[00:00:00] and please use q a however you see fit generally when we do this there's a desire to begin giving [00:00:07] feedback in q a we will happily hear that but still ask that you put into the survey [00:00:12] so that survey is where your feedback becomes actionable for q a what we would like to [00:00:17] prioritize are clarifying questions so if you've heard something that didn't quite make sense or [00:00:23] you're still missing pieces of the puzzle to be able to generate some feedback for us and make [00:00:28] a decision in your mind about what feels right that's how we really want to spend our time in [00:00:32] q a that's how we'd like to prioritize the microphones if you have a question we would [00:00:37] invite you to come down to one of the two mics we have one in the aisle here we have another [00:00:41] in the aisle here please just queue up and we will try to move it as efficiently through your [00:00:46] questions as possible all right this gentleman here i think is ready to go oh thank you thank [00:00:54] you for this thorough presentation for everyone here so we [00:00:58] just recently moved to the farragut area and our number one reason for farragut was the school [00:01:06] what how are you going to ensure that teaching the community the standards are maintained [00:01:19] phenomenal question and i will say this this gives me an opportunity to give a shout out to [00:01:23] our administrators in the room i think every single administrator for all of our inactive [00:01:28] schools may be here i won't make you stand up but we have incredible principles at each of these [00:01:36] schools and i would say that the experience any family is going to receive whether they're at [00:01:42] fair primary intermediate the new school north shore lots of burton valley is not only comparable [00:01:48] i think they're actively competing with one another and so you will have a very very competitive [00:01:52] environment regardless of where you go i just want to confirm that it's an area that lots of [00:02:02] families will still be going to west valley for middle school yes that is correct so no no question [00:02:09] about that i think it's going to be an area that lots of families will still be going to [00:02:14] and that's why i would really recommend looking at those implications like some of those will [00:02:18] create what we call theater pattern purity so they'll actually give families an opportunity [00:02:23] for students to spend a little bit more time with their peers uh they'll be moving in the [00:02:28] middle school with matriculating the high school with separate that purity um that's something [00:02:32] we're aware of as well so please zero in on those scenarios and how they impact you [00:02:48] because [00:02:49] being this close i think it's really pertinent [00:02:53] and my house specifically in two of the scenarios is the exact split of [00:03:01] and so to be honest [00:03:12] and then on the one and three it's my house and [00:03:19] third and it goes down vanbury but it's not split down midhurst or anything like that and [00:03:27] i was curious why instead of the southern area that like you said had a shore or under the train [00:03:38] underpass why they wouldn't go down north shore and continue to go down north shore [00:03:43] instead of having to go left and it was why it's split there because i actually bought the house [00:03:51] i grew up in and under your current zoning [00:03:54] friends or but we would have been split and so i know things have to happen but [00:04:05] it's one of the oldest neighborhoods in bergen and so to split up i'm sure a lot of you are here [00:04:13] to split up the king's gate would be pretty rough for a lot of the kids and i had a three-year-old [00:04:19] and a four-year-old they will be going to this school and the people across the street from us [00:04:25] that we've known since birk their kids as well [00:04:29] go to school with each other. And they play every day and every morning they'll have to go to school. [00:04:40] So I'll say a couple of things. First, the digital form, because we want to capture that. [00:04:47] The other thing I'll say is about sort of getting in the weeds of the methodology. [00:04:51] So the maps that you all saw, the maps that we generated, it comes out of our program that we use to forecast in moments. [00:04:58] So it is not, part of the reason that the maps are not as detailed as you get with something like Google Maps [00:05:05] is because that's not what this tool is for. This tool is for figuring out, like, how many kids are going to go to this school [00:05:11] if we draw the line here in five years. So there will be refinements to the zone lines based on the feedback that we get. [00:05:18] And our intention is to the greatest extent possible to try to keep neighborhoods together. [00:05:22] But when we're looking at scenarios like this, when we're looking at rezoning, at a certain point, you, you know, [00:05:29] this neighborhood has 50 kids in it. If we keep that neighborhood over here or move it over there, [00:05:34] all of a sudden there are 50 kids in it. [00:05:35] Our school is overcrowded. So there, there is a time when we have to sometimes make more difficult decisions. [00:05:41] But again, we're early enough in this process that, like, you know, again, put what you just said in the feedback, [00:05:48] put the specifics of the roads and those things like that, because that's something I'll be more than happy to look at [00:05:52] and be more than happy to make some adjustments where and how we can. [00:05:55] Yeah, and that's just why I wanted to bring it to your attention. [00:05:57] Yeah, absolutely. I appreciate that. [00:05:59] Because the, especially from the bus standpoint, like you said, the difference between [00:06:04] loading up, I think the neighborhood is two buses currently, but putting those, putting children in two buses [00:06:12] and driving them across the street rather than splitting them and making them go two separate ways [00:06:19] rather than a route that's south of the, I guess it would be the Chohto line under the railroad, [00:06:27] McPhee, south of McPhee there, under the underpass, everything south there would need to deviate [00:06:34] to the roundabout, like you said, anyway. [00:06:37] So they would go straight up Concord to the existing school. [00:06:43] So that's why that was, yeah. [00:06:45] I'll echo Ryan. So not only, will you just not only put your neighborhood in the survey, [00:06:50] but give us those short names. That would be very helpful as well. [00:06:54] And that's exactly the type of feedback we were looking for. So thank you for that. [00:06:58] I love efficiency. [00:07:00] Y'all done looking? [00:07:08] Absolutely. [00:07:09] I love this one. [00:07:10] Thank you. [00:07:11] This is the best time of year. [00:07:13] So I'll stop notes because I forget things. [00:07:15] So I think y'all can agree that there has been a decline in public school enrollment, [00:07:20] especially with the expansion of vouchers and the price of funding opportunities in Tennessee. [00:07:24] It's likely that's going to increase. [00:07:27] And so also that plus the uneven population growth across Knox County. [00:07:31] What exact data do y'all have to justify resuming students who are already under, [00:07:37] what was that? [00:07:38] We're operating capacity schools rather than prioritizing open private schools in majority existing communities. [00:07:49] I don't know if you've got anything that you'd like to add as well. [00:07:52] I will say that our rezoning conversations don't begin or end here. [00:07:56] And so we had a conversation very similar in Palladl last year, [00:08:03] and we will be having additional conversations moving into next semester. [00:08:07] We will also be having additional conversations moving into next school year, [00:08:10] because to your point, we see uneven student distribution, right? [00:08:13] In a perfect world, everyone would live on, you know, little parcels, [00:08:16] and every, you know, parcel would add up just perfectly to the capacity of the school that is most proximate to them. [00:08:21] We're human beings, and we don't function easily, right? [00:08:24] And so that's not always the case, but this is not the only place that we are looking. [00:08:29] Really what's giving us an opportunity in the why now part of this conversation [00:08:33] is that we do have the addition of those new seats, [00:08:36] and we are very, very cognizant of the pressure. [00:08:39] We are cognizant of the pressure being felt, not necessarily by folks in this room. [00:08:43] And I think that's the hard part of this conversation. [00:08:45] It's pressure that's being felt in the Hardin Valley area. [00:08:48] It's pressure that's being felt further down the Kingston Pike and the North Shore corridor. [00:08:53] And I think that's what makes this conversation harder, [00:08:56] is that we're not talking about my school and the needs it has. [00:08:59] We're talking about how my school might be affected because there are needs in other spaces. [00:09:03] And we recognize that. [00:09:05] There's no real way to take a systemic approach to addressing those concerns [00:09:09] without having some of those conversations. [00:09:12] But it's also why we're having the conversation right now, [00:09:15] because if we can land on a solution that is more protracted [00:09:18] and is therefore more comfortable, we want to do that. [00:09:22] We would hate to wait three, four, five years out, [00:09:25] bank on enrollment patterns changing, and then be wrong, [00:09:29] because that's a much more uncomfortable conversation. [00:09:32] And so that's kind of the why for right now. [00:09:34] I can definitely tell you, like, I grew up here. [00:09:36] I moved to Texas and lived in Houston. [00:09:39] The private school voucher expansion fundamentally changed public schools. [00:09:43] And for five million words, that's not a good public school. [00:09:46] I'm going through my major, right? [00:09:48] It doesn't mean public schools. [00:09:50] There were great public schools in the area. [00:09:52] We appreciate that. [00:09:53] And what I will say is that part of why I think we're holding on to our enrollment projections [00:09:58] is that we're going to be as competitive as possible, [00:10:00] and we're going to fight for our families that we have. [00:10:02] And we would like families to continue to choose KCS. [00:10:04] Thank you. [00:10:05] Thank you. [00:10:11] With all these different scenarios and potential impacts, [00:10:13] as we get ready to provide our feedback, [00:10:16] and we obviously as residents have less insight into the process than you guys have, [00:10:21] so are all these three scenarios equally plausible and equally weighted in your minds? [00:10:28] And as we give feedback, is anything possible depending on the feedback? [00:10:33] Or is there a pre-scenario conceived which is the most beneficial in your mind? [00:10:40] Phenomenal question. [00:10:41] I will say, having seen a version of this, [00:10:42] a few times already, [00:10:44] we have yet to make a proposal to the board that looks exactly like the scenario we talked about with the community. [00:10:50] And so I think some version of something that's on the screen is absolutely going to be recommended to the board. [00:10:57] I think it is significantly more likely that you see combinations and compromises among those three scenarios [00:11:05] result in the final proposal that we make. [00:11:08] So I don't think right now any one of those scenarios [00:11:11] just as it is, [00:11:13] is going to result in the proposal. [00:11:15] But I do think you're looking at versions. [00:11:18] I know that you're looking at versions of the way we could potentially draw those lines [00:11:22] to generate the relief we need. [00:11:24] And so some version of that will appear in the final proposal. [00:11:27] Did that answer your question? [00:11:28] Yeah. [00:11:29] Okay, great. Thank you. [00:11:30] That was a good question. [00:11:32] Yes, I've got a question related to enrollment projections for Faraday Intermediate and Faraday Primary. [00:11:39] You had mentioned that the portables would all be eliminated, [00:11:42] which is what we were all hoping for at the beginning. [00:11:45] I hear you, sir. [00:11:46] Yeah, and I just wanted to make sure I heard that correctly [00:11:48] and also just follow up with looking at some of the enrollment projection numbers y'all provided [00:11:53] relative to what was provided three years ago for building capacity for those schools. [00:11:58] It looks like those numbers would be at or above capacity for what was shared with us three years ago. [00:12:03] And so I wasn't sure how that was going to be accomplished without eliminating portables, [00:12:07] or are the numbers going to be limited? [00:12:08] Or are the numbers a little bit different from what we expected? [00:12:12] I'm going to take a stab at that answer, but I think you also may have lost me somewhere along the way, [00:12:16] so I seem to go in a different direction. [00:12:18] Stop me and tell me I'm not answering the question that you asked. [00:12:20] So one thing that I will say, and once you want to jump in, I saw you step forward. [00:12:24] Okay. [00:12:25] I just noticed that you stepped forward. [00:12:28] So I'll say two things. [00:12:29] One, we spent all of last year overhauling our programmatic capacity formula for schools. [00:12:36] So there were a couple things true. [00:12:38] There were a couple things true about our prior capacity formulas. [00:12:40] One, they were based on footprints of the building that in a lot of spaces no longer existed. [00:12:45] So we had, over time, put in walls that didn't previously exist, [00:12:49] take down walls that previously existed. [00:12:51] And so Mr. Shover had the privilege of walking through every single one of our schools [00:12:56] and making sure that the footprint we were assessing from a programmatic capacity standpoint was accurate. [00:13:02] And then there was also an application to that formula. [00:13:06] So I'm going to repeat. [00:13:07] The application to that formula, too, are staffing formulas. [00:13:10] And so previously we had essentially looked at, you know, how many students can fit in this building [00:13:15] and not necessarily apply the lens of, you know, what does it mean to educate students in that space, right? [00:13:20] How do we need to use those spaces? [00:13:22] How many of those can functionally be classrooms? [00:13:24] And then how many of those can functionally be classrooms under the staffing formula and the leverage? [00:13:28] So there's some mathematic limitations that I would say are very different in the formula that we're using as of last year forward. [00:13:35] And so we're reflective of the actual utility of the facilities and what we're getting out of those facilities. [00:13:40] If the question is about capacity shifting, I would say that's the answer, and that's what's going on there. [00:13:45] Are you saying there was, like, actually a building? [00:13:48] When we were considering what type of school to build there, numbers were shaped, for example, [00:13:53] like for Barrett Intermediate, that it had a capacity of a certain amount. [00:13:57] It took the portables out and said that it kept the capacity of, like, maybe 570 students. [00:14:03] Yes. [00:14:04] So the new projections look like they exceed that already. [00:14:07] So we're not sure if that was a different change in the formula of how you determine how many students would fit there. [00:14:13] And ultimately what I'm hoping to see is that these, the Faraday Intermediate and Faraday Primary, [00:14:18] and all the schools, you know, are not going to be already at 100 percent or more than 100 percent capacity [00:14:24] when we choose a solution here. [00:14:26] Okay, sorry, I think I'm caught up. [00:14:28] So what I will say is the capacity that you see reflected on the board here, [00:14:32] this is total brick-and-mortar capacity, so none of these include portables. [00:14:37] That's true for any label that says Faraday Primary or Faraday Intermediate. [00:14:41] That's assuming the elimination of the portables. [00:14:43] So the capacity that's reflected there is for those schools. [00:14:46] The other thing that's going on mathematically with those two schools is the change in the student population. [00:14:52] So you probably saw for, and definitely saw for Faraday Primary, a lower capacity because it's a K-2 school. [00:15:00] So K-2 classrooms just have a lower capacity. [00:15:01] K-2 classrooms just have a lower student-to-teacher ratio. [00:15:04] K-3 classrooms have a higher student-to-teacher ratio. [00:15:07] So you also probably saw a higher programmatic capacity for Faraday Intermediate. [00:15:12] What you see here is equal parts new formula, loss of the portables, [00:15:17] but also an assessment of what the programmatic capacity of those facilities will be when they're K-5. [00:15:24] So we then are assuming that there's a fairly equal distribution of K for two students [00:15:29] as there is for K-5 students. [00:15:31] So that's going to change each of the building-length capacities for prior, [00:15:35] and really any of the prior primary schools want to increase, [00:15:40] want to decrease in those related audiences. [00:15:42] Yeah. [00:15:43] Okay. [00:15:44] I think just knowing that the portables will be gone is a good idea. [00:15:46] The portables will definitely be gone. [00:15:47] Yes. [00:15:48] Thank you all for the presentation. [00:15:56] Scenario one, and you mentioned lose all the portables. [00:16:03] I think the projection was around 84% capacity. [00:16:06] So what number would lose? [00:16:08] I mean, because I do think, as you all mentioned, it's unacceptable, I think, [00:16:19] and not just going to have portables. [00:16:21] It's about building the school. [00:16:23] And so it seems like scenario one. [00:16:25] This is the capacity only in the bricks and mortar part of the school. [00:16:41] So the answer to your question, like what percentage needs to be gone for it to be [00:16:46] for everybody to fit into the physical school building, [00:16:49] it's what we need to get below the capacity number, [00:16:52] like the capacity number that's listed over here. [00:16:54] So 860, I just thought you said that it's not going to be. [00:17:04] It's less than the programmatic capacity that's on this screen. [00:17:09] So could we, at that point, push all of our Cardin Valley elementary students into the building? [00:17:16] Yes. [00:17:17] Yes, we could. [00:17:18] Would it be comfortable? [00:17:19] Probably not. [00:17:20] And so that's the reason when we're talking about that long-range planning, [00:17:24] when we talk about the 80% threshold, [00:17:26] that's part of why we talked about the 80% threshold. [00:17:28] Essentially what you see in schools is, you know, once you hit that point where, [00:17:33] wow, I'm on the cusp and I probably can stop using my portable space, [00:17:37] if you've not seen that stability for a few years, [00:17:40] you're going to move a lot of teachers around just for another neighborhood to potentially be built [00:17:45] and have teachers moving right back out to portables. [00:17:48] And so when we say we would not have eliminated the need for portables, [00:17:52] some of that is just knowing what's coming in the Hardin Valley area [00:17:55] and knowing that this amount of relief, [00:17:57] while it technically gets you under that threshold, [00:18:00] we do not want to over-promise that we would then be walking away from portables. [00:18:04] We would not be demolishing portables on that site because, in good faith, [00:18:08] we anticipate potentially meeting them based on the developments that are coming in. [00:18:12] So that's essentially what's happening there. [00:18:14] That was completely misunderstanding of your question. [00:18:17] I apologize. [00:18:18] If you look at the capacity numbers, in 2027 we would be under, [00:18:22] but in 2030 we're back over. [00:18:24] So it's like we would be – [00:18:27] we could not use portables for two years. [00:18:30] So with that kind of time horizon and that kind of scenario, [00:18:34] I would not advise us to remove those portables [00:18:36] because we're just going to pay them more money to put them right back in. [00:18:39] Is it – just one more thing. [00:18:41] Is it realistic – you mentioned tight time. [00:18:43] So is it realistic for everybody to send all these comments in? [00:18:50] And as you stated, maybe one of these three scenarios isn't even the one that's picked [00:18:54] when it's really approximately three business days [00:18:57] to get all this information aggregated for you all to look at [00:19:00] to then just cycle through it. [00:19:02] And it seems like – [00:19:03] So I would say that's where the digital format is very helpful to us. [00:19:10] So in the past, you know, we've done sticky notes. [00:19:12] Sticky notes take a long time to read. [00:19:13] They take a long time to decipher. [00:19:15] And sometimes, you know, handwriting is a little bit easier to parse with than others. [00:19:19] So that digital format is going to make that easier for us. [00:19:22] The survey, when you get into it, what it's also – [00:19:25] what you'll see is that it's community-specific. [00:19:27] And so that will allow us to start working [00:19:29] through those permutations on a community-by-community lens. [00:19:33] The software that Mr. Gillingham alluded to earlier, [00:19:37] really that planning software already is actively projecting [00:19:41] the number of students on each parcel. [00:19:44] And so the actual permutating from parcel to parcel to parcel, [00:19:47] that part's not hard. [00:19:49] The hardest part of this process is done just by merit generating these scenarios. [00:19:54] As you move lines at that point, you're essentially tipping over or under. [00:19:58] And it is relatively quick at this juncture. [00:20:01] And this is essentially how we've probably timed, I would say, [00:20:04] every single decision we've done like this the past three or four years. [00:20:08] That's always the rapid part because for us that moves very quickly. [00:20:12] Getting it to this point and getting it to accuracy is the thing that takes us a long time. [00:20:18] I think it's a very good question. [00:20:20] Thank you, by the way. [00:20:31] And I apologize for my questions. [00:20:33] I'm not the smartest man in the world. [00:20:35] And if my numbers are accurate, [00:20:36] I've only had ten minutes to look at these. [00:20:40] We didn't have the opportunity to look at these ahead of the meeting, [00:20:42] so I apologize. [00:20:45] So at the beginning, I think, Corey, [00:20:49] you mentioned that North Shore Elementary area is the most mature growth. [00:20:55] And it doesn't have a lot more room for growth. [00:20:57] I think that's how you put it. [00:20:59] In fact, that's consistent with what I've heard from people in the community. [00:21:02] I'm a real estate professional. [00:21:03] I'm not good at it. [00:21:04] But it also doesn't add value from my experience as well. [00:21:07] But that's at the lowest. [00:21:09] I think it does add room for growth of the areas we're talking about, [00:21:12] especially when you compare it to where the new school is in Hardin Valley. [00:21:15] I would put Kingston Pike one room beyond that. [00:21:18] I would say Kingston Pike is more congested than the North Shore Drive area. [00:21:23] Okay. [00:21:24] And also, I hear 80% is this number that starts to get concerning. [00:21:30] And I guess my question is, [00:21:32] if you look at the scenario two and three in particular, [00:21:34] it leaves North Shore Elementary School [00:21:37] with 450 and 460 empty spaces. [00:21:42] And we're talking about 50%, mid-50s and mid-60% as far as capacity. [00:21:48] Meanwhile, that same scenario puts the new school at 88% capacity. [00:21:54] And I guess I'm curious why you would move kids out of a school [00:21:58] that you guys have said has a very low opportunity for growth [00:22:03] and leave it at a 50% to 60% capacity [00:22:06] when the new school is sitting in an area [00:22:09] that has by far the most opportunity for growth. [00:22:13] And I've heard of that area. [00:22:15] But the last thing I'm going to say, I can't. [00:22:17] But in Hardin Valley, it's still in these highs. [00:22:21] When you can actually take the kids from ALI [00:22:24] that you have in this proposal, [00:22:26] move them into North Shore, [00:22:28] and actually get a lower capacity [00:22:31] than you have proposed for the new school [00:22:34] in scenario two and three. [00:22:36] So my question is why, [00:22:40] why would you dislocate all these kids from North Shore? [00:22:44] Anybody here from North Shore? [00:22:48] Best school in Oslo. [00:22:50] No offense to everybody else. [00:22:52] Not sure why you missed it. [00:22:54] But why? [00:22:56] And then you reduce the opportunity for this new school [00:22:59] to take on this growth. [00:23:01] That it's going to happen. [00:23:03] I mean, there's not a square foot of land [00:23:05] if somebody doesn't want to build a house. [00:23:07] So my question is why would even two and three be, [00:23:09] a scenario that would be considered? [00:23:11] And conversely, it seems like there's a scenario [00:23:14] that's best fit for this [00:23:16] that isn't even up on the board. [00:23:18] So I think it's a phenomenal question. [00:23:20] I'm going to ask Justin, [00:23:21] will you take me back to the West sector, [00:23:24] like slide two, three, at the beginning? [00:23:26] While he's tapping us through these, [00:23:29] what I will say is that you've landed on the rough point. [00:23:32] Right? [00:23:33] And I would say for scenario three in particular, [00:23:36] the fact that the new school [00:23:38] and one of the other Farragut area schools [00:23:41] would be taken over that 80% threshold for doors open, [00:23:45] we don't like that. [00:23:47] That's not ideal. [00:23:48] We don't want to do that. [00:23:50] And so that is an implication that we're labeling, [00:23:53] not as a positive in that scenario, [00:23:56] as something that we don't feel great about. [00:23:58] That being said, the reason that scenario made it to the board [00:24:01] is that the schools at that point [00:24:04] and the boundary lines in scenario three [00:24:08] that we're talking about, [00:24:09] Justin, we keep going back to, [00:24:11] just go all the way back to slide like two. [00:24:14] So while he's getting there, [00:24:15] I will say that in scenario three, [00:24:18] the one that we're talking about, [00:24:21] the growth for the new school [00:24:24] and the school that, [00:24:26] it's either Farragut intermediate or Farragut primary [00:24:28] that would be taken over that 80% threshold, [00:24:31] that would be growth in the Farragut area [00:24:33] that they would be experiencing, [00:24:34] not in the Hardin Valley area. [00:24:36] So Hardin Valley is absolutely, [00:24:38] still growing. [00:24:39] That would still be a focus of concern for us. [00:24:42] I think the challenge we're labeling is very honestly, [00:24:45] as far as Hardin Valley is concerned, [00:24:47] is that right now, [00:24:48] no amount of pulling out of the Hardin Valley community [00:24:51] into Farragut is going to prevent a probable conversation [00:24:55] about the need for a new school in Hardin Valley. [00:24:57] There's so much developable land in Hardin Valley [00:25:01] that while we may generate [00:25:03] some of that immediate relief in this move, [00:25:05] and that buys us time. [00:25:06] Time is helpful. [00:25:07] And so that's, [00:25:08] that's scenario one that we're talking about. [00:25:10] We're buying some time with scenario one. [00:25:12] More than likely, [00:25:13] Hardin Valley will require a brick and mortar solution [00:25:17] because there's so much developable land out there. [00:25:20] That's the downside on scenario one. [00:25:22] The scenario you're talking about, [00:25:23] scenario three, [00:25:25] really this is the map that is kind of the salient point here. [00:25:29] So, and this is that challenge I mentioned just a moment ago, [00:25:32] which is that we're having a conversation about a school [00:25:36] because there's a ripple effect [00:25:38] that it could potentially generate for us. [00:25:41] So scenario three, [00:25:42] yes, it will take some of our Farragut area schools [00:25:45] over that 80% threshold. [00:25:47] But Farragut as a community is also pretty built out. [00:25:51] Is there still room to develop? [00:25:52] Yes, absolutely. [00:25:53] Is there as much room to develop in the Farragut area [00:25:56] as there is in the Hardin Valley area? [00:25:57] No, there's just not. [00:25:59] So that's a reality that we're grappling with. [00:26:02] But again, it's something that we're labeling as a discomfort. [00:26:04] What it does for us, [00:26:05] if you look at this map, [00:26:07] is it does take the utilization of North Shore Elementary School down [00:26:12] exactly the way that you described. [00:26:14] Taking that utilization rate down, [00:26:17] generating approximately 400 additional seats essentially [00:26:21] at North Shore Elementary School [00:26:23] lets us then have a conversation about a domino effect [00:26:27] down Kingston Pike and down North Shore Drive. [00:26:31] So that's not just empty seats. [00:26:34] We need a domino effect from there. [00:26:36] A domino effect. [00:26:37] So if you look, [00:26:38] so Sequoia right here at that 80% threshold, [00:26:40] 100 kids over. [00:26:41] I'm going to just keep moving west. [00:26:43] So you're going to take Sequoia kids and put them in North Shore? [00:26:45] Do what? [00:26:46] Or just move them all down? [00:26:47] So walk with me, literally, permanently. [00:26:49] Sequoia, 100 kids over. [00:26:51] I'm going to keep moving. [00:26:52] Bearden, 19, not that big of an issue. [00:26:54] West Hills, 90, that's an issue. [00:26:56] Rocky Hill, 167, that's an issue. [00:27:00] AL Lots, 41, don't feel great about that. [00:27:03] Bluegrass, 2, that's probably a non-issue. [00:27:06] Then we hit the 100. [00:27:07] We've got 100 available seats right now at North Shore. [00:27:10] That 100 available seats can't absorb all of that. [00:27:14] We pull a portion of North Shore up [00:27:17] and we create enough capacity at North Shore [00:27:19] that we can start moving down. [00:27:22] That's probably one of the only relief valves we can exercise [00:27:25] for the Kingston Pike-North Shore quarter. [00:27:28] That's depleting. [00:27:30] How many available seats in North Shore? [00:27:32] Right now, at the 80% threshold, 109. [00:27:35] How does that compete with the numbers here that show 400? [00:27:43] I think you're right. [00:27:44] So these numbers here, this is 100% capacity. [00:27:49] This is just the capacity. [00:27:51] No, it's current enrollment versus capacity shows. [00:27:55] Again, I'm not going to numbers that show 400. [00:27:58] For today, you mean? [00:28:00] This scenario three. [00:28:01] Am I not reading this right? [00:28:03] Capacity, 1348. [00:28:05] Current enrollment, 969. [00:28:07] The capacity we were looking at is the total programmatic capacity, [00:28:10] not the 80% capacity. [00:28:12] Okay. [00:28:13] So that's 100 available spots. [00:28:15] So if you take 80% of 1348, [00:28:18] that gives you the programmatic, like, [00:28:20] our target for the programmatic capacity. [00:28:22] And that's 100, the difference between... [00:28:24] Exactly right. [00:28:25] Okay. [00:28:26] Oh. [00:28:37] This is... [00:28:38] So you'd rezone every school. [00:28:40] You're talking about rezoning every school district [00:28:42] to triple down into North Shore of what you tried to do. [00:28:44] Yeah. [00:28:45] So we would say if we went with a version, [00:28:47] something like scenario three that created enough capacity [00:28:50] somewhere along that corridor, [00:28:53] we would plan to use that relief. [00:28:56] So that's a big... [00:28:59] When I say it's a big ripple effect, [00:29:01] I mean it's a big ripple effect. [00:29:02] But if you look at these schools, [00:29:03] and part of why we called out, [00:29:05] there's really just not available land there. [00:29:07] It wasn't to say there's not available land there, [00:29:09] we don't anticipate there being kids. [00:29:11] It's to say there's not available land there, [00:29:13] we don't anticipate building a school. [00:29:15] And so that's the reality of what we're looking at as a district. [00:29:19] And that's why we're having this conversation. [00:29:22] Okay. [00:29:23] Thank you. [00:29:33] Some of my concerns and questions kind of on the head [00:29:35] in answering the last two questions. [00:29:37] A, why are we not talking about a new school in Hardin Valley? [00:29:42] Yes. [00:29:43] There you go. [00:29:44] In scenario one, [00:29:47] one of the most densely building areas, [00:29:51] there's a lot of new buildings that are coming in. [00:29:57] It's a new area that needs to be renovated. [00:30:02] And so is there a way to actually get the new buildings [00:30:06] into a new school? [00:30:08] You've talked about using this formula for projecting, [00:30:10] you know, parcel to parcel, the students coming in. [00:30:13] Are you actually accounting for the new building [00:30:15] that's happening? [00:30:16] Because I don't know that we are. [00:30:18] We've got high density housing being built on Everett, [00:30:21] or long-term for the students that were pulling in [00:30:25] from Hardin Valley, are we just gonna have to build [00:30:27] a new school and rezone again? [00:30:30] So now we're gonna be moving, you know, [00:30:32] two or three times, these young kids. [00:30:36] I've got an incoming kindergartner. [00:30:38] Like, this is very long-term for me. [00:30:40] And I would say that if I could have had [00:30:42] the previous gentleman stay, these two holes are really, [00:30:46] when I say we're standing between two difficult decisions, [00:30:49] it's this, right? [00:30:50] So I would say the downside to scenario one, [00:30:53] we are very likely moving families [00:30:56] if we go with a version of scenario one, [00:30:58] or if we go with this build from Hardin Valley [00:31:02] into the Farragut area in scenario two, [00:31:04] either of those two options, right? [00:31:06] We're disrupting feeder patterns in Hardin Valley, [00:31:08] we're disrupting continuity in Hardin Valley, [00:31:10] knowing that it's probably not enough for the future. [00:31:13] That is the reality of what we're hearing. [00:31:15] Again, it lies as time, and time is of the essence [00:31:18] when we think about the fact that [00:31:20] this school alone costs $44 million, [00:31:23] and that cost is something that we have [00:31:24] to be cognizant of, right? [00:31:26] So time gives us, generally, more time [00:31:29] to raise those dollars, potentially. [00:31:31] I would say to find another solution, [00:31:33] but I honestly don't think there is another one [00:31:34] in Hardin Valley, right? [00:31:35] You do have that development going in at a rapid pace, [00:31:39] and the reality of our schools is the reality of our schools. [00:31:42] That's the consternation when scenario one [00:31:44] and that half of scenario two. [00:31:46] Then we see the other side, right? [00:31:48] When we move over and we start talking about, you know, [00:31:49] okay, we've heard in Valley, [00:31:52] and that consternation is still there. [00:31:53] We know we still have a very real need [00:31:55] to address that problem, [00:31:57] but we wouldn't have created the disruption [00:31:58] that we create right now, [00:32:00] knowing that it's not a long-term solution. [00:32:02] So we're gonna hold onto that, and we move over here. [00:32:05] We have a conversation about, okay, [00:32:06] well, what if we create relief, [00:32:09] and we can address a problem over here? [00:32:11] Because addressing a problem over here means [00:32:14] that we aren't carrying two potential capital solutions [00:32:17] in two different places, [00:32:18] but we do that, and we're affecting [00:32:20] an entire school community, North Shore Elementary School, [00:32:23] that really isn't over capacity, right? [00:32:26] This isn't necessarily or inherently [00:32:28] a North Shore Elementary School conversation. [00:32:30] North Shore Elementary School just geographically [00:32:33] is essentially a linchpin to another solution, [00:32:36] and so that's the balancing act that we're talking about. [00:32:40] That is also very disruptive to a community. [00:32:42] It does give us a long-term solution, [00:32:44] but neither of those are easy, [00:32:47] and that's what we're recognizing. [00:32:48] We're recognizing that it's what we want to hear, [00:32:51] what those road points are, [00:32:52] so we can determine how to try to make, [00:32:55] what is, at the end of the day, [00:32:56] going to be a difficult conversation [00:32:58] no matter what we land on, [00:32:59] a little bit more comfortable, if at all possible. [00:33:01] So yeah, same thing for higher ed. [00:33:03] Yeah, and I guess the real crux of the question is, [00:33:08] are these numbers actually considering the new road [00:33:11] that has been approved in zoning, [00:33:14] but is not yet broken ground? [00:33:17] I mean, we've got, like I said, [00:33:18] hundreds of new apartments on our road alone, [00:33:23] hundreds of new units going in in multiple locations [00:33:27] that would be a new zone along with [00:33:30] these new-built communities, [00:33:31] and so again, just thinking even maybe immediate short-term, [00:33:36] if we've got thousands of new families [00:33:39] that are in that blue area of scenario one, [00:33:43] do we then have a two-year gap where now I'm in second grade [00:33:48] and I'm funneling back into overgrown and carpeted out? [00:33:55] At the risk of getting too nerdy and too in the weeds, [00:33:57] the short answer to your question is yes. [00:33:59] We get a, we work very closely [00:34:01] with the Knox County Municipal Planning Office, [00:34:03] which approves all applications for construction, [00:34:08] at least at the level that we're talking about. [00:34:10] And so they give us a monthly notifier of, [00:34:13] you have new construction in this area, [00:34:15] we're expecting the student yield speed this. [00:34:18] So we use a nationally recognized, [00:34:20] very nice software called School Site Pro [00:34:22] to do our enrollment projections. [00:34:25] It pulls in historical data from our area, [00:34:28] breaks Knox County down into 1,200 different study areas, [00:34:32] and looks at the historical growth data [00:34:36] and demographic data, birth rates, [00:34:38] those sorts of things from each one of those study areas, [00:34:40] compares it to national trends and like markets [00:34:43] to arrive at like, it's still a, [00:34:45] like again, my crystal ball is not perfect, [00:34:48] but it is, it's meant to be a, [00:34:50] as educated a guess as we can possibly get. [00:34:52] So then we take those 1,200 different study areas, [00:34:55] project on them and stitch it back together. [00:34:58] And each one of the study areas fits inside school zones. [00:35:01] So we can say like, [00:35:02] give me all of what Faraday is gonna look like, [00:35:04] or all of what Powell is gonna look like. [00:35:07] And so it's updated monthly, [00:35:09] and then we do a once a year annual sort of like, [00:35:12] overhaul of everything and say, [00:35:14] okay, are there things that the monthly stuff didn't catch? [00:35:17] We wanna make sure that we're getting everything. [00:35:19] And so like, am I gonna tell you it's perfect or not? [00:35:21] But it is a thoughtful, considered, deliberate process [00:35:26] based on as much science, I guess, [00:35:30] for lack of a better term, as we can get. [00:35:32] So, you know, we're trying to make informed decisions [00:35:35] at the end of the day. [00:35:45] I'll echo the gentleman before me, [00:35:47] as well as the guy down there. [00:35:49] I just, up to school in a short minutes, [00:35:54] look, just kind of help me understand a little bit [00:35:58] the scenario situations here, [00:35:59] kind of going back to Justin, [00:36:01] if you wanna go back to slide two. [00:36:03] But if you go back to the slide, [00:36:07] we've got the arrows pointing, [00:36:09] and I certainly appreciate the leaky bow. [00:36:11] And there we go, Justin, you're the man, [00:36:13] I'll do that, let's take Justin around, [00:36:14] and he'll cross, and then he's gonna . [00:36:19] So I certainly understand and appreciate it. [00:36:22] What I'm kind of confused is that there's not [00:36:24] a single scenario that addresses [00:36:27] Hardin Valley issues and chaos. [00:36:30] And that doesn't make any sense to me. [00:36:32] Because we're standing here, we're looking at that, [00:36:34] we're looking at the plus 120, we're looking at the plus 40, [00:36:36] we're looking at the plus 41. [00:36:38] And we only have scenarios that address one or the other. [00:36:41] And scenario two just doesn't make any sense to me, period. [00:36:44] So I'll just kind of wipe that off the map. [00:36:46] One and three, it's almost like one and three, [00:36:49] we don't have one that can provide, [00:36:54] maybe not maximum relief, but some relief to both. [00:36:58] But then also considering the preservation, [00:37:00] as the gentleman that was here before me, [00:37:03] the preservation of North Shore kind of as is, [00:37:05] with the capacity that it's got, [00:37:06] because just looking at the numbers [00:37:08] and dumping this spreadsheet into my friend, Mr. GPT, [00:37:13] you just look at some of these things, [00:37:15] and scenario two, Farragut schools are over 80% by 2030. [00:37:20] Scenario three, Farragut schools are over 85% by 2030. [00:37:25] And I love Knox County schools, I love you guys, [00:37:29] but I don't think we're accounting for the amount of growth [00:37:32] that we've got. [00:37:33] We still have big, beautiful apartments [00:37:35] that are at half capacity. [00:37:36] If not less than that, and more being built, [00:37:39] like people are coming, [00:37:40] and they're not going to stop coming. [00:37:42] And I think these numbers are grossly underestimated. [00:37:45] And I think maybe we crawl before we walk in this scenario, [00:37:49] kind of give a little bit of relief to Hart Valley, [00:37:51] a little bit of relief to AL Lots, [00:37:53] to kind of keep everybody happy, [00:37:54] and keep North Shore, North Shore. [00:37:56] And also, by the way, [00:37:57] don't decimate North Shore to 66% respectively by 2030, [00:38:02] because there is no projection in any of these numbers, [00:38:05] of that leakage. [00:38:06] And so I think we're going to have to reach over [00:38:08] from the other schools, [00:38:09] and what that rezoning across those five schools [00:38:11] might look like, [00:38:12] and how those folks might feel about it. [00:38:13] That's right. [00:38:14] Thank you. [00:38:15] Thank you. [00:38:16] Thank you. [00:38:17] Thank you. [00:38:18] Thank you. [00:38:19] Thank you. [00:38:20] Thank you. [00:38:21] Thank you. [00:38:22] Thank you. [00:38:23] Thank you. [00:38:24] Thank you. [00:38:25] Thank you. [00:38:26] Thank you. [00:38:27] Thank you. [00:38:28] Thank you. [00:38:29] Thank you. [00:38:30] Let's just stay on that slide. [00:38:31] So I will say a couple of things. [00:38:32] Scenario three does eliminate the need for portables, [00:38:33] plus my children. [00:38:34] I'm talking to the audience. [00:38:35] Oh, there you are. [00:38:36] Scenario three does eliminate the need for portables at AL lots. [00:38:42] So scenario three is addressing lots, [00:38:45] but to your point, not Hardin Valley. [00:38:46] So I want to call that out, [00:38:47] but I realize that's only half of the equation, right? [00:38:52] I also want to be very, very honest that, [00:38:55] for two reasons, actually, [00:38:57] with scenario three, [00:38:58] or scenario two, [00:38:59] where North Shore is concerned, [00:39:01] that 2030 projection is the only projection we can generate, [00:39:06] based on what we've seen, [00:39:06] based on this scenario. [00:39:08] Because to your point, [00:39:09] we haven't had the secondary and tertiary conversations [00:39:12] about what that domino effect would look like [00:39:16] if we were to be able to make that pull [00:39:19] down Kingston Pike, down North Shore. [00:39:22] We have no intention of leaving North Shore Elementary School [00:39:27] that empty for that duration of time. [00:39:30] So if we locked into a scenario [00:39:33] in which we were able to generate capacity at North Shore, [00:39:36] Elementary School, [00:39:38] we would be turning around [00:39:39] and having a broader West Knoxville conversation [00:39:41] immediately thereafter. [00:39:42] Now, the reason that we're not doing this all at once [00:39:45] is for two reasons, actually. [00:39:47] One, and I'm going to kind of explain this [00:39:49] to a couple of folks that have asked already, [00:39:51] the best way, honestly, to explain it in my mind, [00:39:54] I'm a visual thinker, [00:39:55] is, you know, that Cracker Barrel game [00:39:57] where you move the pegs. [00:39:59] We have to move a peg first, essentially. [00:40:02] So we've got to know what peg we're moving [00:40:04] and what capacity we're creating. [00:40:05] So we have to move a peg first, essentially. [00:40:06] So we have to know what peg we're creating [00:40:07] before we can have that secondary conversation [00:40:09] about how we're making use of it. [00:40:11] So that would be coming [00:40:12] if we wound up locking into a scenario like this. [00:40:15] We would plan to make use of that facility. [00:40:18] The other caveat that I would give, [00:40:20] and this is the reason, again, [00:40:22] we want to have conversations early, [00:40:24] is that the other way we would be making use of that facility [00:40:27] is potentially through a very generous transfer offer. [00:40:30] So what we would be in a position to do today [00:40:34] that we could not potentially do, [00:40:35] three years from now, [00:40:36] four years from now, [00:40:37] five years from now, [00:40:38] is talk about a multi-grade, [00:40:41] automatically approved transfer [00:40:43] for existing families. [00:40:45] So that is another reason [00:40:48] why that held capacity at North Shore, [00:40:51] honestly, at AL Lots, [00:40:53] is critically important. [00:40:55] Now, Hardin Valley is a little different [00:40:56] in that, yes, we would want to be able to offer [00:40:59] something similar to Hardin Valley. [00:41:01] They're already so capacity constrained, [00:41:03] we don't think we could be that generous. [00:41:04] At Hardin Valley, we're going to try, [00:41:06] potentially, [00:41:07] if that's the scenario we wind up walking into. [00:41:09] But North Shore and Lots just have more space right now [00:41:12] for us to work with. [00:41:13] So if the consternation is, [00:41:15] and this is what we're trying to figure out, [00:41:17] what makes sense for the community, [00:41:19] figure out what makes sense for the community at large, [00:41:21] whichever that is, [00:41:22] it's a permutation of what we've talked about, [00:41:24] whatever that is, [00:41:25] that's a decision we need to walk in on. [00:41:27] Then we need to figure out, [00:41:28] well, how do we make it feel right [00:41:30] for the families that are enrolled in these schools today? [00:41:33] And one of the only other opportunities [00:41:35] that we have to offer to that equation [00:41:37] is a transfer opportunity. [00:41:39] And that could give us some continuity [00:41:41] and help us potentially slow walk a domino effect. [00:41:44] If we do walk into something here, [00:41:46] we could slower that, [00:41:48] we could slow that drain, essentially, right, [00:41:51] that drip, [00:41:52] if it meant honoring our existing families [00:41:54] through a longer transfer. [00:41:56] And so that's really what we're trying to figure out [00:41:58] is what matters most in this conversation. [00:42:01] So we appreciate you sharing that. [00:42:02] And encourage everyone to share, you know, [00:42:05] similar or very different opinions, [00:42:08] however they pertain to you in the survey. [00:42:11] But I hope that helps. [00:42:12] I'm not fancy enough to have GPT, [00:42:18] so I'm just calculating. [00:42:20] So, scenario two. [00:42:22] If we had, [00:42:25] so the new school would be at 80% capacity, [00:42:29] North Shore would be at 59% capacity. [00:42:32] Is there something magic about the Concord, [00:42:35] where it's circled? [00:42:37] Like, can you just? [00:42:38] Yes. [00:42:39] I'm gonna lie down here and explain that. [00:42:40] Yes. [00:42:41] Because if you just shift it to the left, [00:42:43] then that would solve it. [00:42:45] So you mean, like, [00:42:46] why do we draw lines at the Concord? [00:42:48] Right, why can't you just shift it? [00:42:50] To? [00:42:51] To, like, Choteau Road or something. [00:42:53] I gotcha. [00:42:54] So the, [00:42:56] there's nothing magical about the roundabout itself. [00:42:59] But when you look at the Choteau Peninsula, [00:43:01] from my perspective, [00:43:03] there is, [00:43:05] it's basically like, [00:43:07] it's on, [00:43:08] it's a crosshairs, right? [00:43:09] Or at least I think of it. [00:43:10] You have it divided in half [00:43:11] by North Shore Drive coming through, [00:43:12] and then you have [00:43:13] North to South via Choteau Road. [00:43:15] So, [00:43:16] it doesn't, [00:43:17] like, it makes more sense [00:43:18] to me from a logistical standpoint [00:43:20] to take all of it rather than one quadrant [00:43:22] or another quadrant. [00:43:24] Because I'm still running buses the same amount. [00:43:26] We're still, [00:43:27] if we're looking to, [00:43:28] to use Ms. Lautner's term, [00:43:29] purify a feeder pattern, [00:43:31] those kids that are on that, [00:43:32] let's say we take the northern half of the peninsula [00:43:34] and we, [00:43:35] and take it to Farragut [00:43:36] and leave the southern half at North Shore, [00:43:38] the kids in the southern half of that, [00:43:40] of that, [00:43:41] the Choteau Peninsula [00:43:42] don't have that same purity. [00:43:44] So there is a, [00:43:45] like, there's a lot of reasons why it, [00:43:47] at least to me, [00:43:48] it makes sense to move it as a whole. [00:43:50] If you don't agree, [00:43:51] by all means, [00:43:52] please tell us. [00:43:53] Like, give us your reasons. [00:43:54] Like, I'm not, [00:43:55] like, [00:43:56] I'm not the fount of all good ideas. [00:43:58] And so, like, if you don't, [00:43:59] like, if you don't like what we put together, [00:44:00] you don't like one of the things that I've said, [00:44:02] like, by all means, [00:44:03] bring that to the forefront. [00:44:04] Like, tell us your reasons. [00:44:05] Y'all live this stuff. [00:44:06] Like, I'm looking, [00:44:07] I, [00:44:08] I've lived in Knoxville my entire life. [00:44:09] I have a lot of experience, [00:44:10] although I am a bearded high school graduate. [00:44:11] I'm about to die. [00:44:12] I have a, [00:44:13] I have a lot of experience, [00:44:14] like, being here, [00:44:15] being in the community. [00:44:16] My family is here. [00:44:17] I have, [00:44:18] but that's not the same thing [00:44:19] as driving Choteau Road every single day. [00:44:20] And so, like, [00:44:21] and I don't want to try to substitute one for the other. [00:44:22] So please, [00:44:23] like, [00:44:24] let us know about that sort of stuff. [00:44:25] Thank you all for this presentation [00:44:26] on thought and statistics and geography. [00:44:27] We want to do it. [00:44:31] And, [00:44:32] and, [00:44:33] and, [00:44:34] I do echo the gentleman over there. [00:44:39] I, [00:44:40] it's tough. [00:44:41] You guys have three presentations this week. [00:44:42] It's Thanksgiving the next week. [00:44:43] And then the week after, [00:44:44] you're presenting this to the board. [00:44:45] So that seems like a really tough timeline [00:44:46] to aggregate all of this data and commentary. [00:44:47] But, [00:44:48] but my question is, [00:44:49] I live in Concord Hills. [00:44:50] And so, [00:44:51] I live, [00:44:52] just about six months ago, [00:44:53] there were two giant pillars [00:44:54] put outside my neighborhood [00:44:55] that say, [00:44:56] Ferry Town Center. [00:44:57] And, [00:44:58] and, [00:44:59] and, [00:45:00] and, [00:45:01] and, [00:45:02] and, [00:45:03] and, [00:45:04] and here we were. [00:45:05] I'm in the town of Farragut. [00:45:06] I live on a street called [00:45:07] Farragut Surprise Passage Boulevard in [00:45:08] I live on a street called [00:45:09] Farragut Collection Center [00:45:11] I live on a street called [00:45:12] Farragut Hill's Boulevard. [00:45:14] And so, [00:45:15] there is a strong sense of [00:45:16] Farragut community. [00:45:17] And, [00:45:18] and now we have three schools [00:45:19] in the town of Farragut [00:45:20] that we are trying to deal with. [00:45:22] And so, [00:45:23] Scenarios 1 and 2 [00:45:24] make a lot of sense [00:45:25] to me. [00:45:26] But Scenarios, [00:45:27] I mean Scenarios 1 and 3 [00:45:28] make a lot of, [00:45:29] Scenario 2, [00:45:30] Concord Hills, [00:45:31] which is in Washington [00:45:32] our television school. [00:45:33] System 10. [00:45:34] So where is the factor of community relationship and history factoring to the statistical analysis [00:45:47] that are on these maps because it doesn't make a lot of sense for a remote area in partner [00:45:52] valley to be green for the intermediate school when I'm getting shipped off to Pellissippi [00:45:56] in the morning square. [00:45:59] What I would say is that that value that you're expressing, that community value, it comes [00:46:05] out here. [00:46:06] So when I said at the beginning, you know, these are scenarios to start a conversation, [00:46:10] this was an exercise in showing what it takes to create the numbers and the patterns that [00:46:16] can generate the relief we need to use. [00:46:18] That doesn't mean that it's right for every single community. [00:46:22] And so please flag that. [00:46:24] That's a suspicion that we have, right? [00:46:26] We felt like it was going to be validated very, very quickly. [00:46:29] You just did. [00:46:30] But I would still encourage you and those of your neighbors who are affected as well [00:46:35] to make use of the survey to validate our thinking in that space. [00:46:39] And that's exactly what we want to do with every single one of these scenarios. [00:46:42] Phenomenal question. [00:46:43] Thank you. [00:46:45] We live on Fox Road. [00:46:58] So Fox Road is kind of in a weird area because we are, and my husband went to these schools, [00:47:05] this exact. [00:47:06] So AOI is West Valley and then Farragut High School. [00:47:09] So sending us to North Shore and then we would go to West Valley, but then we would go back [00:47:18] to Farragut. [00:47:19] Like, how does that? [00:47:21] You all actually are queuing up in symmetrical ways. [00:47:27] So we anticipated hearing this from a portion of Farragut-Concord Hills that we were talking [00:47:32] about just a moment ago. [00:47:33] And we also anticipated potentially hearing this as well. [00:47:36] And it is something that we were curious about. [00:47:38] And so if you're saying, you know what, I understand the bigger picture of what's happening, [00:47:43] but Farragut feels like a more right fit because I want a version of that purity. [00:47:48] We can't guarantee that we can accommodate anything that is shared, but we do want to [00:47:53] hear that because we also aren't guaranteed that we can accommodate that. [00:47:57] So please let us know. [00:47:58] Why is that one road, though? [00:48:00] Like, with everything else, it splits Pellissippi. [00:48:03] But with Fox Road, it's... [00:48:05] Math, kids, number of students. [00:48:09] So it was... [00:48:10] There's an element in every single one of these exercises where the... [00:48:15] I went back to, like, our methodology at the very beginning. [00:48:18] And one of the things that I said is sometimes these things are in tension with one another. [00:48:21] We can't always deliver on all of them. [00:48:23] This is one of the examples of we can't always deliver on all of them. [00:48:26] Because at a certain point, what we're trying to do is make sure that we don't have too [00:48:29] many kids in the building. [00:48:30] And so going through that exercise, sometimes you have to make moves to try to make sure [00:48:35] that we don't have too many kids in the building. [00:48:36] And so we try to achieve that goal that they are... [00:48:37] Like, it does create a new fear pattern, like you're talking about. [00:48:38] It's talking about making an impactful change to these families over here, not something [00:48:39] that, you know, we want to do, but that's where the numbers last. [00:48:40] So, again, I would say, like, that's an excellent point. [00:48:41] That's a great, great thing to bring up. [00:48:42] It is a thing that I had in the back of my head while we were doing this. [00:48:43] And so, you know, as Corey said, like, sort of validation from the community that y'all... [00:48:44] Because, again, I'm not trying to substitute my experience. [00:48:45] I'm not trying to substitute my experience. [00:48:46] I'm not trying to substitute my experience. [00:48:47] I'm not trying to substitute my experience. [00:48:48] I'm not trying to substitute my experience. [00:48:49] So, like, please let us know about that. [00:48:50] Let us know your concerns about that. [00:48:51] Let us know, you know, how that feels, how, you know, when you sit in it, like, where [00:48:52] you are with that. [00:48:53] Because we do weigh those things highly. [00:48:54] Like, we've talked a lot about the fact that, you know, we're not going to be able to do [00:48:55] that. [00:48:56] We're not going to be able to do that. [00:48:57] And so, again, I would say, like, that's an excellent point. [00:48:58] That's a great, great thing to bring up. [00:48:59] It is a thing that I had in the back of my head while we were doing this. [00:49:00] And so, you know, as Corey said, like, sort of validation from the community that y'all... [00:49:01] Because, again, I'm not trying to substitute my experiences for yours. [00:49:02] So, like, please let us know about that. [00:49:03] Let us know your concerns about that. [00:49:04] Let us know, you know, how that feels, how, you know, when you sit in it, like, where [00:49:05] you are with that. [00:49:06] Because, like, we do weigh those things highly. [00:49:07] Like, we've talked a lot about the fact that, you know, we have to make the best long-term [00:49:08] decision for the district. [00:49:09] And that's true. [00:49:10] But that doesn't mean that we don't pay attention to things that aren't numbers and dollar signs. [00:49:11] Like, our business is kids. [00:49:12] Our business is serving families. [00:49:13] Like, this is what we are here for. [00:49:14] Like, she can go see a doctor. [00:49:15] She can go see a nurse. [00:49:16] She can go see a nurse. [00:49:17] She can go see a nurse. [00:49:18] She can go see a nurse. [00:49:19] She can go see a nurse. [00:49:20] She can go see a nurse. [00:49:21] She can go see a nurse. [00:49:22] She can go see a nurse. [00:49:23] She can go see a nurse. [00:49:24] And all of that, she can go see a doctor. [00:49:25] And all of that can be done. [00:49:26] And we have to make sure that, like, we have the best decision for the district. [00:49:27] And that's true. [00:49:28] But that doesn't mean that we don't pay attention to things that aren't numbers and dollar signs. [00:49:29] Like, our business is kids. [00:49:30] Our business is serving families. [00:49:31] Like, this is what we are here for. [00:49:32] Like, she could go somewhere else and make a whole lot more money than she is right now. [00:49:33] But she does this because she cares about the mission that we share. [00:49:34] And so, like, your lived experience, like, how you feel about these things, does carry [00:49:35] a lot of weight with us when we're going through this process. [00:49:36] this because she cares about the mission that we share and so that your lived experience like how [00:49:42] you feel about these things does carry a lot of weight with us and i'll share kind of in practice [00:49:49] because uh the previous speaker actually gave us an opportunity um to kind of highlight how this [00:49:53] might work so let's say um you know we hear that there's this this um right on north shore drive [00:50:01] that is maybe um west sorry my cardinal directions correct here west of that concord [00:50:10] um roundabout right that's saying you know what i realize that you're taking us here because of [00:50:14] this path but really it makes more sense for us to stay in north shore if there's a way for us [00:50:18] to accommodate that what that does essentially is it takes some kiddos that we had previously [00:50:22] mathematically accounted for going to that new school now they're not there right so that might [00:50:27] give us an opportunity to permutate within these lines that are in the farragut area [00:50:31] we do that then maybe we can accommodate this right and so when we say we need this feedback [00:50:37] we need this feedback because every single one is going to pull on one or another end of a strand [00:50:44] mathematically it does need to work out right we need to believe that we are creating enough [00:50:48] capacity for us to feel like we're making a good decision by 2030 and beyond but it doesn't mean [00:50:55] that it has to be the decisions one of the three that are on the board here so yes thank you so [00:50:59] much for sharing that can't i'm guaranteed that we can honor it [00:51:01] we can definitely guarantee that we'll try hi good evening uh thank you as everybody else said [00:51:09] for your time this evening um my questions i'm a concord girls resident as well ironically [00:51:14] um my questions initially went to kind of sense of community um but i don't question [00:51:22] on that um i thought to kind of go to another issue that i think is on the mind of all of us [00:51:27] that are kind of very residents that stand out like this is outside of the country [00:51:35] there is those of us who reside in the town of france we purchased our games in large part [00:51:41] because we want to consume four schools within the county [00:51:46] you know obviously scenario two i think this has resulted in a lot of kids within concord hills [00:51:51] and other areas moving to north shore so my question is to what extent have you taken into [00:51:58] account the potential negative financial impacts of that decision we've definitely anticipated that [00:52:06] But again, you know, fill it out in the survey. [00:52:09] That's why we're going to continue to direct everyone back. [00:52:11] You're validating thinking that we have in that regard. [00:52:14] And this was, again, that conversation starter [00:52:17] just to say, help us contextualize what this would do for you and your community. [00:52:21] So I appreciate you sharing that. [00:52:23] I would also encourage you to just drop it onto the survey. [00:52:25] This is also a great opportunity for me to plug on the survey [00:52:29] that none of the fields are mandatory. [00:52:31] So there's one mandatory field and it's tell us what school community [00:52:35] you're in, because it does affect the questions that you receive access to. [00:52:38] But beyond that, don't feel like you have to go through [00:52:41] and comment on every single scenario. [00:52:43] There is one that you have insight on that you think we need to know. [00:52:47] Feel free to skip all the others. [00:52:48] Just tell us what you think we need to know. [00:52:50] And so please take advantage of that. [00:52:52] In terms of a K through five school, [00:53:04] are there plans to do anything to make it more K through five friendly? [00:53:09] Right now, there's only four bathrooms in the entire building, and [00:53:14] there's no classroom to bathroom door access like it generally is. [00:53:27] He got a pass, but I can see him back there. [00:53:30] And I want to see if he would like to take this question. [00:53:33] I would say just to give him some time to make a decision [00:53:37] as to whether he'd like to walk up here or not. [00:53:40] What I would say in the interim is that the next phase in all this work [00:53:44] is to really begin working with the principals or principals [00:53:47] have already been thinking about this conversion, preparing for this conversion, [00:53:52] because there's more that needs to happen than just facilities. [00:53:55] I appreciate you labeling that, but this is a big move on behalf of those two schools. [00:53:59] So there are a lot of things that need to be true of facilities [00:54:04] to be prepared to accommodate that new grade band. [00:54:07] By merit of being an elementary school and having served elementary school [00:54:11] students, we're not anticipating a lot of change. [00:54:15] But I will turn it over to Dr. Adams, who's acquired a microphone. [00:54:18] Good evening, everyone. [00:54:20] I got a pass because I'm at the first. [00:54:21] Very good meeting. [00:54:22] So I got a pass tonight. [00:54:24] Thank you all for your input. [00:54:26] That's a great question. [00:54:27] I will say Mr. [00:54:27] Shover, our executive director of facilities and new construction, [00:54:32] he didn't walk the building. [00:54:33] We looked at that. [00:54:33] That's something that we're going to work with the building level principals [00:54:36] once we get to that point. [00:54:38] There's a programing piece that comes in that's involved in that. [00:54:41] I will say the elementary schools and the primary schools are pretty much standard. [00:54:47] But again, we'll evaluate that. [00:54:49] A lot of that has to do with scheduling. [00:54:51] There's a scheduling piece. [00:54:51] I know that because I'm a former principal. [00:54:54] Middle school and high school, not elementary, but again, we'll work with principals to ensure [00:54:58] that they designate the necessary classrooms in close proximity to the restrooms. [00:55:03] I believe that was your question. [00:55:06] There's only four bathrooms. [00:55:07] Designating the classrooms to be in closer proximity to the restrooms. [00:55:11] But there's no plan to add restrooms for the current restrooms. [00:55:17] I have a first grader as well as a third grader and an eighth grader. [00:55:22] But when my first grader comes in, I'm not going to be able to do that. [00:55:22] But when my first grader goes to the school to do things and pick up her brother, [00:55:26] I know that the toilets are universal. [00:55:30] But it's not as universal as she probably would have liked it to be. [00:55:37] I'm the PTO president also. [00:55:39] And we're currently raising funds for stools for the toilets. [00:55:46] That just seems odd that there's not a plan for toilets. [00:55:52] So, again, I'll go back to the conversation we had when we looked at this originally. [00:55:57] The standard for elementary and primary, there's no difference in the standard. [00:56:01] There may have been, correct me if I'm wrong, Mr. Shover, there may have been something in the past, the current standards for elementary and primary, there's no difference. [00:56:09] Is that correct? [00:56:12] Historically, there was some limited difference in stool height and height with mode across the system and actually across the industry. [00:56:20] That has gone away because it doesn't really exist anywhere else in the world that that child is at. [00:56:26] If they're at McDonald's, if they're at their house, wherever they are, those things don't exist there either. [00:56:31] And what it starts to do is limit the flexibility of how that building can be used in the future. [00:56:36] So if you all didn't hear, basically what he said, historically, there was a difference. [00:56:41] The current standard, and that's the industry standard across the board, whether it's schools or whether it's commercial, the standard is what it is for elementary school. [00:56:50] So essentially, what we would be looking at is just making sure that the quality of experience is commensurate with what you would see across other elementary schools. [00:57:00] We do have K-5 elementary schools that don't have maybe that degree of difference that maybe we've previously experienced by Meredith having been at a primary school in Finn, a fully formed primary school. [00:57:14] As we continue to grow with that facility, if there are commodes that are probably smaller. [00:57:20] Then they need to be, I could see us, you know, upsizing over time, but we wouldn't be investing capital to bring us up to a standard that is above and beyond what is reflected across the county. [00:57:33] And I would just like to add to that, when we do our capital improvement plan, it's on a five-year trajectory. [00:57:38] So when we look at that, we don't have any current dollars for the intermediate or the primary, which will be the new, which will be converted to K-5. [00:57:48] So those schools will be basically. [00:57:50] Okay, but students would not be accessing facilities in an elementary school space that other elementary schoolers are not accessing. [00:58:01] So that standard of experience is what we would be looking for. [00:58:05] Would it be identical to what the primary school versus the intermediate had? [00:58:09] Maybe not, but would we be asking one or the other to do something that other elementary schools across the district are not being asked to do now? [00:58:18] I will just add. [00:58:19] I will just add. [00:58:20] We do look at furnishings, and again, we'll work directly with the building level principal if that's a need in the school. [00:58:26] Okay. [00:58:28] Question not about toilets. [00:58:31] So with the numbers in all of the scenarios, a lot of those schools, their capacity is definitely below 80%, and a lot of their total capacity numbers are below 800. [00:58:43] What is that going to do for staffing and elimination of staffing positions? [00:58:48] So same number of students. [00:58:50] It's distributed in a different way, right? [00:58:53] So elimination of positions, that's not really something we're worried about. [00:58:57] Redistribution of positions, potentially. [00:59:00] Now, what I will say, actually, which is, again, something we'll have to grapple with, but we think is worthwhile in adding to the conversation, there may be some addition of positions we'll need to consider as a district if we pursue a very generous transfer offer. [00:59:15] So if we pursue a very generous transfer offer, what that does for us, essentially, is it. [00:59:20] It means we need to do a little bit of preliminary staffing, assuming families are moving with their zone pattern, but there's also some buffering that will need to be done to potentially account for that opportunity and that choice to remain in the school. [00:59:35] So depending on the extent of the transfer that we offer, there may not be very much transition at all of staffing. [00:59:42] If there is a large transfer offered and a high appetite for that transfer, essentially what that would look like is that. [00:59:50] Like that attrition over time, what we would hope to do with that is map that attrition to future zoning in so that we could eliminate the fluidity in the staffing, right? [01:00:02] We know having staff work together, know each other, get used to one another's routines, that creates a phenomenal work environment, a phenomenal learning environment. [01:00:12] We want to preserve that to the extent possible. [01:00:14] We think a generous transfer offer could potentially help us navigate some of that potential volatility. [01:00:20] While we're also planning for years out in a transfer, again, that's specific to scenario three. [01:00:27] Scenario two, that would almost, not scenario two, scenario one, that would almost definitely be a movement of staff to follow students, essentially, is what would happen in that regard. [01:00:38] So we would see students exiting a facility, maybe have some transfers to potentially remain behind, be able to weather that a little bit, but more than likely see staffing following those students into that new space. [01:00:49] We do have. [01:00:50] We do have a new facility opening that will need to be fully staffed, and that's why we're not worried about elimination of positions. [01:00:57] Yeah, not just the teacher staffing, but guidance counselors, and then STEM. [01:01:01] I see on the map that Sequoia is 100 over their 80% capacity, but they already lost their STEM. [01:01:08] So what's that mean for North Shore if they drop even lower? [01:01:13] Is there a chance that programs that they have will go away? [01:01:18] I'm not in touch with that. [01:01:19] No, I do. [01:01:20] I'm not in touch with that. [01:01:20] So those related arts classes, those are largely constrained to that homeroom allocation, so their allocation map is a little bit different than just straight enrollment of a school, right? [01:01:31] So I would say a lot of that just depends on what we offer from a transfer standpoint, how much of that is taken advantage of, and then really what we anticipate as a secondary or a tertiary step. [01:01:43] If we know more rezoning is coming, and really it's a one-year gap in time, there's... [01:01:50] A lot we can potentially do to try to be conscientious of that. [01:01:54] And so that's, again, why we want to have this conversation as early as possible, so we can start thinking about how do we minimize the amount of disruption, both for our families, but also for our staff as well. [01:02:05] It's contingent on locking in on a decision, which is why it sounds like there's a lot of I don't know right now. [01:02:10] Every single one of these scenarios would generate a different answer to that question. [01:02:15] Our commitment would be to try to eliminate the amount of change. [01:02:20] It's not possible. [01:02:21] Thank you. [01:02:22] Thank you. [01:02:23] Hi. [01:02:28] Thanks for your time tonight. [01:02:29] My concern with all three scenarios is that all students that will be attending Farragut Primary would eventually be split in half between two different leader school paths, half will go to Farragut Middle and High, and half will go to Karn Valley Middle and High. [01:02:44] So all students will be losing half of their friends to a different leader school. [01:02:49] You said all three scenarios? [01:02:51] Yeah. [01:02:52] It looks like all three scenarios with a... [01:02:54] I'll let Ryan speak to that. [01:02:55] That's definitely true for scenario one. [01:02:56] It might be true for a version of scenario two. [01:02:57] Scenario three gets us a lot of inter-pattern parity within the Farragut area, as well as [01:02:58] for our students who also may be impacted for North Shore and for a lot. [01:02:59] Do you want to speak to that a little bit more? [01:03:00] Sure. [01:03:01] Scenario one and two, there are students that are currently zoned to Hardin Valley that [01:03:02] will come to K-Farragut School. [01:03:03] I think they will go to Hardin Valley Middle and High. [01:03:04] I think they will go to K-Farragut School. [01:03:05] I think they will go to K-Farragut School. [01:03:06] I think they will go to K-Farragut School. [01:03:07] I think they will go to K-Farragut School. [01:03:08] There isn't... [01:03:09] Scenario three doesn't address Hardin Valley at all, so that one... [01:03:10] To your example of students... [01:03:11] Because it doesn't affect that school. [01:03:12] So you're saying scenario three all students will be zoned to K-Farragut School. [01:03:13] That's the first scenario. [01:03:14] Yeah. [01:03:15] Scenario three. [01:03:16] Scenario four. [01:03:17] Scenario five. [01:03:18] That's definitely one in the North Shore area that needs to be zoned to Hardin Valley Middle. [01:03:19] Scenario six. [01:03:20] Scenario seven. [01:03:21] That's the first scenario. [01:03:22] That's the first scenario, the one I looked at. [01:03:23] And there are a lot of students in that area as well as in the Farragut area as well as [01:03:24] for students who also may be impacted for North Shore and for a lot. [01:03:25] Do you want to speak to that a little bit more? [01:03:26] Sure. [01:03:27] address our primary law. So that one, to your example, students wouldn't be able to because it doesn't affect the school. [01:03:36] So you're saying scenario three, all students that would be zoned for Farragut Primary would be going to Farragut Middle and High? [01:03:47] I'm going to walk that through. [01:03:48] That's a great point. I would say that this is true for the impacted families. So for families that are zoned for Farragut Primary or Intermediate, [01:04:07] that's the same zoning pattern, who may be in to at Hard Valley Middle or Academy, we're talking about those students. [01:04:15] Like currently there are kids that are in Farragut Primary and Intermediate. [01:04:18] Is that what you were talking about? If that's what you were talking about, yes, that would be true. [01:04:23] But that would not be a new zoning pattern, that would just be a preserved zoning pattern. [01:04:28] I was just looking at the new Farragut Primary, would most students be going to on to Farragut Middle and High? [01:04:37] Yes. [01:04:38] So, yeah, most students will. Like if you look at this map up here, the portion of the yellow Farragut zone that is north of I-40, [01:04:45] those kids currently go to Farragut Primary and Intermediate and then go to Hard Valley Middle and Hard Valley Academy. [01:04:51] That is still going to be true. [01:04:53] Okay, it looks like that it would be split between Hard Valley and Farragut Primary. [01:05:05] Scenario three would not impact any Hard Valley Elementary school. [01:05:16] Good evening. [01:05:17] I appreciate the opportunity for all of us to be seen and heard tonight. [01:05:22] Originally, I had resolved that I wasn't going to have anything to say this evening because my youngest is a fourth grader. [01:05:27] And I thought, you know, respectfully, you could say, girl, you don't have a dog in this fight, sit down. [01:05:32] However, as the girl who attended Farragut K-12, as the mom who once her family moved across the country to California, [01:05:40] moved back and purchased her childhood home from her parents so her kids could follow in her footsteps, [01:05:46] as a woman that was a former Farragut ATO president and was very well connected with this community and with the staff, [01:05:52] I would be remiss if I didn't have something to say tonight. [01:05:55] So I would just like to take a step back to all those previous meetings from the years past, [01:06:02] where, admittedly, I was entirely way too involved in the process. [01:06:06] I had a lot of research, attended every single town hall, community meeting, school board meeting, all of the things. [01:06:12] While I could pull up screenshots on my phone, [01:06:15] or while I could point out people in the room and say, this was said on social media, [01:06:20] or this was said to our faces, I'm not going to do that. [01:06:24] But I am going to go ahead and speak for all of us in the room that had been present at those meetings when I say, [01:06:30] what we had all heard was that all of this concerning the new school would only affect kids currently at Farragut schools. [01:06:42] There won't be any rezoning at North Shore. [01:06:48] We were told that kids from A.L. Watts and Hardin Valley wouldn't be pulled into this. [01:06:51] It was only going to alleviate the issues at Farragut because Farragut was where the overcrowding was happening. [01:06:57] We're trying to get the portables out, all of that. [01:07:00] So while I completely understand the Knox County community as a whole, [01:07:05] the ideas of, hey, there's growth, this and this, don't even get me started on can we just stop building. [01:07:11] I know it sounds very get off my lawn, but am I wrong? [01:07:15] Okay. [01:07:16] Yeah. [01:07:17] I don't see how all of this is now, quote unquote, our problem. [01:07:25] I mean, we were told. [01:07:27] I don't want to say we were lied to. [01:07:29] I don't want to say we were just placated so that the meetings could end. [01:07:32] But I feel like there's been a little bit of context that's missing or some clarification I don't have. [01:07:39] So I'm just curious to know how we got to this point that now we're talking about not just Farragut. [01:07:47] Good evening, Josh. [01:07:48] Good evening, Jessica. [01:07:52] Good evening. [01:07:53] You spent a lot of time together in those meetings. [01:07:54] Farragut. [01:07:55] Good to see you. [01:07:56] So I will own that 100 percent. [01:07:57] So we want to be good stewards of taxpayers' dollars and one of the reasons we built the [01:08:02] largest elementary school in the town of Farragut area was because of the projected growth. [01:08:07] There was a significant decline in growth over the past, what, year or two? [01:08:13] Three years? [01:08:15] Six? [01:08:16] Seven? [01:08:17] Eight? [01:08:18] Nine? [01:08:19] Ten? [01:08:20] significant decline so what would it look like we were looking at zero point is it 0.01 accuracy [01:08:30] for so for the projections it was 0.01 so we saw an anomaly in the past two or three years so [01:08:37] there was a significant decline in growth and you look at our other areas there was a significant [01:08:43] increase in growth is that just through k-5 or is that through k-12 k-5 especially right right so [01:08:50] our elementary you look at our middle schools the majority of our middle schools are fine majority [01:08:55] of our high schools are fine there are some high schools we're encroaching in middle schools [01:08:59] but elementary in certain areas it's a problem we just you've seen the rezoning we did in the [01:09:05] community the power community and so forth so that is the reason right so the intention was [01:09:11] to capture the growth within the town of [01:09:14] reality was it shared an office so to answer your question like i own that 100 [01:09:19] it's one of the reasons we want to build the largest elementary school because we [01:09:22] wanted to account for that growth it just didn't happen that way so i appreciate that [01:09:28] second part to my question you might just want to keep in mind because um [01:09:34] i'm just going to call out the other friends in the room because i know that [01:09:37] a lot of us in the community have had these discussions as well as i know for a fact that [01:09:42] i've had these [01:09:43] discussions with a lot of staff at both FPS and FIS. [01:09:47] And when we started talking about this whole [01:09:50] having multiple schools within Farragut, [01:09:53] there had been a concern about [01:09:55] what will the rezoning look like? [01:09:57] Where will those lines be drawn? [01:09:59] And how will we make sure that beautiful Farragut, [01:10:02] the amazing melting pot that it is, [01:10:05] was not gonna have lines drawn that send kids to school [01:10:08] where, if you just look at it, [01:10:10] I'm just gonna call it what it is, [01:10:11] it looks like it's socio-economic division. [01:10:13] It looks as if all of these people [01:10:16] going to the bigger houses over here [01:10:18] and they're paying all the money, [01:10:19] they're going to the new build. [01:10:20] And these houses here, when I went to Farragut, [01:10:24] it was like you had the kids that lived in the big house [01:10:26] off-tour, sitting in a desk next to the kid [01:10:28] that did live in the trailer [01:10:29] on the other side of North Campbell Station. [01:10:31] And I know that sounds crass, [01:10:32] I like the generalization, [01:10:33] but I'm just gonna call it what it is, okay? [01:10:35] I pulled up those maps, I zoomed in, I looked at things. [01:10:38] It's 2026 and we're trying to move forward in a novel way. [01:10:43] Let's not take a step back and put ourselves [01:10:45] in a situation where it almost looks like [01:10:47] the schools in Farragut are possibly segregated [01:10:50] for a variety of reasons. [01:10:52] I would mention that [01:10:56] as a very honest answer. [01:10:57] If you look at the history of Knox County Schools, [01:11:00] when you look at the zoning, it's all over the place. [01:11:03] There's cutouts, it's not pure. [01:11:05] Mr. Dillingham has done an exceptional job [01:11:08] of one, having clean zoning lines, [01:11:10] and two, trying to clean up the figure patterns, right? [01:11:14] So there's a lot of things in the past, [01:11:15] if you look at the past pre-zoning, [01:11:18] the zones don't make any sense. [01:11:20] If you look at how he's cut out the zones [01:11:24] in the zoning lines, they actually make sense, right? [01:11:27] So I understand where you're coming from and your concerns. [01:11:30] I can assure you that was not taken into consideration. [01:11:33] Okay, I actually, can I add to that too, [01:11:35] just to say that one, if you see blind spots on these maps, [01:11:40] please let us know, we want to know that. [01:11:42] What we would not do, I'm gonna come over here [01:11:44] because this is a very good area, right? [01:11:46] What we would not do, and we've had this question asked, [01:11:49] right, why don't you take, [01:11:51] and I'm picking arbitrary squares, essentially, right? [01:11:55] Why don't you take this area and send it around [01:11:58] past these guys so that we can socioeconomically [01:12:02] balance the school, right? [01:12:04] We've actually been asked to do the opposite, right? [01:12:06] Let's create zoning lines that take areas of affluence, [01:12:10] with areas that maybe are not as affluent, [01:12:14] to be able to balance that school community. [01:12:17] One, that's not a geographically, you know, [01:12:20] sound practice, that's not a great answer, right? [01:12:22] The reality of the reason we don't do that [01:12:25] is essentially that the affluence of a community [01:12:28] changes over time, right? [01:12:30] So you have areas that appreciate, [01:12:32] you have areas that depreciate, [01:12:34] and I would also say, the moment we illustrate [01:12:37] that we could potentially do that, [01:12:38] that we could take an affluence [01:12:40] balancing approach. It also means we can do exactly what you're warning us against and [01:12:44] we don't want to do. So what we've done and what, and I will echo Dr. Adams, what Mr. [01:12:49] Dillingham has done, and I would say very, very ardently and with aplomb, is say we're [01:12:54] going to take a strictly geographic and numeric approach so that we can justify those lines. [01:13:00] Again, if you see blind spots, we want to hear those, but that is how these lines were [01:13:04] governed. Thank you for that. [01:13:06] I fundamentally don't believe that your zip code determines your academic outcomes. [01:13:10] I don't care how rich you are or how poor you are. That doesn't tell me your aptitude [01:13:14] to learn. It doesn't tell me what kind of student you can be. It doesn't tell me anything [01:13:17] about your trajectory in life. And to pretend otherwise, to draw zone lines otherwise, I [01:13:23] think is a fallacy. So, and I'm not, I hope this doesn't come across as mad if you're [01:13:30] struggling about this, and this is the way that I am doing these things. [01:13:33] I'm not saying that that's what you said. [01:13:35] No, no, no. [01:13:36] I'm just saying that for all of us that have no real information parameter with me, [01:13:40] right, because none of us have seen any of this stuff, when you've heard bits and pieces [01:13:45] from other people and then you come in and you see it's on its face and you just look [01:13:48] at how it is, I mean, does that make sense? [01:13:51] No, and actually, I would say that's part of why we want so badly, and I know this was [01:13:55] not a popular decision, right, to hold these conversations until we have them in person, [01:14:01] right, because you get those maps pulled. There's a lot of assumptions that can be made [01:14:05] when we don't have an opportunity to have that exchange, so I appreciate you saying [01:14:08] that, so that we can have that exchange. [01:14:10] Sure, thank you. [01:14:11] Yeah, as somebody with spiritual discernment and also a wild imagination that can come [01:14:16] up with a conspiracy theory like that, I would much rather get clarification and just hear [01:14:21] you all say what you have to say, versus just creating a mirror right there with you. [01:14:25] Yeah, I appreciate it. [01:14:26] Thank you. [01:14:27] Thank you for your time. [01:14:28] Thank you for answering, for your time this evening. [01:14:35] It's almost like playing with what I can't imagine. [01:14:37] I can't imagine how long that has taken. [01:14:39] Justin, it's funny too. [01:14:44] Thank you. [01:14:45] We're going to make a lot of stickers after this. [01:14:47] Yeah. [01:14:48] I survived every single one of those. [01:14:50] I think many people have hit on a similar topic of we look very good, we look mature, [01:14:57] we're proud of this area. [01:14:59] I moved here in 2019, and honestly, I grew up in a school system that I would not ever [01:15:05] allow my children to grow up in. [01:15:07] I'm very proud. [01:15:08] Let's say very proud. [01:15:09] When I see arrowheads coming into this area, my alarm goes off because I think, have you [01:15:14] guys been on roads and seen what we're dealing with already? [01:15:15] Every day. [01:15:16] I'm sorry. [01:15:17] Every day. [01:15:18] Yes. [01:15:19] Says the bus guy. [01:15:20] And I know that there's many other areas like that, but if we're specifically talking [01:15:21] about Farragut, and we're looking, and we're making these adjustments, we're looking at [01:15:22] a lot of different things. [01:15:23] Yeah. [01:15:24] Yeah. [01:15:25] Yeah. [01:15:26] Yeah. [01:15:27] Yeah. [01:15:28] Yeah. [01:15:29] Yeah. [01:15:30] Yeah. [01:15:31] Yeah. [01:15:32] Yeah. [01:15:33] Yeah. [01:15:34] Yeah. [01:15:35] Yeah. [01:15:36] Yeah. [01:15:37] Enough policy stuff thatALDMPZM seems to add a little bit of this to it, like one [01:15:38] thing with our zoning, and we're adding people to this area. [01:15:39] It doesn't make sense to me and I don't know the capacity these new apartment complex is [01:15:40] going to take, but let's estimate that the one behind Kroger is going to occupy 600 people? [01:15:41] I don't know. [01:15:42] Because I'm not studying this stuff, my mother and four children and all of the place, [01:15:58] you know, but if I look at these things. [01:16:06] And we know that's going to add additional traffic, additional community members, to think that we're pulling more people into our system doesn't make sense to me at all. [01:16:17] And the people of these areas are very proud to live here and very happy here. [01:16:21] So when I look at this map here, I think, okay, you look at Heart of Valley, you've got a plus 120. [01:16:25] Has there been any consideration to just rotate like Heart of Valley, that eastern portion of Heart of Valley? [01:16:37] Have we considered moving the bed into a free fall camp scene of love? [01:16:42] Yes. [01:16:43] Because you have, in that area, if you add the space that they have, that's a plus 170 in Heart of Valley. [01:16:50] Is that a... [01:16:53] It works. [01:16:53] I'm sorry. [01:16:54] So, you know, once... [01:16:55] Plus 120, so then Heart of Valley is actually negative 50 at that point. [01:17:01] And I could go on with the mathematics that could continue to make sense. [01:17:05] So has that been a consideration to move that rezoning, your mill group in Heart of Valley? [01:17:11] Especially when you're talking about, okay, I've got a 10-year plan. [01:17:15] I've got the financial portion of that plan. [01:17:18] But if you are considering building a brick and mortar in Heart of Valley, that's also going to alleviate Heart of Valley. [01:17:25] So I... [01:17:25] I believe that with the additional community members coming to the fair area, our school is going to need that additional 420 capacity that we're trying to fill now. [01:17:37] So you then... [01:17:38] You see, I know it's a vicious cycle, but have you considered that? [01:17:41] Yes. [01:17:42] And I would say you actually identified a very likely secondary tertiary next step in that Heart of Valley area if scenario one or some version of scenario two doesn't make it to the board, right? [01:17:55] So what we're doing is we're illustrating that we could potentially provide some initial relief to Heart of Valley, and that would be helpful to us. [01:18:03] It's helpful to us because we know that additional developments going in are also going to be eating into that 114, that plus in the Mill Creek area. [01:18:11] It's just a more rapidly developing area. [01:18:14] Everywhere in West Knoxville, I will say this, West Knoxville is a rapidly developing sector of the county. [01:18:19] So we're up against that no matter what the rate at which Heart of Valley is developing. [01:18:25] Is the reason why that 114 we anticipate disappearing from the map just a little bit more rapidly than, say, the 450-some-odd seats in this Farragut area. [01:18:39] It's really just rate of development. [01:18:41] Some of that, it's a roll of the dice. [01:18:42] It's a gamble. [01:18:43] It's based on projections, conversations that we've had with the county. [01:18:47] But all of that is based on human choice, right, and just human patterns and who moves in with kids and who doesn't move in with kids. [01:18:54] But that's some of that concern. [01:18:55] So we've had some consideration there to say, yes, absolutely, we've considered that, and that would be one of the reasons why a long-term solution for us might be more advantageous to look on the other side of the map. [01:19:08] That being said, we've heard why looking at just the other side of the map feels unfair to the broader community, right, because there's some consternation there, too, and so that's why we're having both conversations to talk about the added traffic variant. [01:19:22] I'm going to let the traffic guy, or bus guy, have a little bit more time. [01:19:25] I'm going to stop at this as well. [01:19:26] One thing I do want to call out about scenario three in particular and then elements of scenario two is that we are talking about students who are already zoned for Farragut Middle and Farragut High. [01:19:39] So we're talking about families who are already buses to an extent that are already moving from an area we're discussing into an area we're discussing. [01:19:48] So there's some predictability there, right? [01:19:50] Now, when we're talking about moving Hardin Valley South, that does feel very different to me. [01:19:54] And I think you've labeled all. [01:19:55] The reasons why we've got some other opportunities to explore there. [01:19:59] Really, the reason we're having both conversations is just out of fairness to the entire West sector that we could do either. [01:20:06] One is more uncomfortable to one side of the community, and another is more uncomfortable to another side of the community. [01:20:11] But, yes, I mean, your opinions are heard, and your insight is felt, and we are considering that for sure.