[00:00:00] questions and we look forward to providing as much clarity as we can. [00:00:05] Career Answers. [00:00:06] I have two questions. [00:00:11] Okay, number one, for the current families at Lotz that could potentially be zoned to [00:00:16] North Shore, what does our feeder look like? [00:00:20] Does it change? [00:00:22] You're, for the current, like if you live on Fox Road or like, so right now your feeder [00:00:27] pattern is Analotz, West Mountain Middle School, Bearden High School. [00:00:30] So your feeder pattern will be North Shore. [00:00:32] Well, not necessarily. [00:00:33] So I, I told the line between Farragut and Bearden currently. [00:00:37] Yes, I'm sorry, you're right, there is a small portion that goes to Farragut High School. [00:00:41] But no, we're not talking, all this stuff is only talking about elementary schools. [00:00:45] It's not talking about any changes to middle school and high school. [00:00:48] Sorry, I didn't, I was not clear here, I apologize. [00:00:51] Yes, and then my second question is, if this is going to become a domino effect for all [00:00:55] of us from Sequoia all the way down, have you all taken the time to notify those schools [00:01:01] as well? [00:01:02] That this is going to impact them? [00:01:03] Because I feel like if they have no idea this is coming, it's a little unfair that they [00:01:08] don't know that this move is going to affect their schools as well. [00:01:11] Yeah, I think it's a great question. [00:01:13] So the answer, the quick answer is no, but there's a why behind that, right? [00:01:18] So what we have to do right now is determine how we draw the lines within the existing [00:01:25] Farragut primary, Farragut intermediate school zones. [00:01:28] So that's our first step. [00:01:30] How we draw those lines will determine. [00:01:31] Whether or not we might be able to provide some relief to Hardin Valley or provide some [00:01:38] relief to the eastern side of the county. [00:01:40] That's an either or, unless you do a little bit of both, right? [00:01:43] So there's still kind of a question mark hanging in the balance. [00:01:47] So before we engage six, seven, eight more schools, potentially, we've got to know, are [00:01:52] we even going there, right? [00:01:54] And so once we have that decision made, once we kind of know what are the options on the [00:02:00] table, then there absolutely is a second round of conversations coming, but we've got to [00:02:06] know what the opportunity is before we start engaging broader subsets of the population. [00:02:11] I think it's a phenomenal question. [00:02:13] There will absolutely be more conversations coming, whether it's in this sector of the [00:02:18] county, West Knoxville, or in other sectors of the county, something that we want to say [00:02:22] just as many times as possible in as many places as possible is that we have seen a [00:02:28] lot of student enrollment. [00:02:29] Enrollment shift across the county year over year over year. [00:02:34] And we as a district haven't always been diligent in addressing those shifts. [00:02:38] And so those incremental shifts for us have kind of built up over time, such that we know [00:02:43] we're having zoning conversations in more than just this community. [00:02:48] Beginning now, it started in Powell last year. [00:02:50] We'll have more conversations coming in the spring and more conversations coming next [00:02:55] year. [00:02:56] And so whether it is, you know, the eastern side of the West Knoxville area, whether it's [00:02:59] the Columbus County sector that we're talking about, or just the community at large, there [00:03:04] are absolutely more conversations coming. [00:03:11] I also have two hopefully quick questions. [00:03:13] I'm on American. [00:03:14] I'm making my daughter take the bus because I see the line up to drop the kids off at [00:03:18] school. [00:03:19] I didn't see anything in the presentation about bus change times. [00:03:22] It was all driving. [00:03:23] I never drive my daughter to school. [00:03:25] So you're the transportation person. [00:03:27] Have you put any thought into what the changes are for bus times? [00:03:30] They're already pretty early for us to get to the bus. [00:03:32] But my daughter's a trooper. [00:03:33] Does it? [00:03:34] Yes. [00:03:35] So we have. [00:03:36] So there's an element of yes and no to your question. [00:03:37] Yes, we have thought about those things. [00:03:38] How will we run buses in those areas? [00:03:39] In each one of the areas that we're talking about rezoning, we are already running buses. [00:03:40] They just go to a different school. [00:03:41] So our generally the way that we approach that is like stops will stay the same. [00:03:42] The routes, to the extent possible, will stay the same. [00:03:43] We just point the bus at a different school. [00:03:44] Her rebel pastor, A.L. [00:03:45] Locke. [00:03:46] He's a pastor. [00:03:47] He's a pastor. [00:03:48] He's a pastor. [00:03:49] He's a pastor. [00:03:50] He's a pastor. [00:03:51] He's a pastor. [00:03:52] He's a pastor. [00:03:53] He's a pastor. [00:03:54] He's a pastor. [00:03:55] He's a pastor. [00:03:56] He's a pastor. [00:04:03] He's a pastor. [00:04:04] He's a pastor. [00:04:05] He's a pastor. [00:04:06] He's a pastor. [00:04:07] He's a pastor. [00:04:08] And they're not the only ones. [00:04:09] I mean, unless you take the interstate in which I don't think the buses would simply [00:04:10] be. [00:04:11] Her bus would go past her current school if she was rezoned. [00:04:12] That very well could be. [00:04:13] I'm just kidding. [00:04:14] That's just kind of the story. [00:04:15] And that's also the kind of feedback that we're looking for too. [00:04:16] I mean so we're aware of that. [00:04:17] But again, the reason these scenarios are being proposed to you all is essentially to [00:04:18] throw some noodles at cabinets and see what sticks. [00:04:19] If you're peeling that one off, we want to know that. [00:04:20] Okay, and the other question here, and this is a general question that we'd love to hear, [00:04:21] but- [00:04:22] and these scenarios are being proposed to you all is essentially to throw some noodles at cabinets [00:04:27] and see what sticks right if you're peeling that one off we wouldn't know that okay and the other [00:04:32] question also have you talked to any of the after school places because the one our kids go to they [00:04:38] don't have north shore on their list where they drive a bus to because it's further away i don't [00:04:44] know if you've talked to anyone about this so we haven't talked to aftercare providers yet [00:04:49] once you've had conversations i'm not aware but i will say we have great relationships with our [00:04:53] aftercare providers i say this having come from the aftercare world what aftercare providers are [00:04:58] doing on an annual basis every single summer is looking at where my kid is going um and where is [00:05:04] that need and so that is a conversation we would have once we know what kind of you know what the [00:05:08] conversation the content of that conversation would be can't guarantee that every provider is [00:05:12] going to be able to go everywhere but providers are absolutely eager to continue to serve their [00:05:17] families um and they've been doing that for a long time and they've been doing that for a long time [00:05:19] and they've been very good at doing so so in scenario three part of george williams memory [00:05:28] church road and ashley oaks look kind of segmented out what are the boundary lines and reasons [00:05:37] so in that one it's in so the boundary lines there are drawn again on property lines they're [00:05:44] generally speaking along fox road on a small portion of george williams and along that section [00:05:52] i currently live off a foreign road so very affected by [00:06:02] all of the [00:06:02] schools what kind of studies for each of these scenarios or possible scenarios regarding traffic [00:06:09] patterns to and from farragut schools in an already overcrowded i mean i have a 16 year old [00:06:15] she drives herself to school it obviously impacts those traffic patterns so what what studies are [00:06:21] done or have been done to show each of these scenarios [00:06:26] so just being honest at this point we have not engaged with any traffic studies or anything like [00:06:32] this again one of those things where it would it's helpful for us to know which direction we're going [00:06:37] before we commission a study or look at traffic or anything those things because the scenarios [00:06:41] are obviously very different they could be moving different amounts of families in different places [00:06:46] so the trips you know that scenario one generates can be very different than the trips that scenario [00:06:51] three generate for example so it's it's a great question it's absolutely something that like [00:06:56] is concerning um to me as well but we haven't gotten to that point it's i guess further along [00:07:05] with the product like it's it's a thing that we look at once we have it like this is what the [00:07:09] zone is this is what we're doing this is the direction in which we are going to our east [00:07:34] including lots of marshall have decreased enrollment each year since at least 2023 and 2024 [00:07:40] school year i know no one has a crystal ball but what's changed in the numbers for schools to the [00:07:46] east of us since the school was planned so since hard valley and farragut were the only schools [00:07:51] that were originally going to be impacted and now we're looking at marshall and watts when all of [00:07:56] the numbers have just decreased start with that and i will actually say just to be completely [00:08:02] honest hard valley was not an initial consideration behind the construction of this new facility [00:08:09] so the new facility off of boring road the intent behind that facility was to alleviate the [00:08:15] congestion in the farragut area and it was anticipated that the congestion in the farragut [00:08:20] area would continue to grow such that those 1400 seeds would by and large be necessary to that area [00:08:27] to your point [00:08:28] what we've essentially seen is an enrollment stabilization in that community and so that [00:08:34] incline that rate of growth has not met the initial projections that governed um the building [00:08:40] of that facility initially and so we are seeing shifts in enrollment not just in this pocket of [00:08:47] the community we are seeing it district-wide full disclosure new districts are seen in statewide [00:08:52] states are seen nationwide and so there's a lot of variables that go on behind that it's part of why [00:08:58] we're helping the community and we're helping the community and we're helping the community and [00:08:58] having this conversation because at the end of the day again we're not at a crisis point we could [00:09:04] see that enrollment continue to stabilize if enrollment continues to stabilize if we do see [00:09:09] a little bit of a decline all of those red numbers they get a little bit easier now what i will say [00:09:15] is that all of those red numbers right now are based on kids we still have so barring you know [00:09:20] the fifth graders rolling up every single year you still have that subset of students we're talking [00:09:25] about elementary school this is our longest runway with students [00:09:28] that's still six years of data that we're basing that off of we're going to lose a fifth grade [00:09:34] class every single year so you might see a slightly smaller incoming kindergarten class [00:09:38] but we've got some continuity we've got a little bit of a runway to work with [00:09:42] as far as our current enrollment numbers go but the point that you make is a very valid one [00:09:47] i think it would be remiss of us not to start a conversation now because we are aware of what [00:09:53] that 80 threshold looks like at all of these schools and so that's why we're having the [00:09:58] conversation but it's also why that sense of urgency isn't as high in this conversation [00:10:03] so when i say conversation starter i mean conversation starter we're really trying to [00:10:08] feel out what is the appetite in the community what are the concerns um and what do we need to [00:10:13] do now versus what do we need to plan for should numbers continue to look the way that they do [00:10:19] how are you going to get all this done and validated [00:10:40] big mention the previous question about the transportation two things i guess i would call it [00:10:58] say and then i'll turn it over to you for the traffic analysis um so absolutely five days [00:11:03] uh and we're hyper conscious of that i imagine ryan's gonna have a lot of coffee in the next [00:11:08] five days but realistically um essentially the lion's share of the hardest work for us [00:11:14] has been done now it's about using those profiles that have been built and augmenting them [00:11:22] so there is a software uh and ryan talked a lot more about software than i could but [00:11:26] essentially the software they're building these profiles off of are already parceled with student [00:11:33] projections built in and so as we're receiving your feedback that feedback being organized [00:11:39] according to scenario is critical to us if that were not the case this would not be doable but [00:11:44] the fact that your feedback is going to be organized according to scenario is going to give [00:11:49] us a chance to start moving those lines to make sure that as we're being responsive to those needs [00:11:55] the numbers are continuing [00:11:56] to bear fruit and they're continuing to work out in a way that is conscientious of the capacity [00:12:01] of each of those schools so the hard work for you all is just telling us what that impact is [00:12:08] going to feel like that is the big ask right now as you all are generating that feedback [00:12:14] we are reacting to it live and continuing to permutate on those day after day after day we [00:12:21] already have survey responses in and it's really just a layering on effect of essentially what you [00:12:26] all are telling you [00:12:26] us from a contextualization standpoint thanks i guess the focus has been a lot on capacity [00:12:32] transportation but what other analyses have been done around educational opportunity feasibility [00:12:38] that kind of thing and when i guess the follow-up question was i know that the agenda for the board [00:12:45] meeting had to be items that he said today was there a proposal attached with that that was [00:12:51] specific or are you still working that out i think i followed you right up into the last part of your [00:13:00] question [00:13:00] idea just working so i know there's a it's my understanding that the agenda items had to be [00:13:06] set for the board and generally when those items are set on the agenda they also needed to include [00:13:14] like supporting documentation was that supporting documentation included oh i think i think i [00:13:21] understand your question but tell me if i answer it in a way that does not make sense and i miss [00:13:25] the point um so the board agenda publishes on december 2nd when it publishes absolutely the [00:13:32] supporting documentation will be published with it so when we say there isn't [00:13:35] a proposal genuinely i mean today there's not a formal proposal what we are actively doing is [00:13:42] taking your feedback to start generating that proposal on december 2nd there will be a memo [00:13:48] published on the board agenda that will detail here's what we heard here are the recommended [00:13:54] zoning lines there will be very detailed maps with those loaning zoning lines attached to it [00:13:59] and then generally there's also a presentation to the board to go through that very specific proposal [00:14:05] as well i will also say that that memo is where the transfer proposal is made as well and so the [00:14:13] transfer parameters attached to zoning scenarios is again very very distinct from the district's [00:14:20] general transfer policy so we essentially set a zoning protocol or sorry a transfer protocol [00:14:27] every time we zone a school so that would be the other part of that memo that i would just [00:14:31] recommend families be on the lookout for so no there is no supporting documentation yet because [00:14:35] there's not an agenda yet but on december 2nd all of that will be packaged and on that agenda [00:14:41] and you've got to do all that in five days or less technically i'm thinking about it i know it seems [00:14:47] like a tight run around this is generally the timeline that we're on and again it's because [00:14:52] getting the math right getting those zoning lines right double checking the proposals and the [00:14:57] scenarios that we build that is what takes behind the scenes time for us once we're talking about [00:15:03] adjusting [00:15:05] granted and skill [00:15:32] so that's really what you're reacting to. So I know it seems like a lot, but it is a timeline we believe we can deliver. [00:15:39] It feels like you've already made a decision. [00:15:45] I promise that we have not. We will continue to surprise ourselves and you all will continue to surprise us. [00:15:52] We actually heard a couple of things last night. We've already had conversations about those opportunities just to perfect and to adjust. [00:16:00] I mean, the extent to which a decision has been made, we know we have to rezone Farragut in response to the opening of the new school. [00:16:09] That is a decision that has been made. Beyond that, everything right now, we're still permutating on. [00:16:15] We're permutating on them from the realm of these three scenarios, but we have not chosen a scenario and we have not locked in those opening lines. [00:16:22] The board website, in your education, your board of education policy, it says that the agenda has to be distributed. [00:16:38] The agenda has to be distributed to board members being made available to the public five days before the meeting. [00:16:44] So that means that the agenda for this meeting on the table will be available December 5th for all of us to see, correct? [00:16:51] It'll actually be available on December 2nd. [00:16:54] Okay, before the workshop for all of us to see before we can come to the workshop, correct? [00:16:59] It'll be available before the workshop. The board policy speaks to the voting meeting. You'll still have it on December 2nd. [00:17:07] The workshop is on December 2nd. [00:17:08] On December, is that right? [00:17:10] 7th. [00:17:11] 7th, yes, thank you. [00:17:12] Perfect, thank you. [00:17:14] Hey, regarding the, and specifically for scenario three, will the county release how many transfers? [00:17:22] Sorry. [00:17:26] The information on how many current transfers are in those schools, and would it make sense to mix those transfers to be where students are already zoned for those schools? [00:17:34] Because, just a guess, but those schools probably contain a lot more transfers than the other parts of Knox County because of the educational standards of those schools. [00:17:43] I think it's a phenomenal question. [00:17:44] We actually received a very similar question in Powell, and I know we're talking about different communities, right? [00:17:49] But anytime you're talking about congestion, I think the first question is, right, who's not zoned here? [00:17:54] And so, when I say that the general transfers that KCS awards are based on a capacity basis, that is true, right? [00:18:02] So, while there may be a high degree of interest, and it is absolutely true that many of the schools that were on that map have very, very long transfer wait lists. [00:18:12] They don't have transfer approval numbers that are putting us over capacity. [00:18:17] So, could we look at potentially rescinding transfers? [00:18:21] We could. [00:18:22] Would it take those schools out of the red? [00:18:23] It would not. [00:18:24] It's a great question. [00:18:26] Good evening. [00:18:31] So, the first one is, is you were discussing that you would be utilizing the surveys, and it would be auto-created into the scenarios in which ones you guys are leaning towards. [00:18:45] So, ALLOT's being the smallest school. [00:18:48] Are we out of that? [00:18:49] Is that an immediate disadvantage for not having families or individuals? [00:18:56] That's a phenomenal question. [00:19:03] And if I did not say this, I apologize. [00:19:07] These are not votes. [00:19:09] And so, what we, what is very important to us, right, is that our ability to respond to just the practicalities you all are presenting to us is not based on the volume of what we're receiving. [00:19:23] So, it is not that, you know, we've seen a ton of responses to this. [00:19:28] It's not that it's going to sway us in this direction. [00:19:30] We genuinely want to know what are the very real day-to-day complications here, what are the very real day-to-day complications here, and what sets us up best for the district. [00:19:41] So, at the end of the day, we're going to make that decision based on what we believe does the most good for the most number. [00:19:48] But it's not going to be based on just concentration or volume of feedback. [00:19:52] Okay. [00:19:53] Phenomenal question. [00:19:54] And with scenario three specifically. [00:19:56] Lots. [00:19:57] We obviously have already been through the rezoning process in the last 12 years. [00:20:07] So, is that being taken into consideration? [00:20:10] And was that taken into consideration when AO Lots was? [00:20:14] We've already felt the reverberations of a rezoning already. [00:20:26] Another opportunity for another school. [00:20:30] But was that taken into consideration or will it be? [00:20:33] What I will say is, are we ready? [00:20:35] Yes. [00:20:36] So, to the extent that we're aware and we're empathetic to that, absolutely. [00:20:37] Will it prevent us from making a decision if it's the right decision? [00:20:38] No. [00:20:39] But it is something that we are highly conscientious of. [00:20:40] Something that we've been talking with our board members about, and I think there's a lot of appetite for this along the board, is just to be more proactive in general where zoning lines are concerned. [00:20:45] Part of how this is possible, right, is that we don't want to have a lot of people who are [00:20:46] just like, oh, we're going to take this. [00:20:47] We're going to take this. [00:20:48] We're going to take this. [00:20:49] We're going to take this. [00:20:50] We're going to take this. [00:20:51] We're going to take this. [00:20:52] We're going to take this. [00:20:53] We're going to take this. [00:20:54] We're going to take this. [00:20:55] We're going to take this. [00:20:56] We're going to take this. [00:20:57] And then we're going to have to figure out, are we going to be able to do this? [00:20:58] I think that's a huge thing. [00:20:59] And I think that's something that we're all very concerned about, and I think there's [00:21:00] a lot of appetite for this along the board, is just to be more proactive in general where [00:21:01] zoning lines are concerned. [00:21:02] Part of how this is possible, right, is that we don't have a systemic process for evaluating [00:21:03] school zones. [00:21:04] So, we're constantly doing this on a case by case basis, because something else has [00:21:05] happened, right? [00:21:06] North Shore Elementary School opens, we have a zoning conversation with lots. [00:21:07] New Boring Road School opens, we have a zoning conversation with lots, right? [00:21:08] That's not systemic. [00:21:09] It's not predictable. [00:21:10] And so, it's not going to change anything. [00:21:11] on a case-by-case basis because something else has happened right [00:21:15] North Shore Elementary School opens we have a zoning conversation with lots [00:21:18] New Boring Road School opens we have a zoning conversation with lots right [00:21:23] that's not systemic it's not predictable and so what we hope to move toward as a [00:21:28] district is a more predictable model now that might mean that we're having [00:21:32] conversations on a five-year or seven-year basis more recurring basis but [00:21:37] our hope would be that there's smaller conversations these are big [00:21:41] conversations right now because we haven't had big systemic conversations [00:21:45] and that's why we've seen some of the pile up and the congestion that we've [00:21:48] seen really just in pockets of the community phenomenal question for [00:21:53] conscientious other we'd love to be able to build a system that kind of [00:21:55] insulates against that we're just not living in that reality right now and my [00:22:00] last question and thank you so much for both of those answers in regards to [00:22:05] Hardin Valley in scenario three I know that you mentioned it helps none at all [00:22:10] I know that you mentioned it helps none at all [00:22:11] for Hardin Valley utilizing scenario three so what is the back up plan for Hardin Valley and there is as you mentioned a lot of opportunity for continued growth and they are already the maxed out of the overcrowded so if we utilize scenario three what happens to Hardin Valley? [00:22:34] I would say whether we utilize scenario three or not more than likely I would say the next 20 years [00:22:41] we are having a capital conversation about hard valley we would like to do with scenario one and [00:22:48] the reason scenario one is on the board is to try to prolong that conversation if the development [00:22:56] that is possible in hard valley you know continues to be realized even the amount of relief we're [00:23:02] talking about in scenario one is more than likely not going to be sufficient to meet the needs of [00:23:08] that community that's actually what we don't like about scenario one what we do like about scenario [00:23:12] one is that it buys us some time so realistically um you know we probably are looking at capital if [00:23:18] it continues to develop at this rate hard valley is a little bit unique i would say from the other [00:23:22] schools that we talked about on the map just in that they do have room potentially for a capital [00:23:27] solution in the way that some of the rest of west oxford does not so that is something we're keeping [00:23:31] an eye on high school with the palace school district a few times and in regards to the [00:23:43] public school district you were taking questions from concerned parents and all that [00:23:48] and you still approved it so i hope this gentleman staying uh has a comment about speak for a few [00:23:56] of us here i think you guys have made up your mind i'm going to speak on behalf of alops my [00:24:02] question is simple here alops right now projected for 2027 is to be 67 percent 665 students that's [00:24:13] roughly 170 fewer students to fix a 41 plus student question is simple why move 100 [00:24:24] 70 students to fix two uh great questions great points first question second um i do just want to [00:24:35] say on behalf of the process in powell because i want to honor the families that came out because [00:24:41] they shared a lot of really good insight with us that we took three scenarios to that community and [00:24:46] we proposed a fourth to the board and so it was a very different scenario and i would say you see [00:24:52] elements of the scenarios that we presented in powell in the final proposal that we proposed [00:24:57] that was made to the community but something that we worked hard to do there was to honor the [00:25:03] feedback we received we learned a lot from that session we learned a lot from the feedback that [00:25:07] was provided and our hope is that the final proposal that was made was just a little bit [00:25:13] more meaningful to families and it feels just a little bit better because they were able to [00:25:20] lose heart and do not lose an opportunity to give us some feedback because we want to be able [00:25:26] to at least read that and see if we can make that [00:25:29] meaningful in the same way so that's point number one um you know the question that you asked is a [00:25:35] great one and it comes down to future planning right the fact that we're having the conversation [00:25:40] right now gives us a chance one to have a longer conversation but two to make sure that as we're [00:25:46] having this conversation we're not just thinking about next year so 41 students that's based on [00:25:51] current enrollment right we know that while enrollment is declining in pockets of the [00:25:57] community it's also inclining [00:25:59] in pockets of the community i actually live right behind aol lots um and i have many many neighbors [00:26:04] that i'm your zone for aol lots who i moved in with kiddos very recently um they were running [00:26:09] the neighborhood they're um i think excellent learners and we'll fill the halls of aol lots [00:26:13] um but we're aware of the fact that you know they exist um and so that's some of that future [00:26:19] proofing that we're thinking about as well that it's not just the 41 today we need to think about [00:26:24] the students tomorrow the next day the next day the next day after that and so that's some of where [00:26:29] buffalo comes into play it's a phenomenal question yeah so just consider this also that uh [00:26:35] i believe within the last four or five years uh the amount of students that is true and that's [00:26:45] something we're keeping an eye on too as we think about that multi-year solution if that continues [00:26:51] to be the case it does change some of our projection formula right now under projection [00:26:55] formula it's based on prior years but until prior years catch up to is that a consistent trend [00:27:02] or is that a moment in time that's essentially that's a moment in time that's essentially that's [00:27:04] that moment that we're living in right that proof point how many years would you need sorry how many [00:27:11] years would you need to see that that that this system is a lot should not be so so talk about [00:27:18] a lot specifically so like the last two years that one has shrunk the last three the three [00:27:23] years prior to that enrollment grew a lot like 150 to 200 kids the three years before that yeah [00:27:30] downturn thoughts before that we had to go back up again like there are definitely waves to the [00:27:34] things there's also a lot of things in the air right now vouchers charter schools like there's [00:27:40] a lot of potential change in the air i'm not going to not be honest with you all those could have [00:27:45] effects and we hold on exactly what that's going to mean so you know in all honesty again i don't [00:27:54] have a crystal ball we're trying to make educated decisions we're trying to make ourselves as [00:27:59] informed as we possibly can but there is uncertainty in that without question it's me [00:28:13] um something i just wanted to ask because i'm [00:28:15] going to ask this via email and no one has asked it tonight yet i know that you put the and i know [00:28:21] that we're going to talk about this in the board meeting so let's go ahead and talk about it now [00:28:24] um i know you put a timeline up there but this was something people asked you know why now [00:28:29] and what happens if we postpone this until january february march [00:28:33] what are the implications of postponing this boat and this rezoning and what does that look like [00:28:40] i know you've already answered directly to me but let's go through it again i like it actually i'm [00:28:46] to your point that we haven't gotten this question yet between yesterday and today phenomenal [00:28:49] question so i'm going to take it in the short term and then i'm going to take it in the long term [00:28:54] so in the short term if we do not approve zoning lines at a bare minimum in december [00:29:02] that pushes back our staffing timeline so we are creating uncertainty for staff and we are putting [00:29:09] ourselves in a pipeline of making some split decisions kind of rapidly toward the end of the [00:29:15] school year as well as the next school year because a lot of principals have already begun planning [00:29:20] for their next semester and the start of the next school year in a way that is just not is it possible [00:29:28] absolutely is it tough on staff it really really is and i would say with this many moving parts [00:29:34] in particular in a brand new school that needs to be resourced that effect would be felt and [00:29:40] compounded in a very real way so there's immediate implications that are based on staffing [00:29:46] um there are also what i would call maybe mid-range um [00:29:50] implications, those are based on transfers. So the later we move in the [00:29:54] year, the harder it is to offer more of an opportunity for more families to stay [00:30:00] because it has, again, a ripple effect on staffing. So if we were to, say, offer families impacted by either of these moves, whether it's the Hardin Valley area or that kind of AL Lots North Shore side, if we were to, say, offer families K-5 an opportunity to remain at their [00:30:20] current zone school, that's a massive staffing impact, right? The ability for a vast majority of the school population to just stay for years has some significant staffing impact for us as well. So our appetite to do that probably decreases a little bit as we get into January, February. We can still do it, it just gets more uncomfortable. The math gets a little bit riskier along the line. So that's the immediate implications. Again, doable, complicated. [00:30:50] That is, if we vote this year, we don't vote in December, right? So that's one half of the question. Say that we vote this year, we vote on a phase of the proposal, and save a phase for next year, right? That guarantees that we diminish the number of transfers that we're able to offer. So there's something that has to happen this year, no matter what. We have to zone very good. Doing that sooner rather than later, I think, is a big thing. [00:31:19] That puts our schools in the best possible position for success. The rest of that timeline really is just about being able to give existing families as much opportunity as possible to remain at their current school. So families with third, fourth, and fifth graders, honestly, that timeline doesn't feel super urgent, right? The closer you are to the terminal grade, the more likely it is you're going to be able to benefit from that transfer. Families with kindergartners, first graders, second graders, who see this and think, wow, change is coming, [00:31:49] the earlier we lock in, the longer of a runway we can offer for students. So that's a little bit of that question. Well, that's that tension. It's why we're going to have the conversation early, because some version of that is going to feel better than another version of that. I don't think you all can tell us what feels right to you. Does that make sense? [00:32:07] It seems like a lot of stuff on the eastern side is all red. It's kind of where we're looking at. Has anybody looked at the data-driven information that says, okay, that's pretty well. [00:32:29] Established. People have been there for a long time. Mortgage rates are very low. There's not a lot of construction. I'm taking that into effect. How much of this is data-driven? To the point earlier, we talked about us. This is a ready-fire game versus actually having that data already ready to go. [00:32:49] This gives me an opportunity to get nerdy. So I said earlier that my department is responsible for doing enrollment projections. So a lot of the things that you just talked about come through our enrollment projections. [00:33:04] So we currently partner with Knoxville-Hawkins County Planning, which reviews all permits pulled for construction, change in density, change in zoning for the entirety of Knox County. So they utilize and we utilize a software system called School Cycle Pro. It's a nationally recognized, nationally used enrollment projection software. But we've given some demographic data, birth rates, the types of housing that's being built. And it has divided the county up into two parts. [00:33:35] We have 1,200 separate study areas. So each one of the study areas is given attributes. The current zoning, what the birth rates have looked like in that specific study area over the last 20 years. Various other things as well. And it will basically generate a student yield specific to Knox County based on what we expect to see from that type of housing in that location using national trends, but also kind of correct it, if you will, for what we've seen in the past 20 years. [00:34:05] So it is not, again, it is not perfection. It is not seeing into the future. But it is very much a day-to-day process. And it is something where we're trying to, you know, we're trying to gather as much information as we can, be as informed as we can, as we make what is very, like, what is a momentous decision. [00:34:26] We don't want to do, we don't want to come off with not having thoughtless for doing a due process. We want to try to look and take into account as many things as we can. [00:34:35] And how our county is changing is very much one of those. [00:34:52] With that in mind, though, I will say here that there was not more consideration given to traffic patterns and as had been referenced before, some of the bus routes and things. [00:35:06] Because, you know, I appreciate that y'all are saying you want to understand at the family level how will some of these changes impact your day-to-day. [00:35:12] If a child will be transferring schools regardless, right, if this is coming, totally respect that process. [00:35:21] One of the key parts. [00:35:22] About being in the Farragut community, for other folks that will be now coming in, is understanding the gridlock that happens every morning due to the sheer proximity of the schools. [00:35:33] And so I think in being in this space, I was wanting to know if, at the meeting yesterday, was that addressed with more Farragut crowd, saying, how are we going to make informed decisions and provide and share our feedback as individual families when we have no idea now, okay, it might be a change from 12th minute. [00:35:52] It's down to eight minutes, but has that been to sit in the 30-minute line all the way down to Easton Pike in front of J.P. Lee or gridlocked at Crixton Chapel and Campbell Station with folks that are attempting to turn right or, heaven forbid, with the lack of a traffic guard, turn left into Farragut Primary or the existing current Farragut Primary. [00:36:14] So I'll just say I just wanted to know, as a Farragut individual, was that brought up with time? [00:36:23] As the Director of Transportation, I'm very worried. [00:36:32] I'm very aware of how it affects the buses. [00:36:34] I'm very aware of what it looks like. [00:36:38] So, yes, it is not, like, it is not that it is not, we don't take... [00:37:09] ...will be, you know, in theory, declined in April. [00:37:16] As informed as possible as a parent, that's going to be providing advantages and disadvantages. [00:37:21] Even if you didn't know what they were, if there was proposed, like, for example, in scenario one, if someone's coming down through Harbor Valley, we know pretty confidently that's going to, you know, definitely increase traffic on Campbell Station, for example. [00:37:35] That might be... [00:37:36] ...be able to say, well, actually, I wonder how it would look instead if we were pulling from the North Shore community, again, knowing that that could drastically impact the day-to-day. [00:37:44] So I'll just say, respect this process, really appreciate all the work that y'all have put into this. [00:37:49] I am a little bummed to see a lack of understanding about the basic infrastructure of the roads. [00:37:55] That also correlates to... [00:38:10] ...community event lots. [00:38:11] We're in a really unique position as far as the socioeconomic status, when compared to the other West Festival schools. [00:38:17] So we have two... [00:38:20] ...communities that are set to receive a third for the next school year, it's being built at Cedar Bluff currently. [00:38:25] We hang out around 15% free or reduced lunch, compared to Ferriero, which is 5%, and North Shore, which is 2%. [00:38:32] We, historically, have had many families poured into our community, and traditionally, our fall festival, for example, would raise around $40,000 in fundraising. [00:38:41] It should be raised right around $20,000, compared to neighborhood schools making over $75,000 in one fall fundraiser. [00:38:48] ...stands. [00:38:52] Plan three. [00:38:53] It takes neighborhoods and communities out of the analog zone that represent two-thirds of our PTO cohort, while taking in one-third of our student body population. [00:39:01] A disproportionate population from an SES standpoint. [00:39:05] And for us, it really puts us in a position where we don't have families, or as many families, that are currently supporting our low-income kiddos. [00:39:13] We love these kids every single day when they walk through the door, but part of the way we're able to love them is by this incredible PTO cohort that has the lunchbox, backpack, water bottle, headphones for them before they can even set them. [00:39:24] I have a kid that lives in my doorway that packs food bags for them on Friday, that sends home with them over the weekend. [00:39:29] That's a really unique position that we're in, and it's a genuine concern of ours. [00:39:32] How will we support these kids when we lose two-thirds of the families that help us support them? [00:39:38] So my question is, has the socioeconomic impact been considered during the last fall fundraiser? [00:39:49] Question yesterday, not quite a question yesterday, which essentially is, you know, do you take socioeconomics into account when those zoning lines are drawn? [00:40:00] The quick answer is no. [00:40:01] And that is essentially because the affluence of communities ebbs and flows over time. [00:40:08] We see neighborhoods appreciate, we see neighborhoods depreciate. [00:40:12] And so, and I'm talking long-term, but I'm also going to just posit that when you draw zoning lines based on socioeconomics, you can apply any lens you want to that, right? [00:40:26] I can create pockets of poverty. [00:40:29] And I can create pockets of affluence. [00:40:32] Or I could create fully balanced, fully equitable systems, right? [00:40:36] So the ability to manipulate that system is pretty profound. [00:40:41] So when we talk about zoning lines, and I think Brian did an incredible job when he went through his methodology. [00:40:47] And I will say, I don't think there's a person with more integrity in this process than wanting to make sure that we are looking at the geography, that we are looking at just those time-honored, [00:40:58] consistent factors so that we can say, in all honesty, that this was a neutral decision for the sake of our families now, for the sake of our families in the future. [00:41:09] That's the intent. [00:41:10] Now, I will say this. [00:41:12] As someone who worked for 10 years in a school that had no PTO, 100% free and reduced lunch, and a community that worked their tails off to, over the course of 10 years, raise $1,500. [00:41:27] Right? [00:41:28] For one piece of playground equipment. [00:41:30] I get it. [00:41:31] And I know how important that school community is. [00:41:39] And I want to hear it in the survey. [00:41:41] But we also, from a methodology standpoint, have to have something that we honor that is true to the factors that we can govern in every single pocket of the community. [00:41:53] So please tell us that. [00:41:55] I don't want to lie to you and say that we're going to take something into consideration that the zoning methodology does not account for. [00:42:00] But that is a reality. [00:42:01] And we want to hear about it. [00:42:02] So that's my quick answer. [00:42:03] I will say, I'm extremely disappointed to hear that. [00:42:04] Because our kids are more than numbers on a data sheet. [00:42:05] They're actual real humans that come into our building every day, expecting something from us that we won't be able to get them if option number three passes. [00:42:06] And I will say this to anybody in the room, in any room. [00:42:07] I would also give just a huge shout out to some of our partners in education, too. [00:42:08] So whether it's national, whether it's federal, it doesn't matter. [00:42:09] It doesn't matter. [00:42:10] It doesn't matter. [00:42:11] It doesn't matter. [00:42:12] It doesn't matter. [00:42:13] It doesn't matter. [00:42:14] It doesn't matter. [00:42:15] It doesn't matter. [00:42:16] It doesn't matter. [00:42:17] It doesn't matter. [00:42:18] It doesn't matter. [00:42:19] It doesn't matter. [00:42:30] Whether this happens or not next year, or if there is a school that you are aware of that has any partners that also have an appetite for helping. [00:42:43] Not the same thing. [00:42:44] And I understand that. [00:42:45] But I do just want to say that there are support mechanisms that we also want to be connecting schools to. [00:42:51] So thank you for elevating that. [00:42:53] And please just submit that feedback as well. [00:42:55] First of all, thank you guys for bringing in all the other schools that are involved in this potential process. [00:43:07] If scenario three does get on the survey, then we should all be able to put our input on that. [00:43:14] And that's great. [00:43:15] since this is supposed to be a community discussion. [00:43:23] Essentially Rocky Hill could be impacted by Samaria 3. [00:43:26] So if we want to have an open line, [00:43:30] she may not be included in Sequoia Elementary, [00:43:35] Bearden Elementary, and Rocky Hill [00:43:36] are not on there to give our feedback. [00:43:38] Are you saying, I'm sorry, [00:43:39] I missed the first part of your question. [00:43:40] Are you saying you are not from one of the communities? [00:43:42] That's correct, but Samaria 3 could be. [00:43:47] So what I would say is, [00:43:48] we've got paper copies of the survey, [00:43:49] and I would happily take your feedback as well. [00:43:52] What we have tried to do is make sure [00:43:54] that when we're talking about zoning lines [00:43:56] for a specific community, [00:43:58] we are asking for families in that community [00:44:01] to weigh in on those zoning lines, [00:44:02] especially right now when one of the push and pulls [00:44:05] that we're talking about is, [00:44:07] is it ALL outside North Shore, [00:44:09] or is it Burke Valley, right? [00:44:11] So letting folks weigh in on, [00:44:13] what other community would I like to have in my school? [00:44:16] That's not the question that we're asking transparently. [00:44:19] We're asking, how do these zoning lines [00:44:20] affect you in this community? [00:44:23] Now, when we get to a point [00:44:24] in which we're talking about next steps, [00:44:27] whether those next steps would impact Bearden or Sequoyah [00:44:30] or any of those other schools, [00:44:31] whether next steps would impact the Harbor Valley area, [00:44:34] there will be a version of this conversation, absolutely, [00:44:39] that will take place specific to those school communities [00:44:42] that would potentially be impacted [00:44:43] by that phase of consideration. [00:44:46] But isn't this being voted on December the 10th? [00:44:49] So if Samaria 3 is voted in, [00:44:52] isn't it too late by that point for our- [00:44:55] So if Samaria 3 is voted in, [00:44:55] I don't understand, how is it not? [00:44:58] So no zoning lines, this is a phenomenal question. [00:45:02] Say version, and again, Samaria 3, [00:45:04] we're not voting on it on the scenarios, [00:45:06] but if something like Samaria 3, round up either, [00:45:11] that does not have a next year effect [00:45:15] on the zoning lines for Bearden Elementary School, [00:45:17] it does not have a next year effect [00:45:19] on the zoning lines for Sequoyah Elementary School, [00:45:21] it does not have a next year effect [00:45:23] for zoning lines in Rockville Elementary School. [00:45:26] What it might do, [00:45:27] is create an opportunity [00:45:29] for us to then have a broader conversation [00:45:32] about congestion being felt in other school communities [00:45:35] that will look and sound very, very similar [00:45:37] to what we're doing today. [00:45:38] So it will say, hey, these are possible considerations [00:45:43] that we want to present to you all, [00:45:45] we want your feedback, we want you to tell us [00:45:47] how would this impact your school community, [00:45:50] and then there will be a round of decisions [00:45:51] that come out of that. [00:45:53] So I do know this is very different, [00:45:55] it's incredibly different from the way [00:45:57] that we have done work in the past. [00:45:59] And that's because we generally don't think this long range. [00:46:03] But because we generally don't think this long range, [00:46:06] we're in a situation that looks like all the red on the map [00:46:08] that we just showed. [00:46:09] And so there are additional conversations coming, [00:46:13] no matter what we pick. [00:46:15] There are additional conversations coming, [00:46:17] honestly, in all of West Knoxville, [00:46:19] just given the overcrowding [00:46:21] and the potential for overcrowding that we're experiencing. [00:46:25] Decisions we make today, [00:46:26] may inform those opportunities for tomorrow, [00:46:30] but there is nothing on the table right now [00:46:32] that would next year affect Bearden, Sequoia Hills, [00:46:36] Rocking Hill, any of the other schools [00:46:39] that are listed as a secondary or tertiary [00:46:42] next phase consideration. [00:46:44] So I hope that helps. [00:47:01] Because the whole point of you doing scenario three [00:47:05] is to open up, you're arguing to bring all those people down [00:47:08] and then you're saying, we might not do that. [00:47:11] So you're, you're blowing up a PTO, not just it. [00:47:23] The 80% hard value, if you compare it to the red area, [00:47:42] it's astronomically more rooftop growth potential [00:47:45] and very hard value. [00:47:47] I think that's pretty commonality. [00:47:49] I believe you even said that last night, right? [00:47:53] So why are we using the 80% threshold? [00:47:57] I understand you need that room. [00:48:02] If it's already built out, [00:48:03] why is that 80% standard being used to argue [00:48:07] that you need to move on? [00:48:08] Move all these students down to another area [00:48:11] when you're using that same 80% threshold in Farragut, [00:48:15] which has astronomically more room for growth. [00:48:18] Hard value has astronomically more room for growth. [00:48:21] And on top of it, Ryan just said in scenario three, [00:48:26] we don't like that it goes over 80%, [00:48:28] but we'll live with it because Farragut is largely built out. [00:48:33] But if you're gonna say that about those areas, [00:48:36] why not change that 80% threshold [00:48:38] and adjust it in these areas [00:48:39] that are mature and they're not gonna get a lot of rooftop? [00:48:42] Why not put a different standard on those, [00:48:44] especially when you're gonna dislocate [00:48:46] hundreds of families based on that area? [00:48:49] So, phenomenal question. [00:48:51] What I will say, and actually I'll let Ryan add to these. [00:49:00] Something that you see in a neighborhood [00:49:01] that's been a neighborhood for 60 years [00:49:04] is that I grow up in that neighborhood [00:49:06] and I start with kids in elementary school [00:49:08] and then my kids leave elementary school. [00:49:10] So they're no longer represented [00:49:12] in that elementary school enrollment pattern. [00:49:14] But eventually I move out [00:49:16] and then a new elementary school family moves in, right? [00:49:19] So that ebb and flow is also something [00:49:21] we have to take into consideration. [00:49:24] Neighborhoods are cyclical. [00:49:26] You do have populations of school-age children [00:49:29] moving into homes right now [00:49:31] that are not generating children in our schools. [00:49:34] And so that room for growth measure [00:49:36] really just is an accountability factor for us to say, [00:49:39] we are kicking a pulse on the fact [00:49:41] that we wanna make sure that when kids arrive, [00:49:44] we've got some space to serve them. [00:49:46] Is 80% a hard cut? [00:49:48] Absolutely not. [00:49:49] It's not. [00:49:50] It is a starting point for a conversation [00:49:52] and for a consideration. [00:49:54] It's something that generally we're looking at [00:49:55] behind the scenes that now we're gonna [00:49:58] clean that curtain back on to say, [00:50:00] we wanna be transparent about the reality [00:50:02] of what this sector of the county looks like [00:50:05] and what the potential future for growth [00:50:08] in this area looks like [00:50:09] and to have that community conversation. [00:50:11] So I don't know if you wanna add anything more to that. [00:50:13] You kind of stole my answer. [00:50:15] But I will say that the 80% is not an arbitrary number [00:50:18] that we just picked. [00:50:19] It is an industry best practice. [00:50:20] And as Corey said, it is meant as a sort of [00:50:25] a marker, a sign, a like, hey, there is, [00:50:29] because we have, we actually have a lot of schools [00:50:30] that are under 80% as well. [00:50:32] So it's meant to say that there's something going on here [00:50:34] that bears closer to conspiration. [00:50:36] Again, your argument that there's families [00:50:38] that move in with kids and move out, [00:50:39] that happens in very hard and valid too, [00:50:41] along with additional rooftops. [00:50:43] That will also create capacity issues. [00:50:46] How many kids do you anticipate [00:50:47] will be moving into North Shore, for example? [00:50:51] Number three, can you bring kids down into North Shore? [00:50:53] How many do you anticipate will move into North Shore? [00:50:56] Are you talking about the students [00:50:57] that will be rezoned from other schools to North Shore? [00:50:59] Yeah, you know, you can do that [00:51:05] without rezoning North Shore right now [00:51:07] and still be in that 80% that is so precious to you guys. [00:51:11] Not to mention, you could actually do more [00:51:14] than that number into North Shore [00:51:16] and still be below the threshold [00:51:18] that you accept in Farragut, [00:51:20] anywhere between 85 and close to 90%. [00:51:25] So my question is, similar to Eyalat, [00:51:27] why would you destroy the culture of the school [00:51:31] and the school that's operating at an extremely high level [00:51:33] when really you have no idea [00:51:36] how many students are gonna come into North Shore? [00:51:39] In fact, you can forecast all you want, [00:51:42] but it seems like you just said to this group as well, [00:51:45] you are building a Farragut school [00:51:48] to rezone Farragut. [00:51:50] And in less than three years, [00:51:52] your forecast for the population growth [00:51:58] completely had to blow up your plan. [00:52:00] So why should we believe that you have any idea, [00:52:06] which you're applying an 80% percentile, [00:52:08] which I already believe is a fraudulent percentile. [00:52:12] Why should we believe that you have any idea [00:52:15] how many kids are gonna come down into North Shore? [00:52:18] Forecast population growth two years out [00:52:21] when you spend $44 million to do so. [00:52:23] Why should we believe that you have any idea how many kids are gonna come down into North Shore? [00:52:24] Forecast population growth two years out when you spend $44 million to do so. [00:52:25] And again, when you have no idea [00:52:27] what that number of students is gonna be, [00:52:29] you're just gonna decimate a school just in case. [00:52:33] Just in case on the chance I might be right this time. [00:52:38] So what I will say, [00:52:40] and thank you so much for sharing. [00:52:41] So what I will say is I want to give you [00:52:48] kind of the behind the scenes thinking [00:52:50] of just why we're having these conversations, right? [00:52:52] So it doesn't feel like there were three random scenarios [00:52:55] pulled out of a hat. [00:52:56] This question of why don't we just make use [00:53:00] of the 109 seats at North Shore, [00:53:01] very valid question, right? [00:53:03] And that's not a consideration that's off the table. [00:53:06] That's a conversation that we're having. [00:53:08] Mathematically though, what I do want to call your attention to, [00:53:11] you add up all these red numbers over here, right? [00:53:15] You're gonna get 420. [00:53:18] 420 students-ish get a potentially no need for portables [00:53:24] in the Western sector down that corridor of the county [00:53:27] and comfort. [00:53:31] We as a community, that's a starting place [00:53:35] for the conversation. [00:53:36] So that's a mathematical justification [00:53:38] for why we're having a portion of this conversation. [00:53:41] Is it math? [00:53:42] Yes. [00:53:43] And what we want is to know about what the impact [00:53:45] on kids would be if we go there. [00:53:48] That's why we appreciate so much [00:53:50] about having this exchange with us. [00:53:52] But in terms of why this scenario, right? [00:53:55] Why create a pocket of approximately 400 kiddos down here? [00:54:00] We've got a hundred, right? [00:54:01] Why don't we just use the hundred? [00:54:03] Just so happens to be closer to what this looks like, right? [00:54:10] There's a justification for it. [00:54:11] That doesn't mean we have to do it, [00:54:13] but we have to have a justification for a starting point [00:54:16] and a reason we're gonna have a conversation as a community. [00:54:19] Otherwise, there really isn't any rhyme or reason [00:54:23] to any conversation that we're having. [00:54:25] So every single one of these scenarios is grounded [00:54:27] in something contextualizing what that something does [00:54:31] and what we want it to do for our right now [00:54:33] and for our broader community. [00:54:35] That's why we're having these conversations. [00:54:36] So I appreciate that, I really do. [00:54:38] I just wanted to share some of that insight [00:54:40] with you all as well. [00:54:46] I'm speaking as a parent in Farragut. [00:54:49] When I look at the current numbers of current enrollment, [00:54:53] you have 2,045 kids in elementary school. [00:54:57] Proposal one, you would increase the total number [00:55:00] of elementary students by 7%. [00:55:02] Proposal two, by 21%. [00:55:07] So I bring that up as a consideration I suggest as a parent [00:55:12] to not disrupt so many students' lives. [00:55:15] We're gonna disrupt only 7% of students' lives, [00:55:17] plus all the Farragut students, [00:55:19] which is students, families, traffic. [00:55:25] That also includes teachers. [00:55:26] It's 140 students for those teachers. [00:55:29] That's five or six teachers. [00:55:31] If you do proposal three, you're doing 500 sets of kids, [00:55:35] which is 20 teachers. [00:55:37] And so, and then the other piece of it, [00:55:40] I mean, my suggestion is to go slow. [00:55:43] If you're gonna do any proposal, [00:55:44] I like one the most or the least disruptive one. [00:55:51] The other piece is consider vertical articulation [00:55:54] with all the students going to middle school and high school [00:55:56] because it compounds in five to 10 years. [00:56:01] Will there be enough capacity at those schools? [00:56:04] Or are we gonna struggle with capacity at other schools [00:56:07] like Bearden? [00:56:08] I'm not speaking for Bearden or whatever. [00:56:13] Just those are the things that I'd like to suggest [00:56:15] that you consider is to go slow [00:56:17] because [00:56:18] a lot of kids and it's, [00:56:22] yeah, we don't wanna distract kids or parents' lives. [00:56:25] I appreciate that. [00:56:26] And I will say go slow is something [00:56:28] we have consistently heard. [00:56:29] I wanna repeat something I said at the beginning [00:56:31] because I don't want it to get lost. [00:56:33] Feedback for us really needs to be in that survey [00:56:37] and contact, please continue to share. [00:56:38] You are more than welcome to continue to share, [00:56:40] but we would invite you to also submit that feedback [00:56:43] on the survey so that we have an opportunity [00:56:45] just to process and conceptualize that. [00:56:48] And I think that having these conversations early [00:56:51] means go slow might actually be recommendations [00:56:54] that we can take, right? [00:56:55] And so I definitely appreciate that. [00:56:57] The only other thing I wanna say is just, [00:56:59] I wanna call out that again, [00:57:01] there's no middle or high school feeder pattern [00:57:04] or zoning changes. [00:57:06] Sorry, nothing better. [00:57:06] There are no middle and high school zoning changes [00:57:09] being talked about right now. [00:57:10] So I just wanted to call that out as well. [00:57:12] But yes, absolutely, please give us that feedback. [00:57:15] Thank you. [00:57:16] I'm gonna make this brief [00:57:17] because I have to go get my kids to bed. [00:57:18] Even though I have a lot of good things to say, I'm gonna go. [00:57:19] A lot of good things to say and a lot of it was already covered. [00:57:23] So I'm gonna step out of the scenarios for a second. [00:57:34] You mentioned several times that for the families tomorrow, [00:57:42] I'll just add a statement and make it, [00:57:46] don't sugarcoat it. [00:57:48] Like this is a tight deadline for the families [00:57:49] who are seeing this presentation. [00:57:54] Please just reshape that for them tomorrow, in fairness. [00:57:57] Thank you, I appreciate it. [00:57:58] Yeah, last thing is I would not compare our children [00:58:01] to noodles being thrown on the counter. [00:58:03] Absolutely. [00:58:04] I think that's just what's going on. [00:58:06] Yep. [00:58:14] Question about transfers, [00:58:15] and then I also got a question about some of the, [00:58:17] implications of these scenarios. [00:58:20] So my first question about transfers. [00:58:24] I understand that they will be equally offered to students, [00:58:29] but that feels like a patch [00:58:32] because they're not equally feasible for people. [00:58:36] I feel like there is disparity in access to transfers [00:58:41] to specific situations. [00:58:44] So my family, I've got two kids at North Shore right now, [00:58:47] and I've got two kids who will start at North Shore [00:58:50] in the next two years. [00:58:52] While the transfer could make sense [00:58:54] for my current third grader, [00:58:56] it makes zero sense for my four year old, [00:58:59] because by the time she is, [00:59:02] there will be no peers in our neighborhood [00:59:05] who are still going to North Shore. [00:59:08] And so in order to take advantage of that [00:59:11] for my third grader, [00:59:12] you're asking me to split my family up, [00:59:14] to send some of my kids to North Shore, [00:59:16] and some of my kids to the new school. [00:59:19] So I just want you to consider that that is a situation [00:59:22] that many families have to reckon with. [00:59:25] And then on the disparity in access to these transfers, [00:59:31] I can't help but think about families [00:59:33] that have to use the buses. [00:59:36] Two parent families, two parents who work, [00:59:40] single parent families, [00:59:42] parents who do not have flexibility in their work schedules [00:59:46] and therefore have to put their kids on the bus, [00:59:48] parents who've got to get kids to multiple schools [00:59:51] across the district around the same time. [00:59:54] How do you think about that [00:59:57] when thinking about this universal offering of transfers [01:00:02] and the transfers, really, for the third scenario, [01:00:07] when it's really, it's just not a feasible option [01:00:11] for everyone that you're offering it to? [01:00:13] I think it's an incredibly fair point, [01:00:15] and that is the downside to transfers, right? [01:00:17] Access to transportation, [01:00:20] and that flexibility in your family schedule [01:00:24] to be able to use that transportation [01:00:26] is required to take advantage of the transfer opportunity. [01:00:30] We don't wanna sugarcoat that. [01:00:32] That is just a reality of that opportunity [01:00:34] and the limitation of that opportunity. [01:00:37] One thing I do wanna say is that the transfer possibility, [01:00:41] where continuity is concerned, [01:00:43] that would be extended regardless of the scenario [01:00:46] that we're talking about. [01:00:46] Now the extent to which we extend that offer, [01:00:50] would depend on the scenario we're talking about, [01:00:52] because the capacity at the schools impacted [01:00:56] would essentially pin us into what's possible. [01:01:00] But I also don't want any Hardin Valley parents [01:01:03] in the room to hear that that offer, [01:01:05] that opportunity would not apply to them as well. [01:01:09] But again, it applies with limitations. [01:01:11] And that's a limitation of transfers [01:01:13] just across the district, [01:01:14] whether we're talking about a resounding scenario, [01:01:17] or we're talking about just the general transfer process. [01:01:20] It's absolutely fair and it's not one financially [01:01:23] that we would be in a position [01:01:25] to be able to adjust in any way. [01:01:28] There's not a way to run buses in such a way [01:01:31] that would allow for us to clear that hurdle for transfers. [01:01:35] We're labeling it as a possibility, [01:01:37] but we also know that it is a very family contingent. [01:01:41] Yeah, and just definitely not a sweeping solution [01:01:44] to this problem. [01:01:47] My other question, I'm wondering if you could go, [01:01:49] I believe it was when you, [01:01:51] when you took that over after the maps, [01:01:55] that there's a slide that's implications. [01:01:58] And I, you guys have thought about this [01:02:01] from a million different, we know that. [01:02:05] And I also know that from which you have cut this. [01:02:13] But I want to better understand, [01:02:19] hoping to better understand some of the underlying data [01:02:28] that has led you to these decisions [01:02:33] that I imagine you could consider, but are just not here. [01:02:37] So, first one's pretty straightforward. [01:02:41] We are talking about kids who think [01:02:46] that they are going to go to one school and are not. [01:02:50] And I'm taking the Farragut kids who know this. [01:02:56] They know that they're gonna get a present. [01:02:59] But in scenario one, I'm talking about Hardin Valley kids. [01:03:02] In two, I'm talking about Hardin Valley, [01:03:05] that Concord Hills region, and North Shore kids. [01:03:09] And in scenario three, I'm talking about North Shore kids. [01:03:10] And in scenario three, I'm talking about North Shore kids. [01:03:11] And in scenario three, I'm talking about North Shore kids. [01:03:11] And in scenario three, I'm talking about North Shore kids. [01:03:11] And I think maybe you left Watt's kids off [01:03:14] of that feeder pattern. [01:03:15] In scenario two, you would not have left Watt's. [01:03:18] In scenario three, you left Watt's off that, bottom right. [01:03:23] Their feeder pattern changed. [01:03:24] Middle and high school does not change. [01:03:26] Their elementary school does. [01:03:28] So from there, I'll just say, Watt's is not listed. [01:03:37] Talking about real kids and real lives, [01:03:40] can you shed some light on the raw number of kids [01:03:45] who are moved out of their existing school [01:03:48] and into a new school in each of these three scenarios? [01:03:51] I know that the goal is to have a long range [01:03:54] under one school room and to minimize impact on kids. [01:03:58] So can you just tell us in one, two, and three, [01:04:01] how many kids are moved in each scenario? [01:04:05] Yes, but we might need to do some math [01:04:07] based on these posters. [01:04:08] So if we can start now, we can give that to you [01:04:11] before the end of the year. [01:04:12] And to be clear, I don't want enrollment numbers [01:04:14] because we have seen those. [01:04:15] I want to know the kids who are in kindergarten, [01:04:18] through fourth grade right now, who are going to move up [01:04:21] to a different school next year. [01:04:23] And I think that good policy is policy [01:04:27] that has already considered that. [01:04:29] And so I'm kind of surprised we don't have those numbers. [01:04:31] No, we do. [01:04:33] So in scenario one, I'll start with Harbor Valley. [01:04:36] So this is about 135 schools. [01:04:42] Portion of yard on road, out of Harbor Valley, [01:04:46] and into Farragut. [01:04:49] And I think what Corey was alluding to [01:04:51] is in each one of these off the top, [01:04:55] in each one of the tables that we have, [01:05:00] you can literally give your current enrollment [01:05:02] and then what the enrollment would be. [01:05:05] You can basically subtraction gets you where we're talking. [01:05:08] But is that, am I misunderstanding what you're asking? [01:05:14] No, I'm worried. [01:05:15] Like your enrollment factors in rising numbers. [01:05:19] I want to know the number of kids [01:05:22] who are currently sitting in seats, [01:05:27] who are going to be told by their parents [01:05:29] sometime in the next few weeks. [01:05:31] You're not going to the school [01:05:33] that you thought you were going to graduate fifth grade from. [01:05:36] Yes, ma'am, and that's what I'm talking about as well. [01:05:38] So those tables will reflect that. [01:05:40] So there are 135 students that are currently sitting in, [01:05:43] or yeah, I think it's 135 students [01:05:46] that are currently sitting in seats [01:05:47] at Harbor Valley Elementary right now as we speak [01:05:50] that under scenario one would move [01:05:52] from being Harbor Valley Elementary School students [01:05:54] to being students at the new Farragut Elementary next year. [01:05:59] Go over where you want to go. [01:06:02] Does it help if I tell you, Rick, [01:06:06] that I'm wrong? [01:06:07] You are saying 135 students, [01:06:10] you're not counting for the next year, the fifth graders, [01:06:13] right, we are talking about real students that would move. [01:06:15] So that's a grade by grade consideration. [01:06:18] I don't know if that helps, [01:06:19] but that is what is reflected in that number. [01:06:21] So on the Eastern scenario, it's about 165 students. [01:06:29] The North Shore, so there are 450 kids that live in Chando. [01:06:34] So that's what we're talking about here. [01:06:37] There are four. [01:06:37] Again, in scenario three, we're talking about 450 students [01:06:40] out of Chando, and it's about 120 students [01:06:43] that are coming out of lots to North Shore. [01:06:47] And again, I'm doing this off at the top of my head, [01:06:49] so if that math is not exactly correct, [01:06:51] again, you can check me by looking at current enrollment. [01:07:30] Conversation with the backdrop [01:07:32] of this school district being in a budget crisis. [01:07:37] And so I can't help but wonder [01:07:40] what the budget implications are of what you're thinking. [01:07:43] I think that's a phenomenal question. [01:07:49] I think it would be misleading of us to say [01:07:53] that budget is not a consideration in our mind [01:07:56] every single time we have a conversation right now. [01:07:59] So the conversation that we may potentially be having [01:08:04] beginning this year with school communities [01:08:06] is one very similar to this about rezoning, [01:08:10] but possibly even rezoning for the sake of consolidation [01:08:14] and school closure. [01:08:16] If you look at the map [01:08:17] that I had up, and I won't subject you all [01:08:19] to the toggling through all of it, [01:08:21] the map that we had up just a moment ago [01:08:23] in the western sector of the community [01:08:26] tells us there is no school to consolidate, right? [01:08:30] I don't have that fear, I'm not carrying that fear [01:08:33] in this conversation for this community. [01:08:36] Schools are mercy on the scenes. [01:08:37] That is a safety factor, but it does mean [01:08:40] that when we think about our long-term potential [01:08:43] as a community, we have to be realistic [01:08:46] that those capital dollars, [01:08:47] to alleviate congestion for all the areas in the red, [01:08:51] we probably don't have that, right? [01:08:54] And so that is part of why we're having [01:08:56] this conversation now. [01:08:57] It's part of what makes it so hard [01:09:00] to be having a conversation right now, [01:09:02] because these are communities, they're whole, [01:09:04] they're thriving, they're kids in seats [01:09:06] that are doing incredible work [01:09:08] and building relationships with their peers, [01:09:10] and we cannot discount that. [01:09:12] We do not want to discount that. [01:09:14] So we want to carry that reality for the kids, too, [01:09:17] today while we're also looking at [01:09:20] what we're headed toward five years from now. [01:09:23] Because I also want to think about the kids [01:09:25] five years from now, and I do not want to think [01:09:27] about the kids five years from now [01:09:28] at the expense of the ones that are in the classroom today. [01:09:32] So please do not hear me to say [01:09:34] that we're choosing one over the other. [01:09:36] We're having a conversation right now [01:09:39] to figure out how we might be able to move forward [01:09:43] as a community within the constraints [01:09:45] that we know we have to operate out of, [01:09:47] for the next foreseeable five, 10, 15 years. [01:09:51] And again, for those who have elevated, [01:09:54] let's have a longer conversation about that. [01:09:56] Yes, tell us that. [01:09:58] We want to know that. [01:10:00] A suspicion, and I told a group this yesterday, [01:10:03] maybe it was in the parking lot, [01:10:05] so I'll share with this group, [01:10:06] a suspicion that we brought into the conversation [01:10:10] that actually has been re-informed by these conversations [01:10:14] was that there would be a large desire, [01:10:17] potentially, among a population of students [01:10:20] that are currently zoned for North Shore Elementary, [01:10:23] bound for Farragut Middle School, [01:10:25] bound for Farragut High School, [01:10:27] that that continuity of the feeder pattern, [01:10:29] building those relationships early on [01:10:31] to be able to go to a school [01:10:33] that matriculates directly into Farragut Middle [01:10:35] and matriculates directly into Farragut High School, [01:10:37] that might be an advantage to families. [01:10:39] So that was something we wanted to pulse check, right? [01:10:43] If we had found out and we walked into a community meeting [01:10:45] and they said, oh my gosh, [01:10:46] that's amazing. [01:10:48] Well, a lot of things just became possible [01:10:49] and comfortable all at one time. [01:10:52] That didn't happen, right? [01:10:54] So we are learning together as a community [01:10:57] what feels right, what feels wrong, [01:10:59] and how we can make the best use of that. [01:11:02] We had to come to the table with questions, [01:11:04] and there's really no more transparent way [01:11:06] to ask those questions than what we're doing right now. [01:11:09] It doesn't feel good, but at the end of the day, [01:11:13] we want to know what you're feeling [01:11:15] because the worst case, [01:11:16] we make a proposal that's not informed by this, [01:11:19] and we find out after the fact why we messed a lot up. [01:11:22] So thank you for sharing that. [01:11:25] I've now gone off on this trail to the point [01:11:26] that I've lost whatever it was that you said [01:11:28] that inspired me so much. [01:11:30] It was the budget conversation. [01:11:31] Yes, I mean, it's a looming consideration. [01:11:33] It's a long way of saying that. [01:11:34] So just to be clear, [01:11:36] there are no actual figures in the short, medium, [01:11:41] or long term that you guys have to say that scenario one, [01:11:46] scenario two, or scenario three is more or less costly [01:11:49] to the district. [01:11:49] Oh, I'm sorry. [01:11:50] I misunderstood the question, [01:11:51] so that was a very long walk to not answer your question. [01:11:54] In terms of the actual scenario one [01:11:57] versus scenario two versus scenario three, [01:11:59] because we're talking about kiddos moving [01:12:01] and teachers largely moving with students, [01:12:04] honestly, the cost savings for us, [01:12:07] these are not cost-saving conversations. [01:12:09] These are conversations about what we need to do [01:12:13] to address overcrowding in a budgetary environment [01:12:17] that does not provide for capital solutions. [01:12:19] So we're not suggesting this to save money. [01:12:23] So that is not an analysis that we're carrying [01:12:26] into this conversation, [01:12:28] because the difference really is nominal at best [01:12:31] from one scenario to another to another. [01:12:33] This is a scenario where it makes it very, very easy [01:12:35] to just do what's right for kids. [01:12:37] That's not something that we're hearing. [01:12:43] Well, once to a few questions [01:12:44] that I've heard this evening, [01:12:46] and I wanna first mention that I think emotions [01:12:49] are really high, [01:12:50] because when we first started this conversation, [01:12:52] we mentioned, hey, we're starting this conversation early, [01:12:55] and we have plenty of time, [01:12:57] and so I think that really charged the audience, [01:13:03] and I actually went to lots when it first opened, [01:13:12] and I have been, and for you to mention [01:13:18] that you also worked in dollars for this year, [01:13:33] when you have been in that situation, [01:13:44] is that the type of society that we wanna be a part of, [01:13:47] where we just say, we're not gonna consider the night, [01:13:59] and you have mentioned many times that we wanna make sure [01:14:02] we do what's right for the kids. [01:14:05] I think that includes all the kids in the community, [01:14:08] not just the ones who are parents. [01:14:14] So I will say, and this has come up a couple of times, [01:14:17] so the graphics aren't part of it. [01:14:25] I understand why, these years are justifying decisions [01:14:33] based on numbers, but I'm saying you have [01:14:35] a unique opportunity to really enhance the lives [01:14:38] of future children in this area into consideration. [01:14:45] Should like, code it any way you want, [01:14:47] give it any type of statistic, whatever, [01:14:49] but in this room, we know what we're doing, [01:14:50] we know what we're talking about, [01:14:52] and how we're gonna be helping over the next few years. [01:14:58] And another question I know has been brought up [01:15:01] for all the red schools that have been built up, [01:15:06] and you said that you have used data over the past five years. [01:15:10] I mean, I think you can employ, [01:15:13] utilize a little bit of AI and figure out [01:15:16] what are the actual projected numbers instead of using, [01:15:26] I didn't realize that you were in charge of transportation, [01:15:29] so maybe you didn't give those numbers [01:15:32] here, but if those numbers are available, [01:15:34] you can provide an addendum to show [01:15:37] what the transportation impact, [01:15:40] because once you, unless you're willing to say, [01:15:51] okay, we selected scenario one, two, or three, [01:15:55] but we are open to. [01:16:09] After you're talking about the traffic impacts? [01:16:10] Yeah, the traffic impact. [01:16:15] I will say, a lot of the things [01:16:21] that we've talked about tonight, [01:16:22] a lot of the slides that have popped up here, [01:16:24] centered around kids, the numbers of, [01:16:29] reasonably here, is the fact that kids are not farmers, [01:16:38] and that is not the only thing that gets talked about. [01:16:56] Our experience is not difficult to put it on the SS, [01:17:23] it's harder data if you. [01:17:43] You said though earlier that you can't, [01:17:48] the suggestion, but you're not going to socioeconomic. [01:17:53] We want to base them on the human factor, right? [01:17:56] In terms of impact to your family, [01:17:58] and so I do want to honor, [01:17:59] we're talking about two different things, right? [01:18:00] When I say impact to your family, [01:18:02] I'm talking about routines, [01:18:03] I'm talking about travel patterns. [01:18:05] I want to take the scenario. [01:18:06] I'm sorry, I apologize, but impact to my family, [01:18:10] my family is gonna be fine, [01:18:12] but my son is going to live in a community [01:18:16] where the parents could not be here [01:18:18] to represent their concern [01:18:21] about their routine in the morning. [01:18:23] So whether you choose one, two, or three, [01:18:26] I'm gonna be fine. [01:18:27] My kids are gonna be fine. [01:18:28] It'll be fine, kids adapt. [01:18:29] But you need to take into account [01:18:32] for the parents that are not here, [01:18:34] and the community, and the children, [01:18:36] and the human factor of the people who are. [01:18:40] I appreciate that. [01:18:41] So quick clarification, [01:18:42] I meant that when we're talking about zoning, [01:18:46] I'm separating what I'm about to say [01:18:48] from what I said about the survey. [01:18:49] When I'm talking about wanting your input on the survey, [01:18:53] I meant the input on the impact [01:18:55] that these scenarios would have on our family. [01:18:56] Now I want to go to what you're talking about, right? [01:18:59] So let's talk about that socioeconomic factor, [01:19:02] because this is something that does matter a lot to me. [01:19:05] I want to phrase what we're talking about in a different way. [01:19:08] So I want to phrase it, [01:19:10] if we play it out to its ultimate conclusion, [01:19:12] like this. [01:19:13] This community, this lower income subset of the community, [01:19:16] geographically, you're gonna have to bypass [01:19:20] a couple of school zones to go over here, [01:19:23] because we need to save this more affluent area [01:19:26] to keep it at this school [01:19:27] to make sure the PTO is staying afloat. [01:19:29] And I know that's not what you're saying, [01:19:31] I know that's not what you're saying, [01:19:33] but in practice, if we are zoning, [01:19:36] and we are looking at movement of students, [01:19:38] and we are looking at capacity, [01:19:40] if we're saying that, [01:19:41] we have to move a certain number of students, [01:19:45] there can't be socioeconomic reasons [01:19:48] that would shelter a group of families against that. [01:19:52] I mean, this specific scenario for Knox County, [01:20:01] there is a factor that should be taken to account [01:20:06] for a scenario to further segregate [01:20:13] the lower income population, [01:20:16] and that will not benefit the community. [01:20:21] You can take that into account specifically, [01:20:24] with one, two, and three. [01:20:26] You don't need to use it every single time. [01:20:29] Next time you do a school zoning issue, [01:20:31] you don't need to consider that as a factor, [01:20:34] but that is a factor in three. [01:20:36] And to be clear, I'm not saying that I wanna keep [01:20:39] one area better or one area worse. [01:20:43] I'm saying keep it mixed, which is what it is right now. [01:20:47] So with your decision to change, [01:20:50] it will make the situation worse. [01:20:54] Any change to any school zone has a risk [01:20:58] of changing the demographics in that school zone, [01:21:00] and we do recognize that. [01:21:10] To reiterate all of this, [01:21:11] my family would be fine, right? [01:21:13] It was pretty difficult to sit on the couch last night [01:21:16] with my fourth grader, my fifth grader, [01:21:19] that's not so much impacted, but my first grader, [01:21:21] and look at the map and tell her which friends [01:21:23] would be going to North Shore with her [01:21:25] if she were to be rezoned in which part. [01:21:27] And I understand that this is a challenging decision [01:21:30] that you guys have to make, [01:21:31] and that families are impacted either way. [01:21:36] I'm lucky enough to be one of those families [01:21:38] that I feel like can support ALLOTs in the community, [01:21:41] and the students that are there. [01:21:43] I will be taken out of ALLOTs. [01:21:46] So my family's support no longer goes. [01:21:52] We're both working parents, and this scenario automatically, [01:21:56] I know, takes me out of the YMCA after school program, [01:21:59] and now I'm scrambling. [01:22:01] How are my children getting home from school? [01:22:07] Responses to the fact of this red school zone, [01:22:11] and not taking into consideration Bearden, [01:22:14] Rocky Hill, and Sequoia. [01:22:17] It blows my mind, the feelings that we're feeling, [01:22:21] and how we're reacting to this. [01:22:25] You acknowledged through these slides [01:22:28] that scenario three is being considered [01:22:31] for the opportunity to relieve the Kingston Pike area. [01:22:36] If you didn't put that in your slides, [01:22:39] I wouldn't be so concerned about it. [01:22:40] That's not the point. [01:22:41] That is something that you're considering. [01:22:43] And the fact that those families aren't going [01:22:45] to be impacted next year, or maybe the year after, [01:22:49] but you're only considering scenario three [01:22:52] because you're considering how you will impact those families. [01:22:57] And so to not even notify them, [01:23:00] and give them an opportunity to have their voice [01:23:02] as part of this discussion, [01:23:05] knowing that they will be impacted if you choose that, [01:23:09] is, in my opinion, very disgraceful. [01:23:11] For this entire scenario. [01:23:13] And again, my biggest concern in the takeaway [01:23:16] is not my personal family. [01:23:19] It's all of those families [01:23:20] that you're completely disregarding [01:23:22] when you know that the decision that you're making right now [01:23:26] has the potential to influence them, [01:23:28] and you're just not even giving them an opportunity. [01:23:30] So I don't even have a question. [01:23:32] I think in the way that you're going to frame that, [01:23:35] moving forward, I feel like you should be [01:23:37] a little more careful in the back and forth [01:23:39] that you've done. [01:23:40] And like, it's all over the slides. [01:23:42] You're taking this into consideration [01:23:44] because it's this big red zone. [01:23:46] And then also say, oh well, it's not going to impact them, [01:23:49] so we don't even, they don't even need to know. [01:24:03] And share our concerns and our desires of our heart. [01:24:10] Parents of AL1s, I'm speaking as a staff member of AL1s, [01:24:13] I'm going to speak as a teacher who has taught Knox County [01:24:16] at a school that was 100% family-based learning. [01:24:20] I taught there for five years. [01:24:22] I taught at another school that was 97. [01:24:24] We had reduced lunch for four years in the community [01:24:29] to make the school run. [01:24:31] And whenever I move to AL1s, and the one thing I say now, [01:24:36] I will retire from AL1s. [01:24:41] AOM is one of the best schools in Knox County. [01:24:45] Not because of the staff, not because of our principals who [01:24:49] are phenomenal, not because of our students, [01:24:52] but because of our parents. [01:24:54] And when you choose to rezone this school, [01:24:57] and move the neighborhoods that you're planning to move [01:25:02] to North Shore, which is also a phenomenal school [01:25:05] with phenomenal parents, staff, principals, and students, [01:25:10] you're taking away from what AL1s has. [01:25:17] But those nine years have been one of the best, [01:25:20] some of the best years of my life. [01:25:22] My child who is in fourth grade, not affected by this, [01:25:27] guess what, I'm a staff member there. [01:25:33] That's new. [01:25:34] Or if there's not enough people to volunteer, [01:25:36] HR is going to come in and say, hey, [01:25:39] you're going to be voluntold to move. [01:25:41] What considerations have you all taken into effect [01:25:57] of the emotional, the mental health of our students, [01:26:03] the parents? [01:26:05] Also thinking, going back to numbers. [01:26:10] Our kids aren't numbers, but we talk numbers all the time. [01:26:14] All the schools that you're moving kids from [01:26:18] are dropping to under 900 students. [01:26:21] 900 students. [01:26:22] 900 is the threshold for an assistant principal. [01:26:27] This year we lost an assistant principal, and it sucks. [01:26:30] I'm not going to lie. [01:26:31] It sucks. [01:26:33] It's been hard for our principals. [01:26:35] It's been hard for us staff. [01:26:37] It's been hard for our students. [01:26:39] I don't get the pleasure of seeing my principals [01:26:41] on a daily basis because now there's two. [01:26:45] And our SPED cases are on the rise. [01:26:48] Our students with needs are on the rise. [01:26:50] Our ELL population is on the rise. [01:26:52] And they're in meetings all the time. [01:26:56] So what supports, what research have you done [01:27:03] as a county, as the school board, [01:27:07] to make sure and ensure that our students, [01:27:10] our staff, our principals, our parents are supported? [01:27:14] Because right now, we don't feel supported. [01:27:18] Appreciate the question. [01:27:19] And I think it's a phenomenal question. [01:27:21] So I'll say a couple of things. [01:27:22] We got a similar question. [01:27:23] We got a similar question. [01:27:24] We got a similar question last night, [01:27:25] but it was through the student lens. [01:27:27] So I'll answer student lens first. [01:27:29] I know that was one of the categories you mentioned. [01:27:31] And then I'll take the others. [01:27:33] So the student question, the student-focused question [01:27:35] we got last night was essentially, [01:27:37] have we looked into the research on the impact of zoning, right? [01:27:41] Changing schools on students. [01:27:43] And the answer that I gave last night [01:27:45] was not through the zoning lens, [01:27:48] but incidentally, as we were doing, [01:27:51] exploring what to do with Farragut Primary School, [01:27:53] Farragut Intermediate School, [01:27:55] the research that was conducted in that space [01:27:58] was what do transitions do to students, right? [01:28:01] They hurt. [01:28:02] Grade band transitions are challenging. [01:28:05] Students lose learning. [01:28:07] That confidence sometimes takes a backslide, right? [01:28:10] Kids are resilient. [01:28:11] But at the end of the day, [01:28:12] being able to provide continuity is better for kids. [01:28:16] And we know that. [01:28:17] So the answer I gave last night was the same research [01:28:21] that went into the conversion of Farragut Primary School [01:28:25] and the conversion of Farragut Intermediate School [01:28:27] into these K-5 elementary schools [01:28:29] really applies here as well, right? [01:28:31] Rezoning is disruptive. [01:28:33] It is difficult on students. [01:28:35] And I don't want to discount that. [01:28:37] When I say, and I actually want to honor [01:28:40] everyone's feedback about that conversation, [01:28:43] that line about starting the conversation early, [01:28:46] I understand absolutely that we're talking about [01:28:49] a very quick proposal. [01:28:51] That we are making. [01:28:53] So I want to take a step back real quick and say [01:28:55] that when I say we're starting this conversation early, [01:28:59] we are pulse checking for, [01:29:02] in each community we're talking about, [01:29:05] what is the desire to potentially move? [01:29:09] And where are the road points [01:29:11] so that we can think further down the line? [01:29:14] Now, we're thinking further down the line, [01:29:16] and in our mind, we're starting the conversation early [01:29:19] just to say there's not a crisis, right? [01:29:21] There's not a right now problem that we have to solve. [01:29:24] So we have some time on our hands [01:29:27] to potentially slow down this conversation. [01:29:31] That's what we're checking from you all on. [01:29:33] Honestly, it's what we're hearing from you all. [01:29:35] We're starting the conversation in our minds [01:29:38] before there is a crisis, [01:29:40] so that if we do wind up in a situation [01:29:43] in which we're talking about rezoning, [01:29:45] the only thing that we actually can do [01:29:48] to mitigate the negative impacts of rezoning [01:29:51] on students is to offer a transfer opportunity [01:29:54] with the recognition that that's limited, right? [01:29:57] The ability to take access and advantage [01:30:01] of that transfer opportunity, [01:30:03] it's already been labeled. [01:30:05] That is in and of itself a privilege, [01:30:07] and we know that, [01:30:09] but it's really the only tool, [01:30:11] the only strategy we have at our disposal [01:30:13] to potentially be able to mitigate [01:30:15] the negative impacts of rezoning on students. [01:30:18] So if we know that we might be moving [01:30:20] toward a future in which rezoning is necessary, [01:30:24] we would be remiss for the sake of those students [01:30:27] that will be impacted, [01:30:29] not to start a conversation early enough [01:30:32] to potentially be able to offer [01:30:35] a very long runway in the form of transfers. [01:30:39] Because once we get to a point in which [01:30:41] we have to rezone communities [01:30:43] and kids have to move next year, [01:30:45] and they do not get an opportunity [01:30:48] to remain at their school [01:30:50] unless they're a rising fifth grader, right? [01:30:52] We know that that felt impact [01:30:55] is gonna be felt from kindergarten [01:30:57] through fourth grade. [01:30:58] So that's just, it's a reality [01:31:00] that we're carrying in our minds, [01:31:02] because we do know that that's what the research says [01:31:04] about what's right for kids. [01:31:06] So I wanna recognize that, [01:31:08] and I wanna honor that there's not a good answer there, [01:31:11] but we're trying to make what could be [01:31:13] a difficult situation as manageable as possible [01:31:16] for students and families later on down the line. [01:31:18] That's number one. [01:31:19] The rest of your question really was about [01:31:22] supports for schools, right? [01:31:24] And recognizing that when my enrollment drops, [01:31:27] so too does the body of support around me as a school. [01:31:32] And that's a reality. [01:31:33] It's a reality for schools with dropping enrollment. [01:31:36] It's a reality for schools that may potentially [01:31:38] go through some version of this process. [01:31:40] It's potentially a reality for Farragut Primary, [01:31:42] Farragut Intermediate that are being rezoned [01:31:45] and just by merit of changing the grade bands [01:31:48] of those schools, their capacity's changing, [01:31:51] and taking them to that 900 max capacity [01:31:53] from a programmatic standpoint threshold, [01:31:55] that's a challenge. [01:31:57] And so that was something that principals, [01:31:59] and I want you all, staff members in the room, [01:32:01] know your principals are advocating for you. [01:32:03] Principals shared that with us on a call [01:32:05] when we initially began this conversation. [01:32:08] Have we considered that? [01:32:09] What we said is, you know what? [01:32:11] The budget is limited, but continue to talk to us [01:32:14] about those thresholds when we talk about [01:32:17] administrator thresholds and what we're able [01:32:19] to award to schools. [01:32:20] If we can make some of these long-range decisions [01:32:24] to maximize our budgets, we might be able [01:32:27] to resource the schools that we have more deeply. [01:32:30] And at the end of the day, when we're having [01:32:32] all these hard conversations, it's because we want [01:32:36] to be able to resource the schools that we have [01:32:39] as deeply and as meaningfully as possible. [01:32:42] Sometimes that's a dollars and cents conversation [01:32:44] and it doesn't feel good and I don't want to pay [01:32:46] you to do anything other than that. [01:32:51] What's frustrating to me, and I hear you say, [01:32:53] or I heard you say earlier, is none of these options [01:32:56] are money-saving potential options. [01:33:01] But also what's frustrating is I've been at LUTs [01:33:06] when the enrollment was 1,100 students. [01:33:08] We were busting at the seams, out of the portables, [01:33:11] teachers on a car, all of that. [01:33:13] And now that we are under 900 students, [01:33:16] you're saying we're so overcrowded and we've got [01:33:18] to move our 170 students. [01:33:20] It's the lowest enrollment we've ever had, [01:33:22] but yet we're overcrowded. [01:33:24] As a teacher, I'm fine with my 25 students that I teach. [01:33:31] The portables, I've taught in a portable. [01:33:34] It was fine. [01:33:35] I can still do my job and my kids can still learn. [01:33:39] To make that as a great thing to check off, [01:33:45] that we eliminate the portables. [01:33:47] Our principal fought tooth and nail years ago [01:33:50] to get more portables so we could have classrooms [01:33:54] for teachers, and we were told no. [01:33:56] Couldn't happen. [01:33:58] And now you want to take those away. [01:34:00] They were taken away whenever they rezoned North Shore. [01:34:03] And then we needed them back. [01:34:05] What's going to stop that from happening again, number one? [01:34:09] But then number two, all of these proposals suck. [01:34:13] None of them work great. [01:34:15] I mean, in reality, if I'm a Hardin Valley parent [01:34:18] or a staff member, it sucks. [01:34:20] If I'm lots North Shore anywhere, it's [01:34:31] away from being made into Carnes, [01:34:36] which Carnes is going to feed into Hardin Valley. [01:34:39] I get all of that. [01:34:40] So if we do scenario three where we don't touch Hardin Valley at all [01:34:46] in five years, guess where we're at? [01:34:49] We're sitting right here again having the same conversation [01:34:52] because Hardin Valley is overcrowded [01:34:54] and we need to move lots of people again [01:34:56] because we've got to continue moving other people around. [01:34:59] When is it going to stop? [01:35:01] So I don't know when it's going to stop. [01:35:04] But what I will say is you landed on something [01:35:06] that I don't want to move off of. [01:35:08] And this is a good time for me to just do a quick reminder [01:35:11] that we want to answer questions. [01:35:14] But if we've moved into feedback, right, [01:35:16] if we've moved into this is what these scenarios do to me [01:35:19] and this is what I need you to know as you go out and build that, [01:35:22] please use the survey, right? [01:35:24] So if there are questions, we will take those questions. [01:35:27] And you landed on something that I just want to call out. [01:35:30] You say, I'm fine with my 25 kids, right? [01:35:33] This is the most comfortable lots he's ever felt. [01:35:35] Put that in the survey. [01:35:37] When we say we want to know what the felt impact is, [01:35:40] I am genuinely saying that's the intent of the survey. [01:35:43] So please, please, please put that in there. [01:35:46] And that is the context that we're looking for. [01:35:49] So thank you for that. [01:35:56] Sorry, I want to go back real quick. [01:35:58] This is quick. [01:35:59] So if we are not on the survey list, who this rezoning [01:36:04] and KnoxSchools.org, is that a good email address to give to our parents? [01:36:08] That would be a great place to start. [01:36:10] And y'all are going to treat those the same as the survey for feedback? [01:36:13] On these specific scenarios, I would say that depending on the nature of the feedback, [01:36:19] if they're pertinent, yes. [01:36:21] If we're talking about feedback that doesn't pertain to the same areas. [01:36:24] Scenario three does impact Sequoia. [01:36:26] So I'm going to give this email address to our parents. [01:36:29] And they can provide feedback, correct? [01:36:31] Okay. [01:36:32] The other thing is, [01:36:33] thank you both for being here, [01:36:34] because I know that I would not want to field these questions. [01:36:37] So thank you for being here tonight. [01:36:38] I actually do really appreciate your time. [01:36:41] I do have one question. [01:36:42] This is a big deal. [01:36:44] This is going to impact a lot of families in Knox County, [01:36:47] regardless of what scenario is picked, right? [01:36:50] Where is the superintendent? [01:36:53] Our superintendent, I will say this, [01:36:56] and we have done rezoning for years, right? [01:36:59] Maybe not like this. [01:37:00] But in rezoning conversations, [01:37:02] it is not uncommon, [01:37:04] and actually it would be wildly uncommon for a superintendent [01:37:07] to be in a rezoning conversation. [01:37:09] But the superintendent will absolutely be making remarks [01:37:12] and be there for and be supporting the proposal [01:37:16] that is made to the Board of Education. [01:37:18] So if you are looking for that insight, [01:37:21] I would very much recommend to look for the Board Week, [01:37:24] because we'll have that presentation on the Monday. [01:37:26] You're going to hear from the superintendent on that Monday. [01:37:29] And then you'll also have answering questions [01:37:31] back and forth, [01:37:32] Q&A, [01:37:33] on the voting meeting that Thursday night on December 10th. [01:37:36] Okay. [01:37:39] I need to clarify something. [01:37:42] Sorry. [01:37:43] From what I understand from looking at your slides, [01:37:46] it's contrary to something that my neighbor down the street [01:37:50] understood from the meeting last night that she heard. [01:37:53] So in scenario three, [01:37:55] are all of the students who are currently at Lotz [01:37:59] to North Shore going to then be feeding in the [01:38:06] into Farragut Middle School? [01:38:08] Because what she heard was West Rappaport. [01:38:11] No. [01:38:12] These scenarios do not touch middle schools or high schools. [01:38:15] Except that it does right there on the bottom line. [01:38:18] Say that one more time. [01:38:19] No. [01:38:20] So I guess what this is trying to illustrate is that [01:38:24] the students that will be rezoning scenario three, [01:38:27] they're highlighted in that sort of bottom right box, [01:38:30] currently go North Shore, FMS, FHS. [01:38:34] This is trying to illustrate that, [01:38:36] if in scenario three, [01:38:37] they would go to the new school that is being built [01:38:39] on Boring Road instead of North Shore, [01:38:41] then they would continue to go to FMS, FHS. [01:38:45] Okay. [01:38:46] That's a really good catch, [01:38:49] and it does need to be updated. [01:38:51] So I caught up to what you were saying. [01:38:54] Yep. [01:38:55] So for these two, [01:38:56] essentially what we were looking at [01:38:58] and the intent behind this, [01:38:59] which you're not wrong, right? [01:39:01] There's missing information there. [01:39:03] The intent behind the call-outs here [01:39:05] is to identify where we might be [01:39:07] eliminating or disrupting feeder pattern parity, [01:39:10] so taking students away from that peer group [01:39:13] that they would move through middle and high school with, [01:39:15] versus where we might be giving students more proximity. [01:39:19] That was the intent, but you're not wrong. [01:39:21] There's some missing lines there. [01:39:22] Okay. [01:39:23] So where I live, [01:39:24] so now I'm looking, [01:39:25] my rising fifth grader is either going to have to leave [01:39:32] all of her friends, [01:39:33] because we're currently zoned for Farragut High School, [01:39:40] but that relates to my transfer question. [01:39:43] You know, you talked about transfers, [01:39:46] potential or so. [01:39:47] Okay, she's going to be in fifth grade. [01:39:49] Maybe she'd be able to stay. [01:39:50] I also have a rising kindergartner. [01:39:53] I'm assuming a transfer, [01:39:55] does it have to be done every year, [01:39:57] is one question. [01:39:59] Yes. [01:40:00] No, I'm sorry. [01:40:01] Phenomenal question. [01:40:02] You will re-up it every single year. [01:40:06] Do not reapply. [01:40:07] So as long as a family wants to remain at that school, [01:40:11] a transfer is through [01:40:12] the terminal grade at that school. [01:40:14] That's just a phenomenal question, [01:40:15] I should have said. [01:40:17] Including for if the kindergartner just stayed alone. [01:40:22] But I assume that does not apply to middle school, right? [01:40:27] It does not. [01:40:28] So then you would be applying for a middle school transfer [01:40:31] if you wanted to create parity there. [01:40:33] She absolutely loved being in the porthole. [01:40:41] She was so excited that she got to walk outside every day. [01:40:45] It's like, Mom! [01:40:49] So, Mr. Dillingham, Mrs. Lockhart, [01:41:06] I want to ask something that you accepted the charge for [01:41:13] until we appreciate you being here. [01:41:14] You charged me, as the school principal, [01:41:21] to care for and lead my school, [01:41:28] trust and communication. [01:41:29] I do that with my families. [01:41:33] Yet it seems like as a district, [01:41:35] we may have missed the cue on some of those, [01:41:38] if not all three of those. [01:41:40] And I just wonder if our school's names, [01:41:43] Bearden, Sequoia, Rocky Hill, [01:41:46] if our school names are on a slide for a potential reason, [01:41:50] why it wasn't more broadly communicated for those schools. [01:41:53] You all mentioned last week a potential reason for us, [01:41:58] but this wasn't it. [01:42:00] And so I'm just wondering, my question is, [01:42:03] these things, why were they not communicated to principals [01:42:06] so that we would be able to clearly articulate to our families [01:42:10] when it gets out? [01:42:11] Because I only found out about it after the meeting last night. [01:42:15] I had no idea, and that's why I'm here tonight, [01:42:17] just to make sure I'm not missing any information [01:42:19] that I can share with my families. [01:42:21] But why is it not communicated within our own people? [01:42:24] And then why not more broadly communicated [01:42:28] to those other schools and families? [01:42:30] I don't know the question. [01:42:34] And I think very well put, very well taken. [01:42:36] And so yes, absolutely, we will take that to heart, [01:42:39] especially as we, that's good learning for us. [01:42:47] What I would say about the communication to families [01:42:51] in particular, trying to determine is whether or not [01:42:59] we are looking at a ripple effect that might affect families. [01:43:03] And so the intent and just saying, [01:43:05] let's have a contained conversation and let's talk first [01:43:09] about where we're even creating capacity, [01:43:13] if anywhere, to determine what communities [01:43:16] do we disrupt at that point. [01:43:18] Some of that is just not wanting people to be concerned [01:43:21] or to be nervous about something that may not even actually [01:43:25] come to fruition. [01:43:26] I would say, especially as we go further, you know, [01:43:30] least down the Kingston pipeline, [01:43:33] the North Shore corridor, you know, [01:43:35] we don't even know yet if we were to create capacity [01:43:38] that would allow us to move in that direction, [01:43:41] is are we having a conversation with the entire corridor? [01:43:46] Are we going to take it in pieces, right? [01:43:48] And some of that is contingent on the zoning lines [01:43:51] that wind up getting drawn. [01:43:53] If we wound up locking in on one of these, [01:43:55] I mean, there's a lot of next step guesses we could make. [01:43:58] But if we want to be true to this process and say, [01:44:01] we're not sure what that purpose is, [01:44:03] what our proposal is going to look like when we make it [01:44:05] to the board, we don't even know how broad to expand [01:44:08] that next realm of the conversation. [01:44:10] And so I think it's a phenomenal point. [01:44:12] I want you to know kind of why it didn't expand that far. [01:44:16] So from our perspective, that's why it didn't expand that far. [01:44:19] And it really was just out of respect for school communities [01:44:22] that may not be affected. [01:44:23] And so that was the initial thinking. [01:44:25] But we will think on that. [01:44:30] Do you have something? [01:44:40] You know, on that slide, [01:44:46] all of her presented can go. [01:44:51] So we feed it into Farragut Middle, Farragut High. [01:44:56] And take into account the folks that are at . [01:45:06] Where if the Arizona 3 happens, [01:45:08] and then have to go back to West Valley. [01:45:10] So they're going to make all these friends maybe at, you know. [01:45:17] And then most of those friends are going to go on Farragut. [01:45:21] And, you know, it bothers me that it wasn't even on the slide. [01:45:29] Because regardless, I just want to know if it was in that little tiny area [01:45:45] where the line just doesn't seem like a lot of it was thought through. [01:45:54] Because I have a neighborhood that's right in front of me [01:45:58] that will be going still to Watts. [01:46:00] But I am 20 feet away from them and will be going to North Shore. [01:46:06] And so the bus will have to pass by those kids [01:46:12] and then pass by us again to take them to Watts. [01:46:16] And then my kid is going to have to wait on a bus. [01:46:19] And then go. [01:46:21] And instead of going just around, get on Pellissippi. [01:46:26] Which as a local, we've always called it like a raceway. [01:46:32] So I don't love the fact that my kid is going to be on a bus on Pellissippi Parkway. [01:46:37] Good school. [01:46:43] And have to go on a parkway to get there. [01:46:46] So I know that you have a little depth of traffic patterns. [01:46:50] But I also want to look at, you know, maybe when we're looking at things, [01:46:55] we should also look at the dangers of buses rerouting children across parkways and interstates. [01:47:03] When they have a perfectly good school in their backyard. [01:47:06] They are, like, and to that extent, like, so right now, [01:47:16] I make a loop that goes right here to Bay of Lots. [01:47:20] And then he left our door from door to door. [01:47:26] He left, went to Bay of Lots, went to West Valley, and came back. [01:47:31] And was there door to door in 2015. [01:47:33] That's two kids, two car lights, all the traffic. [01:47:36] 25 minutes. [01:47:37] Now, what is going to happen is we are going to have to go across Pellissippi Parkway to North Shore. [01:47:46] And then come across Pellissippi Parkway and then get back on past lots again [01:47:52] to get across to another school, to West Valley, to then go home. [01:47:57] So you are taking a 25 minute drop off of two kids, roundabout, [01:48:02] to making both my kids go in two separate directions. [01:48:06] So it seems like the feeders and kids, the parents that have kids in elementary and middle school and high school [01:48:16] weren't taken into effect, or taken into account because they're going in two different directions. [01:48:22] And meanwhile, the kids that are next, like, right in front of me, [01:48:34] than it is to that school. [01:48:37] So I just want to know if that was taken into consideration. [01:48:40] The danger of buses on highways. [01:48:43] The implication of parents with multiple kids in multiple schools. [01:48:49] And how that's going to put it in two different directions. [01:48:52] When ALOTs and West Valley are so close together. [01:48:55] It makes so much sense to go, you know, right around. [01:48:58] And also to that effect, if you're thinking of transfers, cool, that's nice. [01:49:04] But if, so okay, let's say my kid gets a transfer. [01:49:09] Yay! [01:49:10] So she's 20 feet away from that bus stop. [01:49:13] But does that mean, can we, like, sneak on that bus? [01:49:17] So, like, you know, because it's 20 feet. [01:49:20] But you're saying that I wouldn't have that opportunity and have my kid ride the bus. [01:49:27] Because it's, you know, I'm a transfer. [01:49:29] And when, and if you haven't, and I would love to hear that you have considered these. [01:49:39] And I guess that's my question is, have these things been considered? [01:49:43] The dangers of philosophy, the routing of multiple parents and things like that. [01:49:49] And also to what somebody had said about the emotional aspect. [01:49:52] Has anxiety, like her sister, like her mother. [01:50:01] And what is really upsetting is that my third grader is so terrified of the T-caps and the retention law. [01:50:13] And all that crap that goes with third grade right now. [01:50:15] She's been going to for four years. [01:50:27] That her big sister went to for six years. [01:50:30] That I personally have donated my time and money to. [01:50:33] She's not going to get to do that. [01:50:35] She's not going to get to do the fun tradition that her sister did in fourth grade and in fifth grade. [01:50:40] She's not going to get to go on these things. [01:50:42] She's not going to get to have her sister teach her. [01:50:44] And it just, it's upsetting that it's nice that we're giving that, you know, automatic thing for fourth graders. [01:50:52] You know, so in fifth grade they're not disrupted. [01:50:56] But the third graders, they're already having a hard time with T-caps and retention and all that crap. [01:51:02] And now to be, for them to be the first ones that are affected. [01:51:06] I will say this and then I know Ryan has some context that's worth adding to Pella City Parkway. [01:51:19] So I don't want to miss the question that you've asked. [01:51:21] But I will also say that regardless of what Ryan shares with me. [01:51:25] When I say there's feedback that we're looking for and it is on, it is about the impact that these scenarios would have on you. [01:51:34] That is what we're looking for. [01:51:36] We need to put that in the survey. [01:51:38] So we've heard it, but I am asking you to put that in the survey as well. [01:51:43] Do you want to address Pell City Parkway? [01:51:45] And one other thing. [01:51:47] Over at the school, at this very high school, the other half goes West Valley Deer. [01:51:59] There, I don't know, so just like that part of the feeder avenue regardless of the state. [01:52:06] In that area where we're talking about, like our bus routes don't currently access Pell City Parkway. [01:52:11] And as I said to one of the other people earlier, generally speaking what we try to do is mirror the bus routes that already exist. [01:52:17] Just turn them toward another school. [01:52:19] So like I'm not actually anticipating our buses utilizing Pell City Parkway at this point. [01:52:24] Fox Road, Henry Church. [01:52:27] We run it right now. [01:52:35] We run it right now. [01:52:39] Spacious, nice roads. [01:52:40] I'm telling you that we pick up kids on those roads as we speak. [01:52:43] And that's what we're saying. [01:52:47] So Ryan's telling you this would be the implication behind that strategy, right? [01:52:51] That's how that would work. [01:52:53] We are hearing we don't like that, right? [01:52:56] So put that in the survey. [01:53:27] Keep more field. [01:53:33] That's what I was looking for. [01:53:34] That's the one. [01:53:35] I apologize. [01:53:36] Wow. [01:53:39] And again, so what you're feeling, I do not want to minimize it. [01:53:44] I also don't want to miss it. [01:53:45] So this is what we're asking for, right? [01:53:47] When I say that we're bringing scenarios as conversation starters so that we can gauge that reaction. [01:53:53] This is the reaction we want to gauge. [01:53:55] Drop that in the survey so that we can make sure we are capturing it. [01:53:59] We are reacting to it to the best of our ability. [01:54:02] Yes, a question about the transfers and being that they're going to reverse transfers, [01:54:07] transfers to stay where they are now. [01:54:09] You mentioned it was mostly based on the public capacity, but is there any consideration to [01:54:14] kids with disabilities with potentially remaining at a school where there are... [01:54:20] I would say generally we're having the conversation kind of in the reverse. [01:54:29] So when we're talking about transfers, IEP, student accommodations, student needs are [01:54:34] absolutely a factor that are taken into consideration. [01:54:37] Usually it is looking at where I currently am, where I work. [01:54:39] Where I currently am, where I want to go. [01:54:41] Can my receiving school meet my need? [01:54:43] Right? [01:54:44] So that's usually the lens we're looking at that through. [01:54:46] I would say for these conversations, what's actually unique, right, is we're talking about [01:54:50] students with a parent facility. [01:54:52] And so honestly, if I married a student already being there, right, we've kind of checked [01:54:56] that initial box. [01:54:57] We're pretty confident the student's needs can be met in the school where they've already [01:55:00] been met. [01:55:01] And so as long as we're able to accommodate for that student remaining through the transfer [01:55:07] option, there would be no impediment. [01:55:09] If anything, there's more reason, right, to say yes. [01:55:11] So that would in no way shape or form... [01:55:13] Thank you guys. [01:55:20] I mean, I do want to say thank you all so much for giving your time to this. [01:55:23] I know that three nights in a row, and especially as emotions get higher, and we know that you [01:55:30] guys are filling in where you can and answering questions as you can. [01:55:35] And we hope that you give us grace as well in how the emotions feel on our side of it. [01:55:42] We were in a very tough position as well. [01:55:47] I do have two very... [01:55:48] I do make our two very good questions. [01:55:52] You talked about how the conversation, as a lot spirit, the conversation was not started [01:56:09] early. [01:56:10] And to the effect of it, I'm on the PTM, we were told... [01:56:18] It puts us in a really hard, like, trust space of a year ago, we were... [01:56:32] How do we not go through this again? [01:56:36] And that this is going to affect the Farragut school. [01:56:43] Not... [01:56:44] Not being done for us, and not affecting us. [01:56:47] To then find out two weeks ago. [01:56:49] So, was North Shore under fire beforehand? [01:56:53] Was lots... [01:56:54] I mean, is there something... [01:56:55] Great question. [01:56:56] So I would say, for Farragut as a community, if you have students at Farragut Primary, [01:57:00] if you have students at Farragut Intermediate, right? [01:57:02] We have known we would be having a rezoning conversation, really, since the new building [01:57:07] was approved, right? [01:57:08] That has been a part and parcel to that conversation. [01:57:11] We did not anticipate at that point. [01:57:12] We did not anticipate at that time, broadening this conversation. [01:57:17] And so, the broadening of the conversation, absolutely. [01:57:20] That's not only new to you all, it's new to the Farragut community, it's what we're processing [01:57:25] together. [01:57:26] And again, poor choice of words on my part, so I really want to reframe. [01:57:29] When I say starting the conversation early, what I mean is we're talking now about what [01:57:34] do we want to do. [01:57:36] Not locking into something that has to happen. [01:57:39] We are out here having this conversation. [01:57:41] To determine whether or not there is an amicable, very easy path forward. [01:57:47] We are brilliantly getting, you know, the fact that there is not, right? [01:57:51] We had a couple of things that we wondered, like, could this be advantageous to the community? [01:57:55] If we can ever find something that is advantageous to the community that creates opportunity. [01:58:00] If it is a hard conversation, we also really want to honor that. [01:58:07] And so, please, just kind of continue to be with us in this process. [01:58:12] Engage in this process. [01:58:14] Because what we do not want to do, right? [01:58:19] And that is part of the conversation that we're having, is let's start the conversation [01:58:23] now to determine, like, what feels now capable, what feels like a next step, right? [01:58:29] And that's what we're all figuring out together. [01:58:31] So, absolutely, really appreciate you asking that question. [01:58:33] Yeah, of course. [01:58:34] And I will speak on, I hope I can, is that it does feel very major to us because it kind [01:58:42] of feels like the rug has been pulled out from under us and that we were watching, like, [01:58:48] on the outside of the house, seeing everything going on in our neighboring areas and excited [01:58:55] for their future and excited for their growth, only to hear it might hurt us. [01:59:01] And that just came as a massive surprise to us, especially when the other individuals [01:59:06] were expecting it. [01:59:07] And we're like, yeah, we get it. [01:59:09] And we're like, whoa, we don't get it. [01:59:12] And then we'll have to start all over again. [01:59:14] So we're like, oh, we're not getting it. [01:59:15] We're just going to let it go. [01:59:19] We're just going to let it go. [01:59:20] And I think the other thing that really is, the other super, like, another quick question. [01:59:21] Okay. [01:59:22] Utilize scenario three. [01:59:23] It will take lots, effective fall of 2027, down to 67%, correct? [01:59:24] If, just as it's drawn… [01:59:25] As it's, yeah. [01:59:26] If, just as it's, yeah. [01:59:27] But then the three Farragut schools would immediately start at 80, correct? [01:59:28] A little bit over 80. [01:59:29] A little bit over 80. [01:59:30] Okay. [01:59:31] And my kiddo that's a third grader because, like, why is that? [01:59:32] I mean, I know that I don't know. [01:59:33] I know that I have kids that are in the third grade. [01:59:34] immediately start at 80, correct? [01:59:37] I'm a little bit over 80 at the age of three. [01:59:41] And my kiddo is a third grader because, like, [01:59:51] why do the Farragut schools get to have the 80%? [01:59:56] But my kiddo drops to 67 with the potential of losing [02:00:02] favorite teachers or losing favorite staff members [02:00:07] or not even to mention losing friends. [02:00:10] Like, we don't have to go there. [02:00:11] We all know that they're kids. [02:00:12] But, like, how is the conversation? [02:00:15] And I know that it's not fair to lots. [02:00:28] So how do we look like at 67%? [02:00:35] What will the other schools get to rise to that 80%? [02:00:39] And that's part of what we're keeping a pulse on, right? [02:00:42] So I don't want to say that it would not be disruptive. [02:00:44] It would not be a change. [02:00:45] And, again, that's what we're trying to log. [02:00:48] That's what we're trying to capture. [02:00:49] And I would say just to honor the Farragut families that spoke [02:00:52] last night. [02:00:53] They were saying, why are you taking me to 80%, right? [02:00:56] And so, I mean, you've got both sides of those equations that [02:00:59] you're balancing. [02:01:00] And that is what we're weighing right now and we're trying to [02:01:03] figure out because in both spaces, it's a change. [02:01:06] In both spaces, it's uncomfortable. [02:01:08] If we can, through the course of these conversations, [02:01:11] find a way that can either protract or alter or kind of move [02:01:16] some things around to bring those numbers closer to one another, [02:01:19] that's what we're looking for, right? [02:01:21] So I appreciate you asking the question. [02:01:22] And that's why we want to keep going back to you. [02:01:25] These scenarios are starting points, right? [02:01:27] And so please just continue to provide that feedback. [02:01:30] Make use of that survey. [02:01:32] Give us a chance to really spend some time with it, right? [02:01:39] Absolutely. [02:01:40] So I would say those open comment boxes, those are your comment boxes, right? [02:01:43] So if you see, so I would say for, I'm here with Watts, right? [02:01:58] Okay. [02:01:59] So I would say Watts, hop into scenario three. [02:02:01] Pick challenge or advantage. [02:02:03] There's a degree of categorization we knew we were going to have to do. [02:02:06] We try to keep the questions limited because people obviously, [02:02:09] they lose steam in surveys. [02:02:11] So fewer questions, greater response rate. [02:02:13] Put it in there and we'll categorize it appropriately. [02:02:16] Yeah.