two years later, you move that next phase up and you roll everything down. [02:38:13] Now, we're trying to rebuild. [02:38:15] I mean, the amount of time it takes to build a team like the one that I work on. [02:38:18] Shout out to my kindergarten people. [02:38:20] Most of us have been working together over 10 years. [02:38:22] We can almost read each other's minds. [02:38:24] And the idea that we would break that up for a short-term solution that doesn't actually solve a real problem. [02:38:31] There is not a problem. [02:38:33] And then we're going to fix it. [02:38:35] Two years from now, for us, feels insane. [02:38:38] So, my question is, what is the logic behind that? [02:38:41] So, the logic behind lots appearing on the screen, right, is what I was sharing over here. [02:38:46] Which is that, at a certain point, we had to have some framework. [02:38:50] A framework of reference for looking at this school versus that school versus this school, right? [02:38:54] And for us, it came down to, was there a space in which we could eliminate the need? [02:38:58] And I know what I'm about to say. [02:39:00] And I'm already hearing the reaction, right? [02:39:02] But if you're wanting to know how it made it on to the presentation, right? [02:39:06] Eliminating that need for the portables was how it made it on to the presentation. [02:39:10] What I will say is that if one of those scenarios emerged as a desirable option, right? [02:39:18] Something we were carrying in our mind. [02:39:20] Is the very real possibility of trying to do a meeting, really. [02:39:25] To do something unique with our staffing at those schools. [02:39:29] Because if we were to pursue an out-year's plan, right? [02:39:34] It would be foolish of us to disrupt an entire school community. [02:39:38] Knowing that there was potentially a backfill coming. [02:39:42] So, essentially, we had to answer a lot of questions. [02:39:45] We still have to answer a lot of questions on the front end. [02:39:48] To start thinking about those logics. [02:39:50] To think about a couple of next steps, right? [02:39:52] So, not going through this process. [02:39:54] It's hard to say exactly what those would have been. [02:39:56] But we had started thinking in this vein. [02:39:58] You know, if that wound up being appealing to the community. [02:40:02] We're not going to, you know, just move everybody out. [02:40:05] Move them right back in, right? [02:40:07] So, there's going to be. [02:40:09] There would have been. [02:40:10] And maybe still will be depending on how the surveys, you know, play out. [02:40:13] I want to be honest with the process. [02:40:15] That there would probably need to be some conversation around smoothing that transition. [02:40:19] As opposed to just, you know, robbing a school to replenish a school. [02:40:25] Right? [02:40:26] And so, when I say we're going to start thinking differently as a district. [02:40:31] So that we can be more proactive over time. [02:40:34] It's going to consistently. [02:40:36] Whether it's in this community or another community. [02:40:38] Right? [02:40:39] It's going to consistently feel more and more different from the way we've previously done business. [02:40:43] Right? [02:40:44] Because we do have some long range decisions we have to make. [02:40:48] To maximize and make the most of the resources that we have. [02:40:51] We also have to do that and want to do that in a way that is meaningful to our staff. [02:40:57] That is meaningful to our students. [02:40:59] And that probably means we have to do things a little differently than we have in the past. [02:41:03] And so, we're still kind of figuring out what exactly that looks like. [02:41:06] Because we do have a really uneven distribution pattern right now. [02:41:10] When we're talking about students and seats. [02:41:13] And so, that's something we're grappling with county wide. [02:41:15] It is not a right now conversation. [02:41:18] For this community. [02:41:19] It doesn't have to be a right now conversation for this community. [02:41:21] Because again, that map. [02:41:23] That's a future forecast. [02:41:24] Right? [02:41:25] We have communities that look very, very different elsewhere in the county. [02:41:28] That we are significantly overpassing. [02:41:30] Right? [02:41:31] We need to be making a right now decision. [02:41:33] And so, that's a conversation that's going to feel a little different in that area. [02:41:36] So really, this was an opportunity to pulse check on where are appetites. [02:41:41] Where are sensitivities. [02:41:42] And can we start thinking more long range. [02:41:45] And that's really where all of this came from. [02:41:47] Okay. [02:41:48] So, my next question is a question on behalf of other staff members. [02:41:50] Will staff that is displaced if this plan were to pass be guaranteed equivalent positions within the district? [02:41:56] And after taking volunteers for the new school, who would make these decisions? [02:42:00] And how? [02:42:01] Like, whose hands would this be in? [02:42:03] So, if we, actually I can answer this probably from a state of reality. [02:42:09] Right? [02:42:10] Because there is going to be some degree of transition in the barrier regardless of what happens. [02:42:14] So, yes, there will be that voluntary process. [02:42:17] One thing that we can say is that, you know, we're not looking at a loss of students overall. [02:42:22] Right? [02:42:23] If anything, when you start splitting student enrollment, more than likely you're actually [02:42:27] going to wind up with a higher need for teachers. [02:42:29] Potentially. [02:42:30] So, you may actually wind up with, you know, one additional need to currently have depending [02:42:34] on how that distribution all plays out. [02:42:36] So, we would not anticipate a reduction of teachers. [02:42:39] Right? [02:42:40] There may be redistribution of teachers to follow their students. [02:42:43] How those decisions would be made beyond that volunteering in. [02:42:46] Would be a conversation between HR, the principal, and then with the staff. [02:42:50] Okay. [02:42:51] So, I'm going to ask the first part again. [02:42:52] Would the staff members be guaranteed an equivalent position within the district if they were [02:42:57] displaced? [02:42:58] So, I do not work for HR, but in the past we have been able to do that. [02:43:06] Yes. [02:43:07] So, I do not want to speak on behalf of HR and I don't want to convey a sense of security [02:43:13] that is not fair of me to convey, but I would say almost definitely yes. [02:43:17] I'm sorry. [02:43:22] I'm sorry. [02:43:23] I'm sorry. [02:43:24] You're behind the button. [02:43:25] How? [02:43:26] The reason I feel pretty secure in that answer this year is that, you know, we're looking [02:43:27] at a current retirement incentive. [02:43:28] Right? [02:43:29] And so, the early retirement incentive is essentially going to guarantee and the addition [02:43:30] of the new school. [02:43:31] Right? [02:43:32] Is going to guarantee that we have those placement opportunities. [02:43:33] I'm hemming and hedging right now because I also want the answer that I give you to be [02:43:38] consistent year over year over year. [02:43:42] I can give you a lot of security right now because this is an anomalous year for a couple [02:43:48] of reasons. [02:43:49] We've got a new school. [02:43:50] We have an early retirement incentive. [02:43:51] have positions replacement yeah um sorry uh have schools like sequoia beard and west hills rocky [02:43:58] hill and bluegrass been informed of plan three now that it is very clear that it will absolutely [02:44:03] involve them at some point should it be the choice um and also if lots became part of the [02:44:07] conversation in september why wasn't anyone notified so lots became a consideration i would [02:44:12] say for us sometime in the fall until we felt confident that this was going to be the proposal [02:44:19] that we brought to the community right and i would say lots wasn't the only school um that [02:44:22] we were considering the same thing i said to you um the gal over here that asked the question about [02:44:28] you know that sense of urgency feels very different tonight i would actually apply that in the inverse [02:44:33] right we want when there's a possibility on the table we want people to feel that sense of urgency [02:44:37] because we want that real feedback right what if this was real at the same time we also don't want [02:44:42] to disrupt entire school communities if we're not actually talking about something that we think is [02:44:47] going to happen right now [02:44:49] so to go ahead and you know alert a community that there is a possibility that is contingent on [02:44:54] a whole lot of conversation that may not happen four or five years um you know until down until [02:45:00] four or five years down the road feels very disruptive um in a sense and so that really was [02:45:05] the thought process um behind who was informed and who was not can we agree though that two weeks [02:45:11] doesn't really feel sufficient i'm hearing that to the community it does not feel sufficient [02:45:19] um i will say [02:45:20] that uh we're going to take that we will apply that i think in my experience most [02:45:25] families pretty quickly know how they feel about a person that you know something that [02:45:29] is presented to them so living with that uncertainty there's also that you know [02:45:34] question of how long do you ask people to sit in that right um and so i'm hearing maybe maybe [02:45:39] longer than we have right yes and so you're gonna apply that forward but that is some of the [02:45:44] balancing act too right is that we do want we want teachers focused on their kids um and we want [02:45:49] parents you know trusting their children that's one thing you feel was important to do in the end [02:45:50] their school and so if we can truncate that period of uncertainty and that [02:45:55] period of doubt we would like to do that but it's also a balancing act right [02:46:00] because we want people to feel like they've had a chance to share with us [02:46:03] how they feel and so it sounds like maybe we need to elongate that runway [02:46:07] just a bit in the future but essentially that's some of the calculus that we carry [02:46:11] because you're looking at a subset of families that have the ability to be [02:46:15] here at 9 o'clock with very short notice with maybe family members watching their [02:46:18] children and that is not the case for a huge part of I know our lots community [02:46:22] there are tons of families that are not represented here and could not be [02:46:25] because they do not have child care or the ability to find it. And our lots families had no idea. We passed out flyers to windows and cars today. They had absolutely no clue this was even [02:46:36] happening. And if you could continue to just to let them know that tomorrow [02:46:41] especially we will be sending out the videos on the website we'll be sending [02:46:45] out the presentation on the website and the survey so just [02:46:48] include that. [02:46:48] We encourage families who are not able to be here in person to please just take [02:46:52] advantage of those resources and still share their perspectives with us. And I [02:46:55] feel like this has been said but the lack of transparency throughout this entire [02:46:58] process is incredibly disappointing and we truly hope that there is learning [02:47:02] that comes from this and that this process improves in the future for [02:47:05] anyone who's affected whether it's us or other communities. [02:47:08] Appreciate that. Our goal is always to improve after every session. [02:47:13] Okay I'll try to keep you guys short. As you can see [02:47:18] there is a very big sense of community here not just with North Shore but within [02:47:23] Farragut and within Hardin Valley. I wish Hardin Valley was more represented here [02:47:29] tonight because it's very disappointing that there's not a lot of them. We've had a havo of them. I also want to say on behalf of the Hardin Valley community, they didn't opt out. I've talked with some Hardin Valley families the past two nights as well. [02:47:41] However in the Farragut community you guys have basically singled out one neighborhood in a [02:47:48] scenario to Concord Hills. We moved to Concord Hills because it was in [02:47:56] Farragut, in the town of Farragut. So my input is to keep all of the people who [02:48:03] actually live in the town city limits in Farragut schools because it makes zero [02:48:10] sense for Concord Hills, which I think your Google Maps lied to you, I live a mile [02:48:16] from Farragut Intermediate. You have three miles on there. Makes zero sense [02:48:23] for my children to go to any other school that is, I mean we're in the parent [02:48:30] responsibility zone. Why would you move our neighborhood outside of Farragut? [02:48:36] Really, it doesn't make any sense. Also one thing that came up, you guys are [02:48:43] talking about the temple and you know you [02:48:46] said that you've got with Knox County, Knoxville planning. They do not do planning and [02:48:53] development inside the town of Farragut limits. That temple is inside Farragut. So [02:49:00] I don't know if you do that, but you go to the town of Farragut to get all that [02:49:07] stuff, not Knoxville, Knoxville planning. There's a new temple that's right on Kingston Pike? [02:49:15] Yes. [02:49:16] And Dixie Lake. [02:49:17] Is that the one they're talking about? [02:49:18] The one on in Dixie Lake, yeah. [02:49:20] Yeah, yeah, that's in Farragut. [02:49:22] Knoxville, Knox County planning does serve the county of Knox County. [02:49:28] Okay, well we do not go through Knoxville planning for our development of parcels in the town of Farragut. [02:49:37] Okay, it's zoned in the town of Farragut. People who are going to live in the vicinity of it typically will be living in the vicinity of it. [02:49:43] Okay. [02:49:44] Okay. [02:49:45] Okay. [02:49:46] Okay. [02:49:47] And they will be living in the Town of Farragut. So the fact that you guys didn't even seek Town of Farragut with that issue. [02:49:52] My understanding is, is that the town of Farragut has Covenants that are above and beyond, but the county still has reviews still [02:50:04] No they don't. [02:50:05] They do not. [02:50:06] Okay. [02:50:07] 100% they do not. [02:50:08] Okay. [02:50:09] So, I am on the BZA for the county. [02:50:12] Yep. [02:50:13] And I work closely with the town of Farragut. I've been through their process. [02:50:14] Okay. [02:50:15] i've been through their whole thing i go to all the meetings they do not review them so fair you [02:50:22] obviously know more than i do i will say that we get development information from planning for [02:50:27] for the town fair well you guys would be surprised at the projects that we have in the town [02:50:32] still going on so i would reach out to the town of farragut uh mark shipley who is our [02:50:38] town planner right now you really should talk to them thank you thank you i promise i'll be [02:50:46] everything so um with respect to the survey who are you all sending the survey out to [02:50:53] yes so um it will be shared with all of our families that live in a potentially impacted [02:51:00] area so the same families who received invitations um for this evening that'll be the listserv that [02:51:04] we're using to cycle back through that being said it is posted on our website and so if pto's pta's [02:51:10] family members are interested in participating in the survey please feel free to reach out to them [02:51:10] we would like to share it more broadly we would like to be most focused honestly on our families [02:51:16] who stand to be potentially impacted um but it is an open survey and then um i think my views [02:51:24] have been expressed but i think it takes a lot of humility and patience to do what you guys have [02:51:28] done over the last three days so i want to just say thank you for doing that and i as frustrated [02:51:33] as in by the process it it was revelatory to me to see two people have such depth of understanding [02:51:40] of their subject matter domains and i'm grateful that you guys are part of the county administration [02:51:46] thinking about some of these things even if i disagree with some of the conclusions that have [02:51:49] been drawn so thank you we might be calling you for some consulting so appreciate it yeah [02:51:55] and so the board members who have continued to withstand these meetings thank you [02:52:00] i really just urge you all to to trust your gut in terms of keeping this a farragut centric solution [02:52:07] and reject something like scenario three [02:52:10] maybe there's an appetite in our valley and that's great but i think that's my perspective [02:52:14] has been fairly clear so thank you all really appreciate it if we moved lives would that [02:52:28] because we're talking about 41 students over right now unless i'm a second this would affect 170 plus [02:52:34] families in the area with one of those yes it's 170 families so roughly what 200 250 kids for a 41 [02:52:47] are you going to fill that with somebody from rocky hill because if so it seems like you're [02:52:53] blocking your own plans to just bring people straight down north shore by involving lots at all [02:52:59] in a situation that will fix itself so that's something we are looking to do yeah so again [02:53:05] i am going to continue to encourage everyone to take the survey and definitely appreciate [02:53:09] the insight so we're agreed that that would actually get in your way affecting lots would get [02:53:16] in the way of any plans you have to pull people in it would limit your flexibility for the amount [02:53:22] that you can pull into north shore from rocky hill or anywhere else further up making that tip from [02:53:30] uh al lots into north shore preemptively absolutely i mean it would be taking up seats essentially um [02:53:36] in north shore so that would that would be a change factor so scenario three is a problem not a solution [02:53:45] okay yeah so [02:53:46] So we're all agreed that it's going to impact your ability to solve any future problems you may be looking at with that other red area further east. [02:53:56] The problem we were working on determining whether or not it was worth solving would be the elimination of the need for portables at lots. [02:54:04] But again, this is what we're hearing. [02:54:07] My child has been in one of those portables and it's just fine. [02:54:09] So I just want to label what the potential challenge was and identify we are hearing you on just how not a problem that is, right? [02:54:19] It's not a problem with that. [02:54:20] But as one of our teachers put out, she may not be hearing anymore. [02:54:27] The damage it would do to staffing in the short term to then backfill people from another area much further away when we live less than a mile and a half away from AOI. [02:54:39] Which is still further away than Bluegrass and it's even closer to this. [02:54:42] You would force our family to go to the third furthest away elementary school. [02:54:48] And impacting children and ripping them away to just backfill from somewhere else that you're going to disrupt more children. [02:54:57] So please, please, please think carefully. [02:55:01] Don't rip away children that don't need to be away from the communities and schools. [02:55:06] Keep them being as successful. [02:55:10] We have a quick request. [02:55:20] Could you please send the parent square note to all of the North Shore and Lons communities? [02:55:27] Because my child would not change schools in any of these scenarios, but my child's school would change. [02:55:34] And if you're sending them only to the folks that got the notifications about the meetings, I would not receive that direct link. [02:55:41] I have the link, but there are other people, the rest of my neighborhood, that sort of thing. [02:55:44] I would love, love, love for that link to go to all of the schools. [02:55:48] not just the people that are in the specific zone in here yes that's my [02:55:52] favorite thing in the world is to find a way to say yes but I am going to give [02:55:56] you a caveat here so if we were to send that out to every family at this point [02:56:00] families would be receiving a survey that is about a set of scenarios that [02:56:05] does not immediately pertain to their and I get yes in a peripheral manner it [02:56:09] might the confusion I think we could generate in doing that and having [02:56:14] families believe that we might actually potentially be rezoning them is the [02:56:19] reason we would not send that to the parents where what I would say is I [02:56:22] think you all have a phenomenal PTA you all have a great communication network [02:56:26] if you can carry that clarity to your adjacent families that maybe are not [02:56:32] immediately potentially impacted but obviously would have a felt peripheral [02:56:36] effect please feel free to do so that's why it's on the website thank you [02:56:50] and then you said scenario four does not exist yet in our experience there is [02:56:58] almost always a scenario four which is kind of the evaluation yeah I can say [02:57:08] with absolute certainty there will be a scenario four that is what we're going [02:57:12] to be building essentially as we start applying the survey feedback the [02:57:16] knowledge you know that we've heard from the past three nights [02:57:20] is what you open that started with us oh yeah great question yeah so here's how [02:57:27] that yes yes so here's how that will work on December 2nd so we're not going [02:57:31] to go through another round of this right but what we will do on December [02:57:35] 2nd on the board's agenda on their website we will post publish a memo [02:57:41] detailing the scenario as well as significantly more detailed maps than [02:57:47] what you all have seen this evening [02:57:50] so once we are really truly zeroed in on a plan you're going to see street [02:57:54] specific boundary lines that'll all be posted online there will also be a [02:57:58] presentation on December 7th the Monday before December 10th so whatever that [02:58:11] Monday is we'll give a public presentation to the Board of Education [02:58:15] during that period of time from December 2nd onward feel free to [02:58:19] reach out to staff feel free to reach out to board members I think I can feel [02:58:22] I can say with certainty our board members want to hear your feedback right [02:58:25] and we will all be having a conversation that week about the proposal appetite [02:58:31] for the proposal and then that formal vote will take place on December 10 [02:58:36] yeah thank you [02:58:37] one more quick question it's my kid who's graduating and he goes to on campus up and down here [02:58:42] yeah and that is a very tough spot to get in if not the long way next to it if you what's going to happen next? [02:58:49] we have heard this from a few other families and I think it's a very real consideration so we have a great [02:59:00] relationship with our aftercare providers I don't know which one you're at right now but whether it's [02:59:03] so you know Y, Shades of Jell-O and the Boys and Girls Club so as we go through these processes [02:59:10] what I will say that our aftercare providers are looking at is migration patterns for their [02:59:15] students as well and so in most scenarios when we see a large number of students who are enrolled [02:59:21] in an aftercare program whether it's moved off site they're able to get them on campus and receive the [02:59:22] whether it's moved off-site or just never was on-site, right? [02:59:26] Generally, our aftercare providers are also working to coordinate transportation, [02:59:29] and that's always kind of contingent on how many students are we talking about. [02:59:33] But I would also say that aftercare providers are kind of on a daily basis working on reaching out to additional schools. [02:59:41] So there's always a possibility that schools currently without aftercare could receive aftercare. [02:59:46] But this type of feedback, you know, hey, you are talking about rezoning me to a school that does not have on-site aftercare, [02:59:53] and that's a real problem for me and my family, that's what we're looking for on the survey. [02:59:56] So please also put that on the survey. [02:59:58] Yeah, thank you so much. [03:00:02] That's it. [03:00:03] Mine is super fast, and it's more logistical. [03:00:06] So I pulled up the survey. [03:00:08] It only has a lots Farragut, Hard Valley, and North Shore listed. [03:00:11] So as we've discussed, there's other schools that are impacted in this who want their opinions heard as well. [03:00:16] What do they do? [03:00:17] They can email. [03:00:18] They can email rezoning at knoxschools.org. [03:00:21] We had this conversation yesterday evening. [03:00:23] What we don't necessarily want to do is set a precedent for communities weighing in on a decision that impacts a given community. [03:00:29] But that peripheral impact, absolutely. [03:00:31] Please encourage them to send their feedback to rezoning at knoxschools.org. [03:00:35] The link for that email is also on that website. [03:00:37] Okay. [03:00:37] But you can't get past the first question without. [03:00:40] If they go back to, how did you reach the survey from the QR code? [03:00:44] Okay, I apologize. [03:00:44] If you go to rezoning.knoxschools.org. [03:00:48] No, rezoning slash, I'm sorry, MPN, rezoning slash knoxschools.org as a URL, you will receive, I'm standing too close to you, so on that website, they can, you know, receive access to all the presentations, videos, and then the survey links as well. [03:01:09] Sorry, survey links are irrelevant. [03:01:10] The email address is also on that website. [03:01:13] Okay, so just a second comment or suggestion. [03:01:15] Absolutely. [03:01:15] Yep, okay, yep. [03:01:17] Okay, yep. [03:01:17] All right. [03:01:18] Thank you. [03:01:19] All right, guys. [03:01:20] I cannot say enough how much I appreciate those of you who have been with us, too, in three nights, for being with us, too, in three nights. [03:01:26] Those of you who have come out to visit us for the first time this evening, thank you for doing this. [03:01:32] Our proposals are only as good as your feedback, and these are critically important conversations. [03:01:39] So on behalf of our board, because I know that they are hungry for your feedback as well, on behalf of our staff, we really appreciate you. [03:01:45] Hope you all get some rest this evening and enjoy your Friday. [03:01:48] And please be on the lookout for that proposal on December 2nd. [03:01:51] Thanks.